David Brooks Masculinity Analysis

Superior Essays
Society’s False Definition of Masculinity
While walking down the street, what is the first thing that comes to mind when a muscular teenage boy passes by in gym shorts, a cut off t-shirt, tall Nike socks, and basketball shoes? Yet when a scrawny teenage boy with a sweater vest, Walmart jeans, glasses, and champion sneakers passes by does that same thought come to mind? The same thought occurring is very unlikely with both boys giving off opposite eras about themselves. Typically the boy with the athletic apparel is going to give out a very masculine era, and the scrawny (most likely very intelligent) boy is going to convey more of an era that implies weakness. There is something wrong with this picture. How can it be that your typical jock,
…show more content…
Why is it that our young men and boys today are slowly dropping any interest in the education system or school itself? Could it be simply that women are motivated towards pursuing education and doing well more so than men are throughout high school and college? David Brooks gives references to data that has been collected on the female-male ratios of graduating college. In this, he makes several claims, one being that the most important piece of data is “Until 1985 or so, male college graduates outnumbered female college graduates. But in the mid-80s, women drew eve, and ever since they have been pulling away at a phenomenal rate.”(Mind over Muscle). The 1980s was known commonly as the second wave of feminism, where gender equality in the workplace came to be questioned. This wave of feminism was a major motivation for women pursuing careers in college, and it helped them to strive to become something great and to do well. In the article, Mind over Muscle, Brooks also makes a statement that, “Once upon a time, it was a man’s world.” And goes on to talk about how men had grasped all that they needed for power and success; however, when the information age came along that all of that changed. He then states, “In the information age, education is the gateway to success. And that means this is turning into a woman’s world, because women are better students than men.” That …show more content…
So, they follow the idea that if they possess strong athletic and gaming ability, and stay unmotivated to pursue an education and act courteous, they will not have to worry about it affecting their masculinity. In Putting Down the Gun, Rebecca Walker expresses her concern and alarmed feelings when her son comes home from school one day and tell her that “Maybe girls will like me if I play sports.” Her son then goes on to tell her that, “Boys talk about sports, like their matches and who scored what and stuff, or they talk about new versions of computer games or tricks they learned to get to higher levels.” As he started to get teary he says, “I don’t have anything to talk about.” Walker is then dismayed as to how it can be her son who is intuitive, smart, and creative beyond belief can go unnoticed simply because he has no interest in sports, and is not allowed to play video games. After realizing what is going on she says, “The truth of his existence, his many likes and dislikes, none of them having to do with winning or killing of any kind, had no social currency.” Her son was not seen as masculine, and not wanted to be around simply because he had no interest in the things society tells boys and young men makes them manly. Theroux makes references towards how the manly attitude towards sports has a negative impact on athletes and their lives by stating, “Everyone is aware of how few in number are the athletes who behave like

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Male Role Models Vastly Shape Young Men’s Views on Masculinity Where does one’s masculinity come from? This is one of the key questions addressed in Wes Moore’s book The Other Wes Moore. This book contains the coming of age stories of the author and another man named Wes Moore, who begin in similar circumstances but ultimately have two vastly different fates. The masculinity portrayed by Wes Moore and the Other Wes Moore’s male role models as they grew up led them to develop very different views of manhood, and their stories show that in the United States familial male role models play a large role in the construction of young men 's masculinity.…

    • 1206 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the year 1827, Mary Easton Sibley and her husband George Sibley founded the institution that is today known as Lindenwood University in St. Charles, Missouri. For 142 years, Lindenwood University was known as Lindenwood College for Women; then the board made the decision to include men in the enrollment. In this paper I will argue that women protested the allowance of men on campus in the years 1968 and 1969 because of current underlying tension that was already happening in the country. For so many years, men had the advantage of schooling and getting an education that included more than cooking, sewing, and other skills that were considered detrimental for women to know.…

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The story, under first impression, shows hard work is efficient enough to gain wealth. However, sober, honesty, and industrious are defined in the books section about character and morality. This affects the young male readers as it allows masculinity to define one’s work ethic, wages, and profession. By including these testaments, a reader is inclined to embody honesty and industrious qualities to become this “successful professional man” and to raise their own socioeconomic position to meet this idealized form of masculinity. However, a counterpoint to this example is found in the article “Effects of Wealth on Morals” which is included in The Contributor, a literary magazine designated for young men.…

    • 1710 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Judith Sargent Murray

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Judith Sargent Murray very efficiently debunks the idea that men and women are not equal in their intellect in her essay “Equality of the sexes”. During the 17th and 18th century, women we’re viewed as lesser than men in society. Young girls did not receive the same education as young boys, leaving them at a disadvantage. Because of this, women were forced into doing the domestic jobs in society, such as, sewing, cooking and cleaning. Murray find it preposterous that women are treated so differently and looked down upon in society.…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This shows that women now were more independent in society; they were getting the same education as men. It established that females are smart and intelligent, talented, and prepared for anything. The Times also noted that “ Both schools have shown no real disparity in men’s and women’s performance. Students at Columbia, though, have compiled a petition asking the school to hire more female faculty.” This suggests that more women faculty were required at universities and…

    • 963 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Summary Of Masculinity

    • 1618 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Gender roles and performance are often the first visual cues many people have when meeting another person. This seems to have been a primary concern for many young gay men in Lawrence and Ames. Members of society discovering they are queer based on their appearance and mannerisms. In Lawrence a young gay man wrote a coming-out story in the Vortex that discussed his struggle not only with homosexuality but with his effeminacy. He said for many people it was his rejection of masculinity that was the hardest to grasp.…

    • 1618 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Marc Feigen Fasteau stated “The male stereotype makes masculinity not just a fact of biology but something that must be proved and re-proved, a continual quest for an ever-receding Holy Grail”. Throughout history men have always searched for what it truly means to be a masculine man, especially in America. Understanding and researching the true meaning of being a man can be deciphered in the American literature we read today. By reading The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Grapes of Wrath by John Steinbeck, and Billy Lynn’s Long Halftime Walk by Ben Fountain it becomes easier to understand this ongoing question. These American authors reinforce high masculinity standards through their use of tough, strong, and wealthy stereotypes.…

    • 2493 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    The article, “Men, Masculinities, and Feminism” explains that men can be privileged in society but still lose privilege because of certain characteristics that oppress them. The authors, Christopher J. Greig and Barbara A. Pollard (2017) elaborate this explaining that even though men have power based on their gender, their privilege is challenged and ranked within their sex. This can be seen by a social hierarchy that oppresses those who aren’t considered to be as masculine as other Men. Men are pressured by other men to perform actions that are masculine, such as displaying dominance by being aggressive, to secure a higher status. Throughout their life, they are constantly fighting to prove their masculine standing in society so that they…

    • 1285 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nearing the end of his analysis Worster writes that “This professional definition of a real man as a persistent closer becomes easily and consistently fused with the sexual definition of a real man as an accomplished sexual aggressor.” (382) This concept of sexual aggression becomes quite clear when Levene tells Williamson that he, “can 't run an office” because he doesn’t “have the balls.” (2.1) There is an inherent dual meaning in what Levene is saying. There’s first the colloquial understanding that Williamson is not strong enough to run a business because his anatomy doesn’t prove him to be a man.…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Its 2016, forty-four years after the Education Amendment of 1972 had been approved, and many would believe that men would happen to have the majority in education, sports, and the workplace. A lot of people would think that Colleges and Universities would be offering more majors that are strictly known to the public as being only for men. Women would have the chance to go to college, but would not get the same equality as men, especially when it comes to scholarships, grades, and opportunities. Because of the lack of opportunities, many people would agree that women would stop trying to push the boundaries because they would start to understand that they’re not as important as men…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the most dominant ideologies in contemporary societies, is that women are more emotional than men, thus the notions of the "emotional woman" and the "unemotional man". Butler (1990) and Connell (1995) argues that femininity and masculinity are a matter of performance in nature, meaning that they are both subjects to heterosexual norms that are created and imposed upon us through education and social relationships. Due to gender emotions behaviour being socially constructed and the fact that society changes over time, it is fair to say that the way men and women expressed their feelings in the past might not be the same as it is today. The aim of this essay will therefore be firstly to discuss the gender differences in the expression…

    • 156 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Masculinity is, by definition, qualities and/or the appearance traditionally associated with men, especially strength and aggressiveness. This makes men have to appear to be bellicose or tough to impress society and prove themselves as being ‘manly’ men. Making it very difficult for young men and boys to truly express themselves and let others into their personal lives. Crying, self expression, and asking for help are healthy traits for the growth of young boys and men. Without them, young boys could very potentially not be mentally healthy, and may become hostile and unable to connect to other human beings later on in life.…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article I have chosen to read was Disappearing Act by Michael Gurian. This article specifically focused on how the male attendance at universities and higher learning institutions has changed dramatically over the years. For example, up until the late 1800’s women were not able to further their education. Perhaps the author wrote this article because he wanted to bring it to the audience’s attention about how the drop in male attendance has been increasing over the past couple years. But in order to get a better understanding we will first discuss issues that can be seen from the early school years, then we will look at what the universities and institutes were like then and finally, we will see what the universities and institutes look…

    • 1135 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout history, women were consistently being undervalued by men. Also, women are always at a disparity and an impediment towards all the men. A colossal amount of opportunities went to men, even in the contemporary era. Henceforth, it wasn't until recently that women have been able to get educated. As early as the 1800s, women weren't permitted to get an education.…

    • 1950 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is simply naïve to disregard the overwhelming influence that the media and literature has had over the public over the past century and more precisely, in our youth. As a society, we constantly twist ourselves to fit the mold presented to us through various media outlets (e.g. TV, movies, magazines, advertisements, etc.) and in literature we encounter in our lives for a multitude of reasons. Throughout time, men have been presented to fit very traditionally masculine traits based on a preconceived narrative as to what it means to be a man and how to present oneself in order to be perceived as manly by others. Media and literature have branded a hyper-masculine image of men that has in time become what is expected for young boys to follow––be it relayed to them or not.…

    • 1001 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays