Re Baby B No 2 Summary

Great Essays
The decision by Young J in Re Baby B (No 2) has often been described as a milestone decision for the ambit of parental responsibility. Through his judgment, parental responsibility has been extended to authorise the withholding or withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment for critically ill neonates. The purpose of this essay is to critically analyse the standpoint of Australian law in relation to withdrawing and withholding care of ill neonates and offer recommendations if conflict arises.
Best Interest
Individual autonomy is a fundamental right that all human beings possess no matter what their stature. This cardinal principle is placed above all other merits such as patient welfare and sanctity of life. It is important to note that the
…show more content…
In these circumstances, the Family Court or the Supreme Court acting in parens patriae jurisdiction may make orders in relation to the best interest of the child. These types of treatments are call “non-therapeutic” and the case law is well established in this area. Before the decision in Re Baby D (No 2) , the judgment in Marion’s Case was a landmark decision which addressed parental consent to medical procedures for non-therapeutic benefits. Their Honours in their judgment made it clear that consent to special medical procedures such as sterilization, gender reassignment and termination of pregnancy did not fall within the realm of parental authority. As the purpose of these procedures is not to treat life-threatening ailments and due to the gravity of their consequences, it is imperative to obtain court authorisation before treatment is allowed. The High Court stated that although the Family Court had the jurisdiction to make an order for the procedure; it could not extend parental power to special cases. The law tends to be more subjective in cases where consent is deemed to be within parental …show more content…
The parents of a premature severely disabled girl were informed that they believed any further treatment would be “futile” and recommended withdrawing care. The doctors placed a “do not resuscitate sign” above her cot in case she had breathing difficulties. The parents disagreed with the medical opinion and applied to the court for an order. The court found that on balancing the notion of “best interest”, it would be lawful for the doctors not to administer any life-sustaining treatment. It was held that if the baby were to survive a crisis it would cause such a detriment that her life will become

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Unit 1 Equality, Diversity and Rights in Health and Social Care Task 4.1 Evaluate the role of the health and social care practitioner in meeting individuals’ needs through inclusive practice What is inclusive practice? Inclusive practices ensure that all individuals are included in all parts of life and are not discriminated against or ruled out because of unique differences. It includes approaches and attitudes to be taken to make sure that all individuals are included and not isolated. This means supporting diversity and embracing any differences people may have.…

    • 1099 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Family law is an area of law that is concerned with family matters and domestic relations including marriage, civil unions and termination of relationships etc. The law’s success in family law is in the degree of justice achieved for all individuals involved and impacted. There are a range of contemporary issues concerning family law that affect the overall success of this part of the law and that includes recognition of same-sex marriage, care and protection of children and birth technologies and surrogacies. In relation to same-sex couples, the legal recognition of their marriage means more than the right to get married.…

    • 1346 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pregnancy and prenatal harm to offspring arise many issues. What is the right balance of the fetuses "rights" and the mother 's rights of bodily integrity? Finding the accommodating balance is both difficult and challenging. Both the fetus and mother must be analyzed and evaluated to come to an ultimatum deciding what is best for the unborn child, while also considering the mother 's rights to autonomy and bodily integrity. Robertson and Schulman say, "Ethical analysis must balance the mother 's interest in freedom and bodily integrity against the offspring 's interest in being born healthy.…

    • 1030 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Such decisions regarding patients with severe and deteriorating illness should be processed with respect to the patient’s condition becoming worse with time. Having an ethics board or a medical community to alleviate the pressure of a single doctor making a decision for a patient who is not able to act autonomously would allow for a treatment plan to be determined earlier. In Mary’s case, the court ruling prevented the doctor’s from acting to save her…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Test Item #2: The definition of the word autonomy means to be self-determined or to have free will. Patients, who are competent and are of an appropriate age, all have the ability to be autonomous when it comes to making decisions about their healthcare.…

    • 843 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Drobner V. Lancet Case

    • 920 Words
    • 4 Pages

    1. The issue in this case is if the Drobner v. Peters case should be used as a precedent to dismiss the Woods v. Lancet case, that is whether or not an infant plaintiff could recover damages for injuries allegedly sustained in the mother’s womb during the ninth month of pregnancy resulting in serious injuries, permanently damaging the infant. Citing Drobner v. Peters, the Special Term granted the motion and dismissed the suit on the grounds that infant plaintiff’s failed to state a cause of action, thus taking the position that its allegations, though true, gave the infant no right to recover damages in the courts of New York. The defendant also claimed that there was no medical evidence that proved the plaintiff’s injuries resulted from her…

    • 920 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Child Ethical Dilemmas

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages

    What is the ethical dilemma here? The ethical dilemma here is the mother’s religious beliefs versus medical beliefs. A child’s life is currently in danger and requires immediate medical treatments; however, the child may not be treated due to religious beliefs of the mother. The mother is a religious scientist, who does not accept any medical treatments.…

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Introduction Preterm birth can cause serious health problems or even be fatal for a baby, particularly if it happens very early (Weiss, 2015). In general, the more mature a baby is at birth, the better the chances of surviving and being healthy is. Ms. W’s case is no different; she is in preterm labor in the hospital, refusing treatment. Moreover, due to pregnancy and medication annoyance, Ms. W wants to discontinue all treatment, despite doctors’ orders. Ms. W’s potential risks of premature delivery will increase if she does not understand her medical indications, quality of life in association to risks, contextual features, and the way she applies patient preference.…

    • 1590 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Minor Consent And Refusal

    • 1315 Words
    • 6 Pages

    However, the physician must also make reasonable effort to obtain consent from the minor’s parents or guardians. In the Van Mol vs. Ashmore case, Van Mol who was…

    • 1315 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Individual Autonomy and the tension to conform to Societal values In the pursuit of individual autonomy, tensions exist in the obligation to conform to the values and expectations of the wider community, however, this doesn't always need to be the case. The subject of sociology involves the study of just about every aspect of life from the smallest individual concern to the largest institutional crisis. It is because of this broad range that there will inevitably encounter tensions. Individual autonomy is a persons basic human right to be free to make their own decisions without being influenced by other factors.…

    • 175 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Throughout history there have been many ideals about a woman’s body – what an “attractive” woman should look like, act like, smell like, be like. A woman’s body has been appreciated for its beauty as well as objectified based on what that body can do for society --whether or not it is truly fruitful and multiplying; whether or not it is visually pleasing; whether or not it makes money. Women’s health has been at the mercy of male physicians and women’s minds kept as unexercised and out of shape as possible. The “why” behind this phenomenon of oppression has been hotly debated. The reality, however, is that, from the act of childbirth to eating disorders, a woman’s body is a social celebrity.…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This approach is improper because the professional is taking away the mother's autonomy and ability to deny treatment without consequence. In this case, it is clear that the Supreme Court’s decision favors an agency model rather than a paternalistic model. The supreme court granted women who use drugs while pregnant the right to consent and confidentiality and chooses to ignore the emotions of the medical professionals treating these women. This is considered a ‘pro’ in the agency model because the patient has agency and the doctor cannot make decisions for the patient based on their moral evaluation or…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    1.3.1 Case Laws: 1.3.2 The Gillick competence Both at common law and statutory provisions, children have the capacity to perform certain acts and take certain decisions even without the consent of their parents or guardians. The critical question is whether the child has reached the age of maturity and has the capacity to make those decision or actions. Ms Gillick brought a court case against both the Council and the Health Authority about contraception, which she argues was unlawful, on the grounds that it is causing or empowering unlawful sex with children under 16 years, and contravenes s 28(1) of the Sexual Offenses Act 1956, or the offense of being an accomplice to unlawful sex with children under 16, as opposed to s 6(1) of that Act.…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Standard Operating Procedure; Consent and Treatment (2012), for example, if the patient is unable to give consent due to incapacities to make a sound decision (unconscious and/or mentally unstable, etc) and require emergency medical treatment to avoid serious harm, the health professionals can provide treatment by demonstrating professionalism to act in patient’s best interest and legislation would protect for the minors under 18 years old (Guardianship Act 1987 for New South Wales)and it will be different to other states)and mentally disable patient by appointing them a guardian to advocate their rights and make an appropriate medical decision for them (Daly, Speedy, & Jackson, 2010). However, with an exception of medically urgent situation, if patients who arrived in the operating theatre without valid consent the health professionals should not move the patient to the treatment bay and relevant supervisors, such as Clinical Nurse Manger, Medical Director and other health service administrators, should be notified. Treatment should also be cancelled or withheld until the valid consent is available.…

    • 1460 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A study showed that parents decision making relies on a lot more factors than medical data (Carroll, 2012). In fact, when parents were asked to identify what influenced their decision making they were most likely to cite spirituality and a sense of duty to do everything possible for their child. Parents have a more complicated investment in the child than the medical team and may not be able to clearly look at the medical diagnosis, prognosis and potential outcome for the child. I believe the parents’ wishes should be considered along with a more objective fact based decision come to by the healthcare team with a critical eye towards the quality of life sustained by the infant. According to a literature review on end-of-life care in the newborn (Willems, 2014), initial treatment is required for most ill newborns in order to better understand the prognosis for the child.…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays