Beauty, And The Tangled Knot Of A Guilty Pleasure: Article Analysis

Improved Essays
Craig, Maxine L. "Race, Beauty, and the Tangled Knot of a Guilty Pleasure." Feminist Theory 7.2 (2006): 159-77. Web. Maxine Craig in her article, “Race, beauty, and the tangled knot of a guilty pleasure” writes about the complications of beauty standards and the way in which it is perceived in our society. She argues that the discussion of beauty norms by feminist is often incomplete because race and class play important roles in the conversation, yet are frequently left out. Her contribution to the topic is appreciated because she makes it aware that there are both positive and negative attributes to beauty standards within our society. Furthermore, she suggests that beauty standards, if used at all, should be split into varying groups to …show more content…
The purpose of her writing is mainly to inform the public on the dangers and prevalence of beauty standards within our society while promoting the love for each individual’s own self. Furthermore, she argues that beauty ideals have been apart of our society for a long time and she reflects on the history of beauty standards within America to strengthen her argument. I agree with Cheryl in her many arguments within her article because she offers a fresh and new outlook on the topic. Her paper offers a new perspective of the issue by precisely tackling major problems such as the constant portrayal of Eurocentric beauty ideals as the generalizing perception of beauty within our society. I plan to use her article within my own writing to highlight the specific ways she illustrates how African American women were and are currently oppressed because of their …show more content…
This includes the form of beauty ideals African American women are expected to fulfill. She compares this standard to that of the Eurocentric exemplar and suggest that despite their differences, they are equally wrong. She, like many other authors, emphasize the importance of making room to be inclusive of a wider array of body images and shapes. I agree with Demetria in her argument that black body ideals sexualized and exaggerated by media can be just as damaging as the general beauty standards our society portrays. To add to her discussion, I feel as though she could have included how many black women are faced with a double standard of beauty in which they are expected to represent only the ‘good’ traits of themselves, and to mimic everything else. Demetria’s article is important to the discussion, however, because it brings attention to the physical and life threatening dangers that these beauty standards are inflicting on women. Within my own essay, I plan to use her article as an example of how African Americans are dirtily impacted by beauty standards and how specifically dangerous it can

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    In doing so, societal stigmas and norms are created that have the potential to cause harm to those within these groups that do not naturally meet these specific and highly processed standards of beauty. However, an important concept that can be taken away from their work is that if members of these groups can overcome the internal need conform to highly specific and unreasonable forms of beauty, then the industry that profits off of insecurities will hold less power to do so. If the unnatural becomes natural, and grotesque becomes normal, then the necessity to create and reinforce a dichotomy between the two becomes pointless. Accepting that everyone has natural imperfections and deviations strips the power from beauty companies that thrive on highlighting, exaggerating, and vilifying…

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Beauty is defined by the powerful members of a society. In the late 1800’s and early 1900’s, neo-colonialism’s image of beauty entailed westernized features such as thin lips, fine, straight hair, small features and white skin; the paler the skin, the more prestigious. Pale skin often symbolized wealth and status; even Caucasians powdered their skin to look whiter. High society folks did not work outside in the fields, as common laborers did. Their skin was not scourged by the sun. Dark skin was associated with a lower class of people. The darker the skin, the less valued in the culture. In Zora Neale Hurston’s novel, Their Eyes were Watching God, she explored the theme of physical attractiveness during the Harlem Renaissance period. Hurston’s…

    • 1562 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Alright that’s it; you just lost your phone.” I painfully surrendered my phone to my mother. But it wasn’t for a bad grade or any other typical teenage mishap; the cause was simple: makeup. Sure I was old enough and had any right to wear it, but her reasoning always remained the same, “Leah, you are too beautiful to wear makeup”. These words I heard over and over again as a child, but I questioned whether other young, African American women were told the same thing. In “Appearance Obsession” published August of 1995, in Essence Magazine, Bell Hooks stresses how much African American women are spending to look good. The pressures to fit into Western culture can turn into an obsession over their outward appearance. Bell Hooks believes that “the schism between how we view ourselves and how society perceives us, leads to poor self-image and low self-esteem among many Black women, making our lives a breeding ground for "appearance obsession."”(Hooks 1). Hooks challenges women to see beauty as physical health and emotional well-being. I agree with Hook’s stand on the pressures that many African American women face to fit into the stereotypical idea of beauty, but…

    • 1457 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Gender And Gender Analysis

    • 1254 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Women of color are seen as even more natural due to both their gender and their race. This is because darker skin color was often seen as “primitive” or “animalistic,” at least in Western societies (Mascia-Lees). Regardless of the attempts at justifying any differentiation among races, the interaction between race and gender places women of color in a much more challenging position, relative to white women. This, in addition to the view of women as being unsophisticated, creates a very hostile atmosphere for women of color in Western society. Remnants of imperialism and African slave trading hold roots in Western society that permeate a manner of thinking in which people of color are socially constructed as primitive, in need of being taught the “proper” way to live, and in need of being made “whiter”, which is demonstrated by attempts to sell skin bleaching “beauty” products to women of color. Women of color in particular are then seen as less capable of possessing the qualities of a “proper lady” and are treated as such. This view of women, black women especially, has shaped the way that the world perceives women’s bodies and adds to the stereotypes, negative perceptions and flat out inaccuracies that black women face, that white women may not be as exposed…

    • 1254 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article, “Size zero, high-end ethnic: Cultural production and the reproduction of culture in the fashion modeling,” exemplifies the high expectations of modeling for other racially models in ways that explain how producers in the modeling industry, weigh their decisions on two analytically liked issues such as body types and racial exclusion. Mears argues a valid point illustrating how darker skinned toned females that are chosen to walk in the runways exemplify the opposite to the normatively white female body. She states, “Content analyses of fashion media consistently show that darker skinned women have and continue to be posed and styled in exotic juxtaposition to the normatively white female body, if they are included in fashion at all” (Mears, 24). Colour of Beauty, mentions that African American…

    • 439 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the 2011 documentary film Dark Girls, Dr. Cheryl Grills states that “beauty to black people is just a small piece of a much bigger animal.” Women of African descent throughout American history have been in a constant battle between themselves and the world that surrounds them. When media evolved in the nineteen seventies the women of the world seemed to have taken “control” and the “strong black woman” movement began. Throughout the mass media there are various over-generalizations of a black woman. Mainstream media in American society plays a key role in producing negative stereotypes about this race. The misrepresentation of black women can have an ongoing effect on their self-esteem and self-image. The portrayal of this race has been…

    • 1031 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Eurocentric Standards

    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In the documentary, “Dark Girls”, a character says “when you live so many years with people having certain judgements relative to your skin tone, you start to believe it.” In Asian societies, making your children aware (ex. weight, skin color, and etc.) of their appearance “flaws” throughout their life is accepted. Negative psychological effects of the enforcing of Eurocentric ideals are low self- esteem, bad body image, self-hate, colorism within own race, losing ones’ racial identity, mental health issues (ex. depression, anxiety, and etc.) developing eating disorders. In addition, people of darker than desirable skin may have difficulty finding a partner and job opportunities. Eurocentric ideals have become the standard of physical beauty and influence on what the opposite sex sees as desirable. A study on 15 African American teens, 100% of males preferred the more western looking African American women over Afrocentric looking females. An African America girl from “A Girl like Me” responded to this notion, “I felt like there was not any attention towards me because of maybe my skin color or because my hair was kinky.” Eurocentric looking models have affected women’s body and self- esteem when shown these kinds of images on a daily…

    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Milkie, Melissa A.. “Social Comparisons, Reflected Appraisals, and Mass Media: The Impact of Pervasive Beauty Images on Black and White Girls' Self-concepts”.…

    • 1407 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    WRT 205 Research Paper

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Beauty and the way it is conveyed through media coincide in negatively altering women’s ability to justly view and obtain the correct perception of beauty. The ideals and standards that media expose to the public tell a number of women that they do not fit in this altering spectrum. Looking at where the concept of beauty started, how the media interpret it, and the way it physiologically impacts women, we are able to see a correlation that shows how the culture of beauty today negatively impacts society.…

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Beauty matters. Well, at least for some. From the clothes you choose to wear (and the ones you don’t) to the items you own, everything surrounding you changes how people perceive you, even things completely out of someone’s control. Pressures to adhere to societal norms can cause long-term harm for certain people, but others can take this concept in stride. Due to different upbringings, along with different environmental influences, it allows for a range of perspectives. “Girl” by Alexander Chee, a reflection piece on Chee’s experience with femininity, along with the Slam Poetry video “Pretty” by Katie Makkai about her experience with being physically desirable due to pressures with societal norms, bring to the surface the experiences women…

    • 1601 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Bluest Eye: Socratic Seminar further analyzed interesting parts of Morrison’s chapter, autumn. First, I thought it was an interesting that white standards of beauty today are not as prominent as it was in the past, but as society evolved these issues plaguing our society has also evolved into different forms. For example, in the modeling career there is diversity among campaigns like Aerie and as Emily experienced first-hand, beauty touches today are with physical makeup instead of edits for a perfect beauty image. However, the pressure for beauty is still a problem, as Jamie said, when you search Google the first images that show up are white women and as Christina said, actors like Beyonce, a confident black female, have edits making them lighter, showing that there is…

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Women all around the world are well aware of the advantages and disadvantages of being a certain skin color. In Cell One by Chimamanda Adichie, the author touches on female beauty standards that are specific to the Nigerian culture. The reading reveals that women are favored when they are light skinned. Furthermore, America is known for its diversity among the female population. Though there is diversity in American society, there is not necessarily an equal preference for race for women. Because of marriage, the entertainment industry, and international relations, women who are white are favored in Nigeria and the United States of America.…

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    According to a study that was made by Maya A. Poran she cited from other articles something that really stood out to because as a woman, I see it alot in many of my social media handles. “It has been said that white women seem to have a uniform notion of what beauty should be (Parker et al., 1995) and their conception of beauty tends to match the culturally popular images of white women in mainstream media (Wolf, 1991).” Poran’s experiment consisted of 157 women; 52 African American women, 48 Hispanic women, 51 Caucasian women, and 6 “others” which were women who chose not to enclose their ethnicity. The purpose was to see the conception of beauty and perceptions of cultural standards and social media from these ladies. After a series of questions, one being “What is beauty to you?” there was a big difference of definition when it came to race. The women of color and hispanic women who answered the question all answered this question in this exact order; you had to “(1) being white, (2) having white features, [i.e., hair, nose, skin color) (3) being thin, (4) have a pretty face (or handsome) and long hair.” (Poran, M. A. (2002). Which is the exact beauty standard that is represented in social media, and the world…

    • 849 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    This essay will summarize Susan Sontag’s ideas concerning how beauty is seen in today’s modern culture and the consequences that these views have toward women, by using Susan Sontag’s vivid examples and definitions found in both “A Woman’s Beauty: Put-Down or Power Source” and “An Argument About Beauty”. Next, I will argue in support of most of her key points; however, I will also argue against some of the points presented in the essay. For example, I agree with her assertion that in todays modern culture women’s beauty is seen as parts and not as a whole and the effects of this distorted perspective. However, I disagree with her on how she believes that things will get better and how she blames Christianity for fostering one of the distorted perspectives of women’s beauty. Susan Sontag brings about a lot of key points that we as Christians should understand so as to bring about a better attitude and view towards women and beauty. Modern-day conceptions of…

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The saying “Beauty is in the eye of the beholder” expresses the subjective views people have on what is beautiful and what is not. What some may see as beautiful may not be agreeable with others. When it comes to women, they come in all diverse sizes, shapes, and colors that are all beautiful in their own way. In America, it is common to see women being advertised for beauty products. However, the main concern lies in the fact they are subjects of the “ideal beauty standard.” Beauty ads are a platform where advertisers attack on women’s “flaws” and bombard them with “cures” to help them become their definition of “beautiful.” For instance, the beauty industry convinces women that they need to look white. Whiteness is considered superior, and…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays