Pros And Cons Of The Virginia Plan

Decent Essays
Danny Nguyen
Professor Butler
Political Science 1
3-27-2016
Summarized Plans
The Virginia Plan. The Virginia plan was first drafted by James Madison and the Governor of Virginia Edmund Randolph presented the plan at the Constitutional Convention in 1787. During the Convention, Edmund Randolph argued, "that governments lack the power to defend itself from the intrusion of other state’s rights under the Article of Confederation.” (Levy). However revising the article into The Virginia Plan will create a stronger government among the establishment of the three legislative branches. The plan will have two houses and would be allocated based on state’s population, as well as, granting power onto congress to enact and veto state laws by its council consisting of executives and judges. The plan also gave congress the authority to use force against other states that were uncooperative.
…show more content…
William Patterson introduced the New Jersey Plan at the Constitutional Convention in June of 1787. “Patterson wanted to improve upon the Article of Confederation and to allow each state to be run independently, rather than being control by a large body state.” (Roche). This means that the plan will allow each state regardless of the amount of population, to have one vote and allow for the same amount of representative in all states, selected by a legislature. The plan will also give congress the power to raise money through tariffs of imported goods, and Judiciary body of the government will regulate commerce with other nations. The plan will state the Article of Confederation (Federal Law), as a supreme law and allow the authorized use of military force towards any states that defy the law. The New Jersey plan will force the government to take oath in order to support the Article of Confederation and create a policy to handle any

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    There are 3 main plans to replace the articles of confederation the Virginia Plan, New Jersey Plan, and the Connecticut Compromise. The first plan is the Virginia Plan this plan was introduced by Edmund Randolph and helped the bigger states. It had 3 branches the Executive, Legislative, and Judicial but it centred around the Legislative branch. It had a lower and upper house. The lower house was picked by popular vote and the upper house was picked by a list of people who were nominated by the states.…

    • 342 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Virginia plan provided that the congress should compromised by two houses and the representation would be based on the population of states. However, New Jersey plan called for the equal representation. Finally, the government with three separate branches and two houses was included…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He would represent Virginia and would inform the committee of his government plan he had to offer. He proposed a government system that consisted of three branches of government. This system was called the Virginia plan and had a legislative, executive, and judicial branch of government. Some states did not like Randolph’s proposal and declined the offer. However, Randolph was determined to get his plan to be a working system in the future for the United States.…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Convention Dbq

    • 515 Words
    • 3 Pages

    6) After deciding on the rules that would govern the proceedings, delegates prepared to hear proposals on the critical issue that led to the convention: amending and improving the Articles of Confederation. They ended up writing the constitution. Therefore it exceeded its authority. 7) Would the United States have been better off if the Virginia Plan had been adopted as presented? a) States with a large population, like Virginia (which was the most populous state at the time), would thus have more representatives than smaller states.…

    • 515 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of these was known as the Madison’s Virginia Plan. This was by James Madison who was from Virginia. A national form of government should be established consisting of the branches Legislative, Executive and Judiciary. This type of government was very different than that of the Confederation. The delegates were set very much in their ways that they voted to accept this after only a very little…

    • 485 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Ms. Berkin also noted that George Washington was seen as a hero and a nationalist by the people, so he was very well liked. This contributed to the election of George Washington, as the president of the convention. James Madison, one of our founding father and who later serve as our 4th president, rafted a new form of government; That was presented by Governor Edmund Randolph, and named the Virginia Plan. It called for a strong central government, with legislative branches that had the right to tax. They were trying to create a government that would have the power to control trade, regulate commerce and the economy, and protect its citizens from harm.…

    • 1306 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The New Jersey Plan Essay

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages

    What type of representation did the Virginia Plan call for? The type of representation the Virginia call for is the “proportional representation” where states that have larger population will have more representative than the states that have smaller population. It means that states with more number of people would have more to say in the politics and would receive more representatives. 3) How was the Virginia Plan connected to slavery?…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Due to the “Articles of Confederation” inability to tax, and the rising debt, Alexander Hamilton, and James Madison organized a conference at Annapolis in 1786. They planned a convention at Philadelphia to revise the constitution to make it more efficient. Two plans for the new government were discussed. The “Virginia Plan” included an executive and a judicial branch of two houses. The lower house representatives would be assigned by state according to population then the lower house would elect an upper house.…

    • 601 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This would give states representation based on proportionate population. They also considered the New Jersey Plan. This plan proposed a single house legislative where any state, regardless of size, would have the same representation. John P. Roche puts forth his thoughts that the founding Fathers were…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    However, the distribution of representation from the Virginia and New Jersey Plan widely differed. The Virginia Plan was highly represented by the more populous states within the federal government and the New Jersey Plan seemed to provide most of their representation through smaller states who wanted to prevent unbalancing the United…

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dbq Debate

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Prior to The Great Compromise of 1787, the two main plans put forth at the Constitutional Convention were the Virginia Plan and the New Jersey Plan. The larger states favored the Virginia Plan, as the number of representatives in both houses of Congress per state was based strictly on population, giving them more power. The smaller states preferred the New Jersey Plan, which ensured that all states had the same number of votes. The Great Compromise, which became the basis of the new American government, was possible through the coming together of the small states and the large states. In this new plan, the number of representatives per state in the lesser House was based on population and the number of representatives in the upper House was the same for each state, satisfying both sides of the debate (Lapsansky-Werner, 356).…

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1776 the Second Continental Congress began to draft the plans for the government of the new nation that would be formed after the colonies gained their independance. The plan that the congress created is called the Articles of Confederation. The Articles of Confederation created a confederal form of government, consisting of a loose union of 13 states, each with their own governments. However, despite the founder’s good intentions the government formed under the Articles of confederation is considered a failure, because it had minimal powers, did not have a chief executive or national court, and could not effectively raise funds for the national treasury. The biggest fear of the delegates at the Second Continental Congress was government overreach, and tyranny.…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Pros And Cons Of The New Constitution

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    • 7 Works Cited

    Small states were in favour of New Jersey Plan, under which all states would have equal representation in the legislature. On the other hand, large states advocate the Virginia Plan to form a Bicameral (two-house) legislature in which representatives would be appointed according to population. The Great Compromise between the states gave rise to a bicameral Congress in which states were given equal representation in the Senate and proportional representation in the House of Representatives. Roger Sherman played a decisive role in success of Philadelphia Convention. He is remembered as the architect of the Connecticut Compromise.…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    • 7 Works Cited
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Luke Stafford PS 110 7/21/15 States and Federal Government Rights Does the Federal government have too much control? Is the Federal Government oppressive to the people and States of America? Or are states’ rights well protected in the constitution and political practice? To answers any of these questions, we need to look back and see what the Constitution is and the path that was taken by the founders to where we ended up with the Constitution.…

    • 1401 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the first issues that was faced in the convention was how the states would represented in the legislature. James Madison drafted the Virginia Plan as a proposal to address this. The Virginia Plan was put before the convention by Edmund Randolph and proposed the government to be made into three different branches: legislative, executive, and judicial. Of these branches, the people would vote in the members of the two legislative branches, and then the cabinet members of the legislative branches…

    • 1141 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays