Racism In Blaunder's Talking Past Each Other

Improved Essays
In the article “Talking Past Each Other” Blaunder speaks about how there is a gap on how to perceive racism, which reflects a difference between both race (color/white). In the conversation between the white male (Bob), and black female (Shontell) we can clearly see how there is a gap on their perception of racism. Bob is telling Shontell that why would she considered US as racist, if the President himself is black. Her respond showed Individualistic Fallacy, on how her thoughts are based on ideas and prejudices. In this fallacy racism is only a collection of nasty thought she might have about the country itself, that’s why her respond was “you can’t see the forest for its tree”. Basically defending her idea that only because the president …show more content…
The idea is because “racism is a system of “power” and black people as a group do not have power” (Blaunder, Pg.57). The idea that a group of blacks can’t have power shows how only because one person itself has an important position, it does not mean that racism overall towards the race is out the picture. Bobs confusion towards her idea was that how can a place be racist and yet hire you? She then backs up her opinion on how she was hired in a place in which she was the only black person working for them, or ever hired. She later quit because she felt like they were racist, but yet didn’t have a fundamental evidence to prove it. Her only backup during her conversation with Bob was that “It wasn’t that obvious. I was the first black person they had hired, and just didn’t feel like I fit in. It wasn’t a comfortable place for a black person to work” (line 16). I don’t agree with her quitting, she didn’t have a fundamental reason for her to feel like they were being racist. I think it was more her feeling weird because she was the only black person there. Instead of blaming it on them being racist why not look at it as black people not trying to get out their comfort zone, to actually feel comfortable in a place even though the majority group is not of their same …show more content…
Throughout the whole conversation we can argue between Desmond and Blaunder article wider and narrower definitions. All of Desmond Fallacies point of view definition, defended a white narrower point of view. Blaunder black wider definition believed that an occupation is racist simply because of racial minorities and underrepresented in numbers or in positions of prestige and authority. In which case the wider definitions defended Shontell’s reasons on why to feel like there was racism in its

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    This leaves black women without privilege, which results in a nonexistent voice or identity in society. Peggy McIntosh alludes to white privilege as being “an invisible package with unearned assets” meaning those who have privilege are “oblivious” to it and only those who are being oppressed see privilege (McIntosh, P). Our society has been orchestrated in a way that those who aren’t being oppressed fail to recognize the advantages that come with the privilege of being born male or white. How can one understand oppression of those who lack privilege if they don’t first acknowledge the privilege they possess? In order to bring about change and recognize black women as an identified group in society, one must first become more conscientious about privilege so that the structure of who is born with or without privilege can be revised and equal for all people.…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sports And Racism

    • 1651 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In Erasing Racism, Asante explains how there is racism in the workplace and it is difficult for blacks to get certain jobs, or even reach higher positions. Asante argues, “Many whites would typically argue that racism does not exist in the workplaces. Yet in almost all cases where African Americans work with whites, operate on the basis of race… they face racial discrimination that often prevents them from reaching their highest potential” (Asante 276). This is related because even if African Americans wanted to get jobs in the media, they are constantly discriminated against, and this is one of the things that Ratchford does not mention. This causes problems because it means that black athletes are being misrepresented by those in the…

    • 1651 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racism Is Racism

    • 1286 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Taylor Coward SUNY Cobleskill English Is racism a learned behavior or human nature? The past few years in America have showed the true racist colors that paint our nation. Racism is a very controversial topic here in the United States (and in my classroom but, it’s something I desperately need to speak about). The real definition of racism states that it is “the belief that all members of each race possess characteristics or abilities specific to that race, especially so as to distinguish it as inferior or superior to another race or race”. To rephrase, if you use ethnicity to determine whether or not you are better than someone, you are racist.…

    • 1286 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This illustrates how Height felt that black women were not being recognized in the Moynihan report. If black women were recognized in the Moynihan, then it would have been successful. Finally, Benjamin Payton believed that the wording of the Moynihan Report lead to a distraction that lead to ignored Dorothy Height’s argument of black man being dominant. Therefore, the Moynihan Report had issues because it only focus on black males rights and address the problem but did not offer any solutions to solve the…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    People were too stubborn to accept that blacks were equal to whites and that they had every right to be working for the government (Document G). Blacks lived in the same country as whites, but they were scorned for pursuing a career that allowed their voices to be heard. It was as if the white people during Reconstruction were trying to restrain colored people once more, as they did with…

    • 1021 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This ties into what Dubois wrote because they did not truly see themselves for who they truly were, they thought they have to be loser to white skinned to excel and be accepted. They did not accept that they were black and try to build themselves up, infact they were in a way snobbish becau ethey only accepts lighter skinned people int the group and many others that were darker looked up to them. This shows the veil that is blocking the way African Americans see themselves…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Black people in the 1960’s and even today, still face these challenges of not being confident in what they choose to do professionally. During the 1960’s, when black people were finally legal to vote in America, it was still very difficult for them to be eligible. Rosaleen, at multiple points in the novel, stated that she wanted to register to vote. However, during her first attempt to register to vote, she was attacked by multiple white men “yelling for her to apologize and clean their shoes” (32). At this point, Rosaleen had done nothing to apologize for, yet they were assailing her with misogyny and racism, even though she only wanted to vote.…

    • 948 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    A variable that changes with every interaction. The article states there can be two different ideals of racism in this case, race-based prejudice or discrimination where anyone can be racist and then we have institutional racism where those who are in power are racist. Here it is believed that the racism in America is rooted in its own culture. What this meant is that the American people hold onto the stereotypes they learn, i.e. from family, and in turn between different groups are held a predisposition that one is better than the other.…

    • 1416 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Color Blind Racism

    • 2299 Words
    • 9 Pages

    However color blind racism is a perfect example of racism not being over. Color blind racism is racism that acts as if skin color does not matter, even though it’s evident that it does. For example you found whites that refuse to use the word black in public because they are afraid to sound racist. In addition instead of using the word “race” they would rather use words like culture, or ethnicity. Most of them would use the word African-American, or white people who would still support a black person success and be the first to criticize when they make a simple mistake.…

    • 2299 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Whites aren’t the only ones who are racist, but there are Native Americans, Blacks and others who are also racist. All sides of the racial lines that includes the whites ought to be blamed for perpetuating the hate, but it is the blacks and others who either are using their race as a weapon but not wanting to take the stumbling block out of their own path. In part of this story on racist people we can finally recognize that we need to finally solve this problem. To solve this problem is to tell both sides of the story. There are…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays