The Pros And Cons Of Holistic Education

Decent Essays
It is a common cry through America that public schools are failing children. Some parents try homeschooling or enrolling children in charter schools, but for many families, that is not feasible. Though parents and politicians want better public schools for their children, the suggested changes do not tend to stay beneficial for long. This is because the focus problem solvers take is on the system and money, not the children or how the system is implemented.
Most American public schools are not the best they can be for a myriad of reasons. Rote memorization is the main method of teaching children, not informing them why they need to know or how it may affect the students aside from getting a decent grade. Money is spent on luxuries such as
…show more content…
Several call for better budgeting, and a few others call for a “trend” of holistic education in neighborhoods. In holistic education a higher emphasis is placed on the children and community, which lets students learn in different ways which may let their education stick with them longer. The school becomes just one part of the way they learn, extending to the neighborhood around them and letting the parents be a part of their childrens’ education. But implementation in poorer neighborhoods is expensive and requires cooperation from the parents and community for their involvement. Levine and Wilson, both involved with Boston’s holistic education policy “The Circle of Promise,” note in their essay “Poverty, Politics, and a ‘Circle of Promise’: Holistic Education Policy in Boston and the Challenges of Institutional Entrenchment,” that an additional flaw with implementing holistic education is that policy makers make the assumption that non-profit organizations in the area would have excess funds to invest in the holistic policy (13). This is not to say that such a system cannot work, rather that it will need some …show more content…
Budgeting the school’s money better would be a start. Finding out what curriculums work with the students and teachers best before implementing them gives a better chance for more learning to happen. Less spending and better grades occur when school and homework is not seen as a daunting task, so fostering a child’s desire to learn his or her topics outside of school puts less responsibility on the system itself. Finally, a greater focus needs to be put on the child, not just his or her results on a score sheet. Students are humans, not machines on an assembly line, therefore they should be treated as such. Bob Cornett, a former bureaucrat argues in his essay “A Need for Human Logic in Education” that for reform to be useful, politicians must take a step back and address schooling as a human problem that requires human thinking. Appealing to a wide range of learning styles and understanding how much of a workload interferes with healthy development leads to better students. Many children also need direction for life after school. Helping students figure their potential future out early aids the child before he or she wastes a college semester on classes for something he or she does not want to do. Several others know what they want as a career, but school does not provide the tools and skills needed for it. Teaching critical thinking and other life skills gives the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    For decades Diane Ravitch was a tremendous supporter and proponent of school reform, advocating for government and privatized educational reforms such as America 2000, No Child Left Behind (NCLB), accountability, and charter schools. The ideas of reconstructing and reorganizing the public school system seemed like it was too good to be true; and Ravitch realized that this vision was in fact just that. Through Ravitch’s experiences, she has been exposed to the truth of the reforms that took place from the 1960’s to present day and just how damaging these attempts at improving the system can really be. As a result of these findings, Diane Ravitch raises the subject of just how the American education system is progressively failing its students…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Laurence Steinberg article, “What’s Holding Back American Teenagers?” Steinberg talks about the importance of education and how there is a big problem we all aren’t seeing. We think the problem is making school more affordable which is an issue but it’s not the problem. Throughout time, many kids have improved in elementary and middle school by challenging themselves but when they get to high school it goes downhill. Adults think that the problem in the education system is providing affordable education to their kids, so the government gives them charter and public schools.…

    • 1034 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Per Becker Summary

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages

    183). Included in the hands-on research, the writer also uses any many tables to confirm his data. From school funding from year to year and on a three-year period, Koval breaks down the statistical profiles of each city school he visited. What I take away from this book is exactly how he advocated for those who don’t have a voice.…

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “We cannot provide equal educational opportunity if some children get access to a full and balanced curriculum while others get a heavy dose of basic skills (Ravitch 108).” Using logos, Ravitch makes the audience realize that it is simply unacceptable for a country as advanced as the United States to have such a huge discrepancy in education depending on whether or not you go to a private school. Private schools have the necessary funding in order to offer a wide variety of classes to their students. Public schools get funding from the government and hard economic times have caused their budgets to shrink. With a decreased budget…

    • 1041 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In today’s society, education equals freedom. Without putting forth more effort to properly educate children, the children will be easy prey for any person trying to persuade them. While many people do talk about the educational crisis in America, there is no effort from those people to change the situation. Benjamin Barber delves deeper into the problem in his article “America Skips School.” Barber explains exactly how American children have become intellectually inferior and supplies ideas to fix the situation.…

    • 889 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Stakes Is High Summary

    • 2361 Words
    • 10 Pages

    In order to improve educational opportunities we must be willing to partner with communities and let those within the community to help guide us as to what they need, as well as come to terms with our own biases and prejudices. Gorski lays out an outline of how one can implement an education that can be just for all through high expectations, high student engagement, parental involvement, incorporation of art and movement, focus on family strengths, analyze materials for biases, promote literacy enjoyment, and reach out more to families for the positives instead of the…

    • 2361 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    In today’s society, the American education system is not at its peak; it’s corrupt and polluted with twisted appeals towards money and business. This makes a real education hard to earn, but easy to be handed over via a sheet of paper. Unfortunately, there’s not much individuals can do except raise awareness and hope for a fix. One individual, Mark Edmundson, a professor at the University of Virginia, discusses these ideas in a book titled Why Teach?…

    • 1901 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Kandice Sumner’s Ted Talk, How America's public schools keep kids in poverty, she passionately delivers a message about the “education debt” (Sumner, 2015) that many schools, especially those in poor neighborhoods are suffering from. Through her experience as a both a teacher and a student, she constructs an influential speech that argues that we need to help and change the school system, as to include kids of minority races and give equal opportunities to each and every student. Unlike some kids, I have lived outside of New Mexico, I have experienced different things, gone to different schools, and seen different cultures. I have seen the difference in resources, first-hand, in which some of the schools I have been to had many resources…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Public Education Failure

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The road to learning for American children (K-12) is currently filled with potholes and obstacles which prevent students from learning to their full potential and from progressing from one grade level to the next based on knowledge acquired. Many children are promoted each year despite their lack of meeting grade level expectations. I speak for my friend who barely graduated from high school and is now lucky to have a menial job working for Walmart. I speak for my cousin who could have used more help in school and now has five children, possibly destined to live off the state. I speak for my neighbor, a little girl in the fifth grade and only reading at a third grade level while the school refuses to provide extra help because she is progressing.…

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    No school wants their kids to be beat up, not learn anything, be overwhelmed, or have a bad educational experience. Schools want to give their students a good education so they get into a college of their choice, reach their goals, and have an successful career and life after high-school. Many people argue public schools are better, and others argue private schools are better. There are millions of parents switching their kids school system during one year. The debate between public schools and private schools is ongoing with differences and similarities including the securities of their environments, government affiliation with the school system, standardized tests, and the school's…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    significant indicator of the charter movements successes. “Parents want choice in education, and the overwhelming majority of parents who choose charter schools are happy with that choice.” (Richwine, 3) Even though these schools generally have the smaller class sizes and other things that families believe is important to them, Richwine found that the reading and math test scores did not rise as a result of attending these schools. This means, that most charter schools, in addition to public schools, are “failing” their students. Richwine posited that “test scores are notoriously hard to raise through intervention” and that traditional methods of doing so in public schools has failed.…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Our school system has taken a back burner to more important than being able to receive the funding and the required materials to share the knowledge that is needed. Teachers and Schools are being unappreciated while the members of the government receive hefty paychecks. “In 1999 one- quarter of the U.S. public schools reported that the conditions of at least one of their building was inadequate” (Moore 130). The governments wants the educational system to work but how when they give these schools nothing to work with. “ in New York almost 15 percent of the eleven hundred public schools are without full-time custodians, forcing teachers to mop their own floors and students to do without toilet paper” (Moore 130).…

    • 1236 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Poverty In America

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The issue that I chose was the economic issue. This is an issue that really affects Americans because we all have to have money and work with money everyday. But, there are money problems that occur in the U.S. As a country we tend to want a more capitalistic government, but, “no one believes that private businesses should be completely unregulated or that the things people value should be allocated exclusively by an unfettered free market.” (book)…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    California Public Education Essay Nelson Mandela once stated, “Children are our greatest treasure. They are our future”. This statement has proven to be correct with each generation leaving new ideas and innovations for the world. However, the fact that children are the future could not only be positive, but also negative if they are not educated properly and effectively. Due to a reduction in investment of California education, lack of proficient teaching, and big class sizes, the statewide standard of public education has decreased.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Purpose Of Education

    • 950 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Education today, in my opinion, is not doing what it should be doing to ensure that America is actually living up to what it is known for...the land of opportunities. I believe that education should be about an empowering experience that helps students discover their passions, fosters their critical thinking skills, promotes an environment that accepts diversity, and encourages students to apply to skills to the outside world. This should be he purpose of American public schooling because it will help society adapt to changing times and encourage the growth of a well-rounded, modern, and accepting culture which in the long run help foster peace and equality. I am sure that there are many schools in America that try and foster all of things,…

    • 950 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays