Racism In Comrades, By Nadine Gordimer

Improved Essays
Racial injustice has played a tremendous role in world history and still does to this day today in countries like the US, where systemic racism still is a big problem, even in the 21st century. This issue is also one of the main themes in the South African writer Nadine Gordimer’s short story “Comrades”, which was published in 1991. In the short story, contrasts play a big role. However, the main contrast portrayed in the short story is the contrast between black South Africans and white South Africans as the short story is set during the Apartheid rule in South Africa which culminated with the first free election in 1994. In Gordimer’s short story, a white liberal woman offers a group of black protestors a ride and a meal which the protestors …show more content…
Because of this system, the group of protestors seem startled and a bit overwhelmed at the woman’s sudden hospitality and during the car ride, the atmosphere is very uncomfortable as neither of the parties do not know what to say. When they all reach the home of the woman, the contrast between the wealthy and free white South Africans and the oppressed black South Africans is astounding. The home of the woman appears wealthy with golden ceilings and antique chandeliers. The woman also has a maid which appears to belong to the same ethnic group as the group of protestors as they speak the same language, completely unintelligible to the white woman. When the maid had finished preparing the food for the young men and is preparing to serve it, the white woman hesitates. She does not want the young men to see the maid serving them food, instead she wants to serve them the food herself. This brief moment of hesitation by the white woman is probably due to the fact that she wants to appear as a peer to the …show more content…
This is especially the case during the car ride and during the meal at the woman’s house. During the car ride, the young protestors seem quite sceptical of the woman which affects the overall atmosphere. The woman is also not sure of what to talk to the young men about as they come from vastly different social environments. This contrast also affects the young men deeply as they are not quite sure if they can trust the woman or not. But as soon as the woman offers them a quick meal, the atmosphere eases up a bit. During the meal, however, the tense atmosphere returns. Once again, the woman does not know what to talk to the young men about and when she discovers the fact that the young men only speak a limited amount of English, the communication between the two parties become even more challenging. At one point, the awkward silence becomes so uncomfortable that the woman is desperate to say anything, just something to fill in the awkward silence, and ends up saying something completely unrelated to the previous conversation. In that moment, it dawns on both parties that the distance between the whites and coloureds of South Africa caused by the Apartheid system is simply too immense to fix with simple courtesy and

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    When it comes to racial crimes and segregation there is nothing more depressing than talking about how many times our world has been through it. It has happened throughout our entire lives and sadly it still happens today. The devastation and violence from these acts have shaped the way our society is and it’s not necessarily good. As a white male I can’t say I have ever been part of any minority group, but as a white female in South Africa during the 1960s you could say it was quite shocking to be on the opposite side. In the book The Unlikely Secret Agent by Ronnie Kasrils a woman, Eleanor was living amongst the South African Apartheid.…

    • 1372 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Citizen By Claudia Rankine, Rankine exposes the nature of oppression and racism that many individuals of color face on a daily basis. Rankine emphasises both “macro” and “micro-aggressions”, implying that racism can manifest in both direct and subtle ways. Throughout the book, Rankine analyses specific events poetically, using figurative and rich language to dwell deeper into the experience of what it is like to be racially oppressed in a predominately “white background”. Throughout the book, I was particularly intrigued by Rankine's use of the second person present, which is often reserved for works of fiction.…

    • 325 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It initiates that society has made the aunt believe that she and the African Americans are in fact a “nigger” and now accepts it as being who she is. Everything that society says about the African Americans is regarded as true by Aunt Helen, which shows that the relationship between the narrator and society is uneasy because she now believes something she did not believe before because of the flawed…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Segregation is the separation of humans into racial groups in daily life. Throughout history in multi-racial communities segregation has always existed. It can be found anywhere from in school to in the work place. In Jennifer Baszile’s “The Black Girl Next Door” we witness the difficulties Jen and her family have integrating into the white upper class neighbourhood in the year of 1975. This is shown through Jen’s anger, betrayal and naivety, her mom’s teacher-like approach vs. her dad’s business man like approach as well as the social and religious symbols displayed throughout the story.…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    There was still prejudice and pride of the “whites” in South Africa. As mentioned earlier Gordimer wrote about her experiences and things she observed. Gordimer wrote this book with the probable expectation to get a different reaction than the reader first started. Some reactions the writer might want from the reader could be the realization of how bad or horrible things were post-Apartheid. Other reaction could be to break your heart as the parents had their heart broken.…

    • 1578 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Assignment 4 Philip James SOC 100 The first document that I chose is titled “Sociology of Racism” written by Matthew Clair of Havard University and Jeffrey Denis of McMaster University. I wanted to use this paper because it discusses the origin of racism and how people come to possess it. According to Clair and Denis, racism roots from the thought that a certain group is superior to the other because small differences such as hair color, skin tone, and facial structure. Racism is very different from racial discrimination and inequality but really it is the root of difference from one group to another.…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Hortense Powdermaker’s book, Stranger and Friend, chronicles her experiences doing fieldwork throughout her career. In it, she discusses culture as shared meaning, where context and history give different components of a society social value. Through this process, essential qualities of a culture develop. The theory with which Powdermaker views culture, cultural essentialism, is one which uses these essential qualities as means of identification to form groups of people. This differs from Malinowski’s functionalist view, which claims that culture serves the needs of individuals rather than of larger communities.…

    • 967 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    5. Minny feels the satisfaction she does in preparing a BLT sandwich for Jonny Foote because now that the ice is broken between them and there’s no more hiding, she feels relieved that she doesn’t have to work in fear anymore, like she was doing so before. I think this is important to a black maids experience because they already have a fear of there boss because they are in control of so much, but if someone living in the house does not know of the maid that can cause a lot of problems. Finally being able to know that Ms. Celia’s husband knows about Minny gives her a satisfying…

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jasper Jones is a 2009 fictional novel by Fremantle-based writer Craig Silvey. Jasper Jones is a novel that deals with so many different issues and themes ranging from truth and lies, to stereotypes and assumptions, to the cruelty of humankind. Silvey’s novel follows the story of young Charlie Bucktin; the protagonist of the novel, a scrawny, socially awkward Caucasian thirteen-year-old living in a reginal mining town called Corrigan in the 1960s; who is late one night startled by his secret visitor, Japer Jones. Jasper Jones is known for his terrible reputation in Corrigan. He is known as a thief, a liar, a thug, a tyrant, as lazy, unreliable, feral, and he is practically an orphan because his dad is never home and always drunk.…

    • 1047 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even despite the political upheaval and racial tension in South Africa during this time, the South African woman, Sokutu, is able to confide in the Irish girl named Cathy who has dealt with alchoholics in her life. This shows that the bond between women who have struggled does in fact transcend race and class differences. Remembering this occurence changes Jordan 's perspective and reminds her of positive bonds between every human being conflicting with her strong oppinions on race, class, and gender structures. This idea of a women sharing a common identity despite being of different races and coming from different backgrounds is a powerful realization for Jordan but also brings to light the important value of empathy. This value is something that still holds importance today, with so many minority groups being alienated from our modern society it is hard for people to remember that we are all members of the human race who need to do out part to help one…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the poem “White Papers [1]” Martha Collins discloses her past, present, and future understanding of racism. Collins use of sound, language, and other literary devices reveal to the reader the process of which the United States has, is, and forever will be going through to amend racism and racial bias. In this poem the speaker travels through her lifetime finding the indirect influences she experienced from childhood to adulthood that resulted in her thoughts on race. The impression that the speaker received through these influences resulted into her believing that racism progressing in a positive direction was not plausible. In the end, Martha Collins reveals that the nation has progressed despite her predictions, and because of this…

    • 1276 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Ironically, this divide based on colour of skin changed how individuals lived.as coloured people belong in a poor and environment, compared to white people who belong in a rich and luxurious city. This social divide has created false attributes towards both sides of town: coloured people are referred to as ‘dirty’ and white people are referred to as ‘normal’ people. In other words, white people are held even more superior and coloured people are treated and respected much worse. Coloured maids are not able to express their emotions, but rather obey every they are given by a white person, as if they are robots or slaves, not human beings. This social divide has driven the plot of this novel, as Aibileen, Minny, and Skeeter eventually begin to take action against this racism, leading to next argument, hope.…

    • 1529 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    This highlights Malan ’s argument that apartheid’s intention was to keep the black population disadvantaged both economically and educationally. This was achieved by removing all exposure to literature that would help to reveal the inequality and oppression apartheid caused. The black people became South Africa’s Proletariat class, powerful when united but banned from uniting. “My Traitor’s Heart” was positively received by the readers even with its provocative nature.…

    • 1621 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    CRITIQUE ANALYSIS OF “SO WHAT ARE YOU, ANYWAY?” By Lawrence Hill Racism and ethnic discrimination in the North America has been a biggest issue since the colonial times. The segregation continues to take place in many social areas such as housing, education, employment, especially for Afro-American people. 1970’s was the crucial time of the racism, many students killed by the national guards in U.S. during their protests against racial injustice. The violence followed by the Civil Rights Movement and caused awakenings of the anti-racist ideology in literature because” white against black” was not a determinable social impact.…

    • 1018 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From the very beginning, it is clear that “racism” is the central theme that Nadine Gordimer tackles in her work July’s people. South Africa witnessed racial segregation for many years under the apartheid regime. It was based on the belief that some races are better than others moreover the unfair treatment for those who belong to a different race. As a famous satirist and social reformer, Gordimer sheds the light on racism from its different perspectives either physical or mental in order to cure her society ills. First, the readers come across with physical racism which is represented by separation between blacks and whites; they are seen as two different nations because of their physical appearance namely “skin color”.…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays