Qualitative Critique Review
The research articles, “ Nursing, sexual health and youth with disabilities: a critical ethnography” is a qualitative nursing research. The article is a qualitative research because its aim is to gain a deeper understanding of the culture under research .It uses direct quotations of the participants to explain its findings. Janet McCabe and Dave Holmes, who are the authors of the article, collected and analyzed the data. Therefore, which makes it a primary sources. This paper will summarize the article; analyze the strengths and limitations of the study and how it relates to nursing practice. Article Summary
The article uses a poststructural theoretical framework…...
The purpose of the study was to investigate …show more content…
The sample included Registered nurses and social workers. The criteria for participation included: (1) occupation as a Registered nurse, physician or social worker; and (2) Currently working at any of the outpatient clinics at the institution. The invitation to take part in the study was extended to physicians and social workers because of the multidisciplinary approach used in the clinics and expertize these professions have in related to nursing work (McCabe & Holmes, 2013).
Data Collection Data was collected at an urban pediatrics rehabilitation facility in Canada over a period of four months in 2009. The authors collected the data using semi-structured interview with the participants, description and focused observation of the environment, collecting and analysis of documentary evidence and discussion with key informants. Each participates’ interview lasted on average of 45-60mins. Documentary evidence used contained information about job description, institutional policy and nursing notes (McCabe & Holmes, 2013).
Data Analysis The data was analyzed using coding, critical discourse analysis and development of analytic categories. Coding is linking raw data to theoretical concepts. Critical discourse analysis was used to evaluate transcripts, field notes and documentary evidence.
Results
Critique of Strength
Application to
The research articles, “ Nursing, sexual health and youth with disabilities: a critical ethnography” is a qualitative nursing research. The article is a qualitative research because its aim is to gain a deeper understanding of the culture under research .It uses direct quotations of the participants to explain its findings. Janet McCabe and Dave Holmes, who are the authors of the article, collected and analyzed the data. Therefore, which makes it a primary sources. This paper will summarize the article; analyze the strengths and limitations of the study and how it relates to nursing practice. Article Summary
The article uses a poststructural theoretical framework…...
The purpose of the study was to investigate …show more content…
The sample included Registered nurses and social workers. The criteria for participation included: (1) occupation as a Registered nurse, physician or social worker; and (2) Currently working at any of the outpatient clinics at the institution. The invitation to take part in the study was extended to physicians and social workers because of the multidisciplinary approach used in the clinics and expertize these professions have in related to nursing work (McCabe & Holmes, 2013).
Data Collection Data was collected at an urban pediatrics rehabilitation facility in Canada over a period of four months in 2009. The authors collected the data using semi-structured interview with the participants, description and focused observation of the environment, collecting and analysis of documentary evidence and discussion with key informants. Each participates’ interview lasted on average of 45-60mins. Documentary evidence used contained information about job description, institutional policy and nursing notes (McCabe & Holmes, 2013).
Data Analysis The data was analyzed using coding, critical discourse analysis and development of analytic categories. Coding is linking raw data to theoretical concepts. Critical discourse analysis was used to evaluate transcripts, field notes and documentary evidence.
Results
Critique of Strength
Application to