The Ethics Of Human Cloning

Improved Essays
Cloning is the process of creating a new organism that is genetically identical to a single common ancestor. Genetic information from a single parent organism is copied. Cloning is done by nuclear transfer, which is when the nucleus of an egg is removed and replaced with a nucleus from a donor cell. Energy is created in order to jumpstart the cells to start dividing. There are two types of cloning: Therapeutic cloning and Reproductive cloning. Therapeutic cloning is when the cloned cells are harvested shortly after dividing in order to grow new tissues for organ transplant and treat diseases like Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s. Reproductive cloning involves creating an identical organism through somatic cell nuclear transfer, and then destroying …show more content…
Trying to clone human embryos for stem cells has ignited a controversy over the ethics of embryo experiments. Much of the human cloning debate lies in the question “When does human life begin, and what is the moral status of the human embryo?” Stem cells are talked about so much because they can grow into any of the body’s cell types. They can therefore be used to replace tissues and organs for people with disease like Diabetes and Parkinson’s. The controversial part about the process of Therapeutic cloning is that after the cells are extracted, the embryos are destroyed. It is possible that the embryo being destroyed could potentially be a human being; therefore attempting Therapeutic cloning could take a human life. According to nytimes.com, “A drawback of therapeutic cloning is that there might never be enough human eggs available to treat all patients, should the therapy ever work. Egg donors can suffer serious side effects from the powerful hormones needed to generate multiple …show more content…
A quote from Cardinal Sean O’Malley was included, saying that human cloning is immoral because it “treats human beings as products, manufactured to order suit to other people’s wishes.” The article then goes on to talk about the benefits of therapeutic cloning when discussing the fact that they can be used for diseases. It ends with the drawbacks of Therapeutic cloning in that there may not be enough donor eggs. Both sides of the argument are successfully shown in this article and I do not believe the author showed any bias towards the topic he presented. This story is relevant to society as a whole because it shows how even though cloning can be beneficial to some, there are others who believe cloning is immoral and unnecessary. Articles like this can be read by anybody to inform them about topics on Biotechnology that are being experimented on. Researching and understanding the facts about cloning and both the benefits and challenges to it can help skeptics decide where they stand. Without the approval of enough people, further research is impossible. The need for money and donor cells are crucial for cloning and this controversy can hinder the process of being able to clone human beings. The article was clear and thorough enough for a nonscientist to get a general understanding of the topic and controversy; However, I did not get a full and complete understanding of how cloning is

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Human Cloning Controversy

    • 1852 Words
    • 7 Pages

    There is a lot of controversy regarding the Catholic Church and Human Cloning. With more research and scientific advances, it may be possible in the near future to clone human beings. Obviously, the ethical problems that arise must be put into consideration. According to the National Human Genome Research Institute, “cloning describes several processes that can be used to produce genetically identical copies of a biological entity.” Scientifically, human cloning is similar and the only difference is that the biological entity is human beings. On the other hand, morally, human cloning is very different and has different moral implications. Human cloning is against the Church because the human clone was not conceived in a natural way, through…

    • 1852 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most of us will readily agree that it should be allowed and could prove to be useful. Where this agreement usually ends, however, is on the question of will it actually work, and be useful. Were as some are convinced that it will work, others maintain that it won’t. It takes away our own unique sense of individuality. I stand on the line of it won’t work and even if it does it shouldn’t be allowed. It’s basically stealing one 's identity. Most importantly, it defies nature preventing the genetic differences that occur within a species to take place allowing it to survive. In many cases like the one from the article “The Cloning Controversy” “Opponents called for a ban on human cloning research, arguing that cloning offers few benefits to science while requiring unacceptable risks and undermining our very concept of humanness.” Readers can clearly take away that our humanness comes from our natural births and our individuality. Who are we to take away that right to our uniqueness? We are also taking away our own natural ability to provide a better chance of survival by the genetic differences provided by sexual reproduction. Many arguments have been made in the past on why cloning is ethical, but in retrospect they are wrong. In this case the pro’s do not outweigh the con’s. Arguments have been made stating that cloning could save lives, but it would jeopardize many more than it would save the scientists from the article “The Cloning Debate. Should All Forms Of Human Cloning Be Banned?” State “Many experts say reproductive cloning is grossly unethical because it jeopardizes the health of would-be child clones. They note that efforts to clone sheep, pigs, goats and other animals yield few live births, and that many live-born mammal clones die within weeks or months because of abnormalities.” If humans were to reproduce through cloning we would have very little success and the children would not live for very long. Why…

    • 1745 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Human Cloning Essay

    • 1744 Words
    • 7 Pages

    According to the University of Nebraska, gene cloning refers to when DNA is removed from an organism. Enzymes are then used to break the bonds between nucleotides and are snipped into gene size pieces. Plasmids are combined with the genes and transferred into living bacteria. The bacteria can be manipulated to create millions of copies of the same plasmid. Gene cloning is usually associated with gene modification which occurs when a genetic engineer cuts the gene and replaces some of it with new material. Reproductive cloning happens when a mature somatic cell is removed from an organism, and the DNA is transferred to an egg cell whose DNA has been removed. This is commonly referred to as somatic cell nuclear transfer or SCNT. Finally, the egg starts the reproductive process and attaches to the uterus of a female in the same species. This results in a whole organism with the same genetic makeup of the donator of the somatic cell (See Appendix B for a diagram of the process). The last type, therapeutic cloning, occurs when a cell is taken from an animal’s skin and is placed in the outer membrane of a donor egg cell. After being chemically induced, embryonic stem cells will be created. The stem cells can be used in discovering more about diseases and developing treatments for them (Bradford,…

    • 1744 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Science fiction has also given cloning a bad name. Many people automatically assume the worst upon hearing the word “cloning” uttered. Such books like A Brave New World and Rosemary’s Baby paint a dark and scary painting of a future with clones. On the other slightly more optimistic hand, many people think that cloning could be beneficial to the world. Supporters of cloning think that if a man and a woman want to have a child they should be able to have one. They also want to help couples chances in any way that can be ethically justified. A woman with a single embryo only has around a 10% to 20% chance of becoming pregnant through in-vitro fertilization, a complicated compilation of procedures used to treat fertility. If an embryo were cloned, the woman’s chances of childbirth would be increased vastly. The side I chose to support is the side of continuing to explore the possibilities of cloning. I think that the opinion of this essay can be briefed by a quote from Tim Caulfield, the research director at the University of Alberta. “You don’t ban fertilizer because you can use it to make bombs. Don’t ban cloning because it may be abused.…

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the article “Ethical Issues of Cloning” by Rita Putatunda explains about the problems of cloning. Copying the genes and making new reproductions of the human is equivalent to “playing God”. The successful cloning of Dolly (Sheep) in 1997 brings many tension upon society and furthers the possibility of human cloning. However, there is a high failure rate of cloning and it may alter the genes of the cloned animal/human. Putatunda questions that the cloning outcome might act as a unique individual or have to live like a genetic prisoner. The possibility of cloning does have its advantages such as cloning organs to replace or repair the damaged ones. Despite the fact of cloning having its advantages, cloning are against the basic beliefs of…

    • 156 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cloning is a cell, cell product, or organism that is genetically identical to the unit or individual it is derived from. During the process of cloning, a piece of DNA is cut from its source with a restriction enzyme. Then, the DNA is put into a vector ( a DNA molecule used to transport genetic material into another cell). The vector is introduced to a host cell by the process called transformation, then the host cell copies the vector DNA with the original DNA; creating copies of the inserted DNA. After the DNA is done copying, it is then removed from the host cell and purified cell.…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “More than 123,000 people are waiting for organ transplants. Some won’t receive a transplant in time, some suffer through years of pain and medical care before finally receiving the transplant they need, and others are rejected the opportunity of a transplant because they don’t meet the criteria. The average waiting time for a heart transplant is 4 years, a kidney transplant 5 years, and a liver transplant 11 years,” (Life Donor Program). Although theologians, politicians, preachers, and the medical community wrestle with the ethical ramifications of therapeutic cloning, the medical benefits outweigh the ethical concerns. Due to the research and technology today, scientists have learned that they are able to take stem cells from a patient and grow organs and tissue that are explicit to their own DNA so there’s no risk of rejection. Therapeutic cloning also has the potential to cure illnesses that as of now have no cure and take the lives of hundreds of thousands every year. Scientists are able to get stem cells without harming babies,…

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Unlike reproductive cloning, therapeutic cloning does not involve creating full copies of organisms. Instead, it involves taking stem cells from an embryo and using them to make an entire organ that could replace the organ of a patient, rather than needing to find someone to donate an organ. However, religious activists have been consistently opposed to stem cell research and therapeutic cloning because the human embryo is destroyed after its stem cells are removed (Jensen 2). It is an interesting predicament where killing a life that is not fully developed can help save a person who is in need of an organ transplant. Personally, I believe that therapeutic cloning and the use of stem cells is ethical because it is used to help save a person’s life, whether by creating an organ that the person needs or by curing genetic diseases such as Parkinson’s that have so far been…

    • 1366 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The reproductive cloning of human embryos is largely considered unethical because a human clone would have a greatly decreased quality of life; clones often suffer from genetic and physical abnormalities, and have greatly shortened lifespans. Others fear that the reproductive cloning of human embryos has the potential to be abused. In theory, one could create human clones for purpose of organ harvesting. For these reasons, many countries have halted research on the reproductive cloning of humans.…

    • 254 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As you know, I am writing this letter to discuss the issues on cloning. Cloning is an issue that is debated by people who think it is an ethical issue and by people who are just greedy for their own benefit. In other words, people who support cloning are not aware of how wrong it is to make a clone, kill it off for its stem cells, and eventually create another clone. People must not have thought much about it since scientists are cloning just animals, however, if human beings were to be cloned all over the place, there would be an uproar. I will expand on how this cloning procedure does not meet the ethical standards. I hope you will make your decisions regarding this issue.…

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Reproductive cloning is the use of cloning to grow a living person who shares the DNA of the progenitor. Live animals have been cloned using fission (in the cattle industry) and SCNT (e.g. Dolly the sheep). There are currently no confirmed cases of deliberate cloning of a human embryo that was allowed to grow into a live baby. However, many countries (e.g. the UK, Australia)…

    • 128 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although it poses a world of "what-if" possibilities for those that have trouble conceiving or those that seek treatment for genetic diseases that are deemed incurable, the practice of somatic cell nucleus transfer is not ethical. The reasons why consist of many it is morally unethical rely on numerous factors. First and most important fact in my eyes is the creation of life to just destroy that life for research. This therapeutic cloning is legal in some states, but requires the destruction of the embryo after the stem cell harvest. I do not believe anyone should have the power other than God Himself to take a life that does not belong to them.…

    • 257 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When Cloning Is Wrong

    • 1275 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Have you ever wondered what the long term effects would be if cloning was legalized? Maybe the risks involved with it? Well, Leon Kass once stated that “Cloning represents a very clear, powerful, and immediate example in which we are in danger of turning procreation into manufacture.” This being said brings up the topic of whether cloning should be legalized due to the dangers it holds. The answer to this is no. However, Many people disagree. A copious amount of people believe that there can be benefits to parents who cannot conceive children of their own, extra organs for those who need them, and advancements in the field of technology. None of these reasons are good enough to support the legalization of cloning. The reasons that cloning should…

    • 1275 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this article the text states “Animal cloning has proved to be very inefficient, with 277 attempts needed to create Dolly. There is no reason to think that human cloning would be any more successful. The United States and United Kingdom have had many cases against cloning. Most people (not all) have not accepted human cloning.” If cloning is becoming a problem to human beings then it is best if it is banned. For example, in the article it states “Animal cloning has proved to be very inefficient”. If cloning is not efficient or to the point when it is close to efficient then there is no use risking human…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Genetic Cloning also known as human cloning or Reproductive cloning can be for cures for disease and other health problems. Well for Therapeutic Cloning, also a type of genetic cloning, this takes a genetic material from an adult cell and is then placed inside an egg to grow beneficial stem cells, not to produce a baby. But to allow a patient’s own genetic material to be used to…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays