Radical Revolution Vs Russian Revolution Research Paper

Improved Essays
It’s hard to imagine a more radical revolution than the Russian Revolution of 1917: the tzar was killed, the people and the Bolsheviks became the leaders, and centuries of monarchy turned overnight into Communism. A radical revolution is where the people who are uprising decide to revamp the social structure, and change the fundamental beliefs of the society. Their goals were “tearing at the bonds holding the traditional monarchical society” together. By contrast, a “common sense” revolution is where the discontent people overthrow the controlling power generally keeping the fundamental structure of society, but changes smaller aspects they do not like. The complaints of the colonists were that they had issues with taxes, representation, and a distant monarch ruling from across the sea. Many historians consider the American Revolution to be a …show more content…
These ideas talk about how monarchs are very unsuccessful because leadership is passed on through hereditary, and that royalty should not be above average people when they are born. Major complaints about monarchs are that Kings picked because of their family, and they could potentialy not be qualified or experienced to be the leader of a country. Paine’s pamphlet soon becomes the most red and well-known pamphlet throughout the colonies. Another famous historian Gordon Wood, describes how the colonies were infected by the radical idea that every (white) man should be equal in the eyes of the law. Suddenly, in the eyes of the revolutionaries, all the fine calibrations of rank and degrees of unfreedom of the traditional monarchical society became absurd and degrading. The Revolution became a full-scale assault on

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Before the American Colonies were on the verge of independence, almost the entirety of of the colonies’ population wanted nothing but a reconciliation with Britain. It was not until a man by the name Thomas Paine wrote a pamphlet entitled Common Sense that the colonists were fully swayed onto the revolutionary side. Made for the common man, this pamphlet was used as more than just a tool to begin the shifting of the tides towards patriots; it was one of the first extremely successful published persuasive essays. Within its pages, this pamphlet contained irrefutable arguments against the king. Whether it be grievances fueled by unfair tariffs, or arguments that further supported the need for separation from the British, Thomas Paine found a…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Boston Tea Party Thesis

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Introduction: Overview and Summary Statements The American Revolution was a political revolution between the colonies in North America and Great Britain. Although most colonists favored independence, some were still loyal to Great Britain, and were called “Loyalists,” who fought for the British during the wars, unlike Patriots who fought against Great Britain. Advocates supported a new nation being created with unlimited opportunities with newfound freedom. Loyalists were true to Britain because they believed that Britain was inclined to win, so they wanted to fight on the British behalf because they were more dominant and would undoubtedly defeat the colonists.…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    But Some historian like Gordon Wood an Alfred E Young argue that it was revolutionary. They believe that revolution brought a lot of big change other than getting independence (Background Essay). The American Revolution was revolutionary in terms of political independence, but it wasn’t revolutionary socially for groups such as slaves and women's.…

    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Despite such claims to republicanized monarchy in Great Britain, certain colonists and thinkers were not convinced. Englishman, and later colonial resident, Thomas Paine, for example, called into question the integrity of such claims in his pamphlet Common Sense. Written in 1776 and dispensed throughout the colonies, this seminal pamphlet attacked the absoluteness of the British monarchy. Unlike Wood’s interpretation of British monarchy—which is, granted, aided by hundreds of years of reflection—Paine’s argument stated that the British system was victim to the “natural disease of monarchy,” which is a “thirst for absolute power.” Disdainful towards this abuse of power, Paine in turn lauded republicanism, which he admitted was present in the…

    • 1659 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    No longer was leadership based on a God-given right, or only open to those with wealth and status, but it was rather based on merit. A main counterargument is that very little social change occurred, which would deem the revolution as radical, as “Important social institutions were left untouched by the Revolution” (Source A). But one is forgetting in the argument the social change which actually did occur, and the catalyst the Revolution served for…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Luke Losoya October 19, 2017 HIST 1301-079 Professor Jonathan A Lee Causes of the Revolution from Two Contradictive Historians The American Revolution was a unique phenomenon. Many people from complete opposite ends of colonial societies united to gain independence from the sovereign Great Britain, who during the time was the military and economic powerhouse of the world. Historians often find themselves disagreeing over the causes that joined colonial forces together. Gary Nash and Bernard Bailyn are two historians who view the American Revolution from two opposite ends of the spectrum.…

    • 868 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    American Revolution Dbq

    • 560 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Moreover, the common folk, who enjoyed widespread political opportunities and economic and social mobility, did not resent the leadership of the powerful and, therefore, did not demand social or political leveling. They, too, were conservatives who joined the American cause to oppose British efforts to infringe on their rights as Englishmen. In short, the Revolution was a defensive movement to maintain the rights and liberties that Americans had always enjoyed. Those historians who maintain that the American Revolution was revolutionary argue that there is radicalism in ideas, values, traditions, and customs.…

    • 560 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To elaborate, there are some who argue that the American Revolution was not a necessary conflict, as most of the Americans were ruled by a democratic government. The subject of American Revolution has been widely discussed and historians often have different viewpoints on this topic including those presented by George Bancroft, Andrew Hacker, Merill Jensen, Robert Brown, and Bernard Bailyn. However, in order to truly answer the question as to whether the American Revolution was radical or indeed revolutionary, one does not need to look further than to inspect the opinions of Gorge Bancroft, Andrew…

    • 562 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The American Revolution was truly revolutionary. In document three, it shows rich, middle, and poor class playing pool; which definitely did not happen before the revolution. Also, in document four it reveals that, after the revolution, the number of people in the rich class decreased, people in the middle class increased, and the poor class remained unchanged throughout the war. The abolition of slavery happened because of the revolution and, over time, that resulted in a new nation as shown in document five. If the tensions between Britain and the colonies had not built up, then we may still just be 13 individual colonies under the rule of Great Britain.…

    • 110 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One common theme throughout every social and political revolution to ever take place, is leadership. Leadership is the glue that bonds ordinary people, to an idea they all believe in. Average citizens may desire change, but without leaders who truly take action and drive the will of the people forward towards the desired change, no such change will occur. The American Revolution was no different. Increasing British tyranny after the Seven Years War, created a resentment to British Control, and a desire for revolution.…

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Bruce Batista While there was no tyrannical, violent king that was overthrown like King Louis XVI during the French Revolution, or no oppressed proletariat class that replaced the ruling class like in the Russian Revolution, the American Revolution was still truly revolutionary because it changed nearly every aspect of life for the colonists, and America as we know it today would not exist. There economic, political, and social upheaval as a result of gaining independence from England. The Treaty of Paris was signed on September 3, 1783, and it marked the end of the Revolutionary War. Great Britain had to recognize American independence and gave up the land between the Allegheny Mountains in Pennsylvania and the Mississippi River.…

    • 1263 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Common Sense is rightful credited to realigning American’s position on whether or not they should declare independence from Britain due to Thomas Paine’s irrefutable arguments and his persuasive style of writing. Throughout Common Sense, Paine uses logic to explain how unjust the monarch system is, and how as a growing nation, it is an opportunity to create a government that best represents the people. He reminds people of the flaws in Britain’s government and all their attempts to control America by taxing them irrationally. Thomas Paine was so successful in convincing the American’s to declare independence by appealing to their emotions, and disproving arguments that support living under the British rule. What makes Paine’s argument so compelling…

    • 1184 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Often times, the definition of a true “revolution” may seem rather skewed. Societies have the tendency to label certain changes as complete revolutions, even though not much among the people may have changed. The historian Crane Brinton believes that a true revolution is one in which there is “an overall restructuring of the political, social, and economic fabric of a society”. The definition that Brinton provides perfectly fits with the story of the American revolution. The American revolution was not something that happened overnight.…

    • 1044 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The American Revolution in 1775-1783 was caused by the outcome of the French and Indian War in 1754-1763. Where the British fought with the French and had given the colonists a bad impression of the British goal. Due to the heavy debts, the British had no choice, but to tax their colonies. Which angered the colonists and led the people to rebel against their king. Throughout the revolutionary war, the people began to have different thoughts on their political future.…

    • 1077 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The revolution didn’t produce a complete cataclysm of the preexisting social structures. New social groups or class weren’t introduced, but this doesn’t mean the revolution wasn’t radical at all when it came to the social change. The Revolution was able to replace the old archaic type relationships with a social structure that expressed democracy and republicanism. From slavery, women’s rights, voting rights, and religious life, America was incomparably affected socially. There was the separation of the church and the state as the Anglican Church was no longer able to survive, as the official head of the Church of England was a British Monarch.…

    • 1927 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays