Analysis Of Questioning Technology By Feenberg

Great Essays
Unlike many of the writers that have been covered in this class, Feenberg does not feel the need to drown readers in a sea of senseless jargon in order to make a point (I am indeed referring to Haraway). Rather his goal is merely to challenge our common sense instincts on technology, hence the title ‘Questioning Technology’. Specifically, he is attempting to push against the initials views many may hold regarding the perceived neutrality and objectivity of technology, which leads many to envision a technocracy (a government run by technological experts) as an ideal system. His goal as I understand it, is to show that technology is not just an impartial observer, distinct from society, but an integral part of it, subject to both social changes and political movements. …show more content…
As the name suggests, it refers to the fairly simple idea that technology does not necessarily move in a fixed direction, but could potentially move in one of many directions. Ultimately, the direction it ends up taking can be said to be the result of one of many social battles. Feenberg decides to break it down into two general outcomes, the first of which is the preservation of the hierarchy. This is essentially, the ‘bad’ outcome, where those with power manage to perpetuate the power by controlling the development of technology. To him this outcome is the inevitable end of a technocracy. When you base your decisions on what seems to be best for technology, you are really just allowing the system to remain the way it is, which means it will favor the groups currently in power, and allow them to stay in

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Loren Eisley’s “The Bird and the Machine” takes a deeper look at the gap between rapidly developing technology, and the subsequent place that it’s taking in the world, as compared to the natural order of things. He expresses his opinion passionately and portrays the urgency of what he is saying using several effective rhetorical strategies. Though this essay includes strong appeals to pathos and is based on an interesting juxtaposition, he has created an overall weak piece because of an extremely lack-luster pattern of development, as well as a glaring absence of an appeal to logos or ethos. Though the content is strong, it lacks credibility and the reader quickly loses interest, and feels unsatisfied by the ending. That is not to discredit the content itself.…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Technology is overcoming our lives. It is tearing us from nature, and it is allowing us freedom to do as we please. Richard Louv does an acceptable job of explaining this in a passage from "Last Child in the Woods." He creates a cocktail of ideas and rhetoric alike to form a well thought out analysis of evolution of technology, mainly one of a car in his, versus the nature that surrounds us and a simpler time at that. Richard Louv begins his passage with a detailed version of advertisement.…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The View of Future Technology has become a trend that opens the doors to the exploration of surreal technological features. That places us closer to the future people imagined. However, this futuristic world could trap our lives. Instead of enjoying the sunlight and fresh air, we will imprison and control by machines. Everything, people, animals, plants, and objects will be monitoring by machines, and our body, thoughts, and decisions would not have anything to express.…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most of us couldn’t survive without technology. Our lives have become so dependent on it, but we can’t even acknowledge how dependent we have become. A great example would be the book Fahrenheit 451, the society has become so dependent on technology and it is their lifestyle. The theme of Fahrenheit 451 is that technology can change people's perspectives and opinions which are shown through Mildred’s attitude towards material items, Montag’s observations…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    (TS): Technology is dangerous because someone can get so involved in it that eventually technology will become that person's entire life, this is the major message that Ray Bradbury is stating throughout the story. (MIP-1) Technology is everywhere and the characters in the book live and survive on technology. (MIP-2) People become so involved in technology that they become inhuman. (MIP-3) People who step away from technology gain real emotions and memories. (AGG) In Fahrenheit 451 there are many types of technology that are used everyday such as tv’s, earbuds, long billboards and mechanical hounds.…

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “I Am So Totally Digitally Close to You” written by Clive Thompson and “Is Google Making Us Stupid?” by Nicholas Carr both delineate how technology has changed the way individuals interact with others and the way it influences ones point of view. Carr and Thompson also contrast because Carr finds with technology becoming a predominant source of information, the ability to focus and think critically is hindered while, Thompson shows how the use of social media on a daily basis can control lives. “I Am So Totally Digitally Close to You” and “Is Google Making Us Stupid” share similarities because technology has changed the way individuals interact with each other. In Thompson’s “I Am So Totally Digitally Close to You” he aims to explain why individuals are attracted to Facebook, Twitter and other forms of social media contact.…

    • 1243 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Today, technology has a positive effect on us as a whole, but the negative effects of technology are starting to dominate people. In history, many authors have written books in the attempt to convey the potential downsides of technology. Fahrenheit 451 could potentially be a crystal ball. Ray Bradbury foresaw the negative future of technology in an overly dramatic view. However, if technology is produced at the rate that Ray Bradbury predicted, there might be a problem.…

    • 1656 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How would you feel if you had no choice how to live? No choice on who to love? In Anthem & “Harrison Bergeron”, the society's were both based on, Equality. Although, “Harrison Bergeron” by Kurt Vonnegut & Anthem by Ayn Rand are both pieces of dystopian literatures, their portrayal of technology and love, differs greatly. Technology is a thing of the past, present, and as well as the future.…

    • 481 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Neil Postman expresses that society is affected in five major ways from the coming of technology; stating that first technology is a trade-off, second, technology is never distributed fairly, third there are forms of social and political prejudices in all technology, forth technology is not additive; but is ecological, and fifth, technology leads to become mythic. In the world’s society today, the five points of Neil Postman’s essay, is a tunneled viewpoint of specific events rather than the grand view of the global communities that have been affected by technology. Postman chose his study groups and viewpoints to help support his five claims. However, in doing so, he left his ideas narrow and opinions straightforward. He neglected to subject…

    • 1363 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The three women turned slowly and looked with unconcealed irritation and then dislike at Montag” (90) they were not paying attention to him and he knew it, so he pulled the T.V plug to get them away from the technology and truly listen to what he has to say. (STEWE-2) The technology is growing all around them and they do not even seem to care that soon everyone will have technology all around them “Technology, mass exploitation, and minority pressure carried the trick, thank God” (55). All that technology around them, they think that it is a good thing but they don't really realize how distracted they truly are.…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While I do not agree with the views of the authors, I do agree that technology will only continue to grow and there will be benefits. Although I see concerns with this article, I can also see the impact this situation will have on our society over time. In just the last decade, we have seen technology grow, and shrink immensely. By shrink, I mean we can fit what used to be a 60 pound computer system into our pockets. With the decrease in size, the increase in popularity seems to only be growing.…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nicholas Carr’s “Flame and Filament” is a piece of writing which seeks to outline the importance of candle light throughout history and emphasize that it still has a significant place in the modern world. Nicholas begins his story with an introduction to the history of artificial light and explains how the technology slowly evolved over the years, into the modern electrical light which has become of a staple of the world today. Throughout the story the author has added supporting details which effectively serve to communicate and his support the main idea by illustrating the examples he has included. Over all the author did a very good job of attempting to persuade the reader of the importance of candle light, however he failed to list its many shortcomings and therefore I do not agree.…

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Analysis: “The Judgment of Thamus” by Neil Postman Professor and writer, Neil Postman, in his story, “The Judgment of Thamus” claims that today’s technology has both positive and negative effects on society and the world as a whole. Postman starts out writing about the positives and negatives of technology but slowly drifts towards the negative side, attempting to persuade the audience into thinking that technology is harmful to society. Postman’s claim that technology has a multitude of negative effects on society is an overreaction that relies on a truly pessimistic world view. First, Postman introduces opinions of well known people such as Plato, Marshall McLuhan, and Freud to convince the audience that the arguments he states are valid. He builds a blunt view of technology by including some of these views on technology.…

    • 636 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Mark Bauerlein, author of The Dumbest Generation, argues in his controversial novel that America's rapidly developing technology and our growing dependence on it is destroying the minds of our youth. He alleges that today’s youth are losing the ability to think, as we slowly rely more and more on the comforts of computerized algorithms to think for ourselves. Despite my own biased view of Bauerleins viewpoints from the perspective as a literate and well-worded 16 year old living in an arguably virtual world, Bauerlein has some merit, but his perception of what intellect is, and isn’t is veiled, and his own biased maturity is questionable. It is an obvious allegation that technology has a great deal of influence on the lives of students.…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dystopian World Technology is very manipulating in the American Society today. As technology advances in the future, it could have more access and control to the citizens than it does now. There are different types of technology that is being used to make life so much easier, things that the human mind does not completely understand. Technology seems so wonderful until someone who is smart enough looks behind the scenes at what its’ purpose is really being used for. With technology having access to information that should not come into contact at all, will affect how a citizen will live.…

    • 1054 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics