Red Pen Rhetoric Analysis

Great Essays
Some people have been lucky enough to experience the privilege of being educated. Whether or not one has been educated, he or she knows education is an important life aspect because it allows people to learn valuable life lessons and skills. Everyone has their own views on which teaching style is the best, including Mr. Steve Wyrick. In an argumentative essay entitled, “Red-Pen Rhetoric: Looking at the Response to Student Writing in Freshman College Composition Courses,” graduate student and teacher assistant, Mr. Steven T. Wyrick, focuses on what he believes to be the best relationship between student and teacher. This relationship, known as co-constituency, is one that Wyrick believes will help students in writing courses to develop their …show more content…
His purpose is to inform instructors and students about the relationship they share, it is important for both to know about the relationship. Wyrick states how the first step of obtaining a co-constituent relationship is the consideration of “producing an essay in a writing course a rhetorical situation” (2). A rhetorical situation means that the student cannot only learn from the instructor, but the instructor can also learn from the student. Co-constituency is needed in order to allow a rhetorical situation to work, which is why Wyrick focuses an entire part of his paper to explaining what one is. Wyrick then focuses on how students should view their writing instructor as a sage. He believes that students must understand that the only way to improve their writing is by entering into “dialogue with those who have more experience writing” (5). The form of dialogue some teachers use is simply writing margin notes about the MUGS of a student’s paper, but not the actual content of the paper. While other methods of dialogue, such as conferencing, allow the student to think about the content of his or her paper, which will help him or her to develop a better academic

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    For the most part, our similarities such as goals, amount of comments, and the way comments are written and to praise or criticize became main points for students to learn to read and respond properly and adequately towards a student’s paper. Richard Straub’s reading is advice for students on what to do exactly when responding in order for them to manage a paper without to rely on the teacher; remember the teacher will not always be there to guide you. Writing in full statements and be serious on what you comment is what Richard Straub and I experienced with reading and responding. Small dull statements will lead the writer to nowhere near improving because he or she will be confused and not know what to do. Overall, Richard Straub experiences and mine are the same in terms on how each thing is being done and achieve the goal of helping the writer improve its…

    • 1134 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Boyles (2004), “teachers talk with students to monitor their progress as well as to set goals and help them solve problems” (p.75). Teachers should conduct writing conferences in order to assess and evaluate the writing progress of their students. The purpose of writing conferences is finding the strengths and weaknesses of their writing to improve and develop the skills the student already has. Depending on the students writing the teacher facilitates interventions to improve the students writing skills. Teachers should frequently plan writing conferences to check-in on their students and the progress they have made.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In writing, teachers should incorporate their expectations for student writing by using rubrics. Rubrics allow students to write while knowing what’s needed within their writing to develop a well-written piece. Not only does a rubric set the expectations for the students but it is also a learning tool. The students can use the rubric to help them organize their work understand important components of writing. (Saddler & Andrade, 2004,…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Guided Language Essay

    • 2305 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Writing is aimed to express feeling, thought, opinion, or argument of the writers especially students in this case. Moreover, writing also has aim to impress the readers’ attention of what have been written. 2.3 The definition of guided writing strategy According to Heinemann (2007), a guided writing is an essential strategy which provides students with the additional steps towards independent writing. In guided writing strategy, the teacher guides the students in group in the process of writing in order to provide support which can help them to improve their writing competency. Guided writing strategy can help students to transfer their ideas from plan into writing.…

    • 2305 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Outlines give me a better look on what my essay will look like and helps me to condense the information I must fit the essay I am writing. 2. I will develop college writing skills to write well-organized essays by rereading my text, myself as well as using peer review for editing and proofreading my work. I find this step in the writing process extremely helpful in figuring out what ideas I need to expand, or what part I may need to take out. My professor will ask the class to do peer-editing, and then the professor would review it themselves.…

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    This idea is expressed in “Collaboration, Control and the Idea of a Writing Center” by Andrea Lunsford, where she argue that a writing center should “engage students in … not only in understanding and valuing collaboration but in confronting squarely the issues of control that successful collaboration inevitably raises; not only in reaching consensus but in valuing dissensus and diversity (9).” This is idea is critical to my chosen methodology in the writing center. I believe that it is important for both myself and the student to understand that a writing session is a joint-effort; the student can not passively take instruction throughout the session or expect that the tutor will edit their paper. However, I can not control the session by suggesting ideas for a “better” paper, without hearing any opinions that the student has. To circumvent this…

    • 1745 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The next chapter touched on teaching argumentative essays. I find that argumentative essays take planning and an outline. Another thing that helps, is knowing your audience. Knowing who your audience is helps to know how much explanation you need to put into the essay. My last paper in high school was an argumentative essay.…

    • 746 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In making writing assignments, we should question ESL students about how familiar they are and how comfortable they feel with a topic. We have to help them can illustrate their writing structure and teach them right forms of English writing. Allowing them use dictionary and internet to search information, and make them relax to expressing their ideas. We can choose personal topic, it is easier to write because some general topic is uneasy to ESL students. ESL students who are expert writer in their L1 are able to plan.…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example, I was able to contextualize how effective his revision process was since I myself had gone through that process. However, I found it interesting to hear his perspective on what he practices he finds effective in teaching writing. When seeing those practices through the lens of C/T Rhetoric axiology, elements of his writing pedagogy become illuminated that I had not noticed while taking his class. It was also interesting to see how a professor does or does not notice power dynamics in academic contexts. Through this conversation, I was able to gain insights into the thought processes of developing a collegiate…

    • 1108 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, your success with academic writing depends upon how well you understand the topic you can only improve if you put the effort as a college student. As a college student so far my English classes have been great, they have all thought be something that I will…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays