Pros And Cons Of Black Organ Trade

Superior Essays
Imagine yourself in a situation where you are literally dying for an organ and the hospital is unable to supply you with the organ that could save your life. Would you rather suffer in pain or would you turn to the black market to live? Picture yourself in the poorest place in America and you have a perfectly functioning organ and you need to make money fast or else you will be evicted from your home, would you rather wait another few weeks to get your paycheck and risk the chance of getting evicted, or would you sell the organ? These are just some of the situations black market donors and recipients have to endure. Black market organ selling can be defined as purchasing, selling, or obtaining any organ in an illegal manner and some claim that black market organ trade is unethical. Black Market organ trade should …show more content…
For starters, black market organ selling is illegal and is punishable for a $5,000 fine, prison time, or both, th punishment varies between states and countries. Another downside to black market organ selling can include the crimes that are involved, for any black market, deadly crimes can occur, such as murder, but that is very rare. One example of a crime when a man who was interviewed had his kidney taken away from him in a scam. He lied to the surgeon saying that he was related to the patient in order to be able to sell his kidney. The result was that the man only received 1% of the profits. There were two crimes involved with this man, he went against the Nepalis law which is that the organ donor must be a relative (Pokharel). The other crime involved with that man was that the man was robbed of most of his earnings. Another crime that can occur is kidnapping to harvest organs, even though kidnapping is dangerous and plagues places all over the world, this can come to a halt by having more policemen around to ensure the safety of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In “Organ Sales Will Save Lives”, Joanna MacKay argues that the sale of humans organs, such as kidneys, should be legalized. She claims, “There are thousands of people dying to buy a kidney and thousands of people dying to sell a kidney.” She provides critical background information on the problem before delving into her main ideas. MacKay claims that donors need and deserve the money, and that buyers are unable to access the necessary organs any other way. Unfortunately, people living in poverty in third world countries would thrive if given the money buyers are willing to provide in exchange for a vital organ.…

    • 268 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most people would claim that authorizing the sale of organs will take advantage of the poorer people in the third world countries, but that’s already happening. The organ seller does usually collect most of the money promised, but it doesn’t make a dent on their financial struggles. The threat of a $50,000 fine and five years in prison (Finkel 26), the up-to-date ban is not successful in averting illegal organ sales and operations. The underprivileged families don’t need more harsh and rigorous punishments, on the contrary they need just the opposite. If organ sales were made lawful, it could be controlled and supervised by the government.…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sally Satel Organ Selling

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Should organs be legal to sell around the world? Sally Satel, a practicing psychiatrist and kidney receiver, believes so. Satel states that there is a global organ shortage, and that has to do with kidney selling being illegal. In order to make organ selling legal, one would have to price a kidney at $50,000, and implement rigorous health screening. However, what Satel argues in “Why We Need a Market for Human Organs,” reprinted from The Wall Street Journal, is a high risk, high reward deal task in that if everything goes according to plan, everyone is has a new kidney (in theory).…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Third world donors will do anything for money and it could help poverty. Mackay states in the living situations, people are willing to sell their kidneys for 1,000 dollars(159). Mackay’s article then springs into moral issues, she says not being able to sell a kidney violates the basic rights of a donor. Mackay brings up a counter claim from Pope John Paul II when he states that organ sales are morally wrong, she later refutes this argument(158). There is an advantage of government regulation.…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Truth Behind Purchasing Illegal Organs for Transplant The US Department of Health and Human Services reports that an average of 22 people die every day waiting for a donated organ (HRSA). As a result, desperate and wealthy people are willing to pay thousands for black market organs. An illegally purchased kidney alone sells for between 30,000 and 100,000 in America (Interlandi, 2009). However, the donor is likely given less than a tenth of that money.…

    • 1744 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Paper 4 "Organ Sales Will Save Lives" by Joanna MacKay explains the problem that thousands of people are complaining about. This problem is that thousands of people are begging to buy a kidney, but the government doesn't allow people to sell human organs. This outcome causes thousands of people to die each year, creating chaos around the world. Mackay and the other author’s want to convey their message to the government on why this catastrophic problem should be fixed. Since this essay is written on the subject of organ sales and Mackay’s essay was written back in 2004 some information may be dated, however not much has changed to fix this issue.…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One argument against an organ market is that a market in organs would make the body an object to just sell and would ruin social values. Gilbert Meilaender, an author and researcher in bioethics says, “Buying and selling - even if it would provide more organs needed for transplant - would make of the body simply a natural object, at our disposal if the price is right”. It would make organs into an object you can just buy. It would put a price on human life. This would get rid of the idea of everyone being equal.…

    • 1129 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Organ Sales Will Save Lives In the essay “Organ Sales Will Save Lives” by Joanna Mackay, kidney failure is the main topic. In the thesis Mackay says “Government should not ban the sale of the human organs, they should regulate it.” It is supported by the evidence it will save lives. 350,000 people in America struggle with this situation each year.…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mackay explains illegal organ sales and how it puts the donor, doctor, and patients in danger. Mackay goes into detail on why the donor goes through the dangers. MacKay whole argument to this article is that the government should not have this ordeal illegal. The government should make it legal so then it will have less risks for the donor, doctors, and patients.…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article, "Organ Sales Will Save Lives, by Joanne MacKay, she appeals to the readers’ emotions by raising awareness that there are thousands of people in the world that die every year due to not enough life-saving organs, specifically kidneys. End Stage Renal Disease is when the kidneys stop working and the patient must endure grueling dialysis treatments and put on the transplant list, where they wait for a very long time for a cadaver kidney donation (MacKay ##). With only these options, some patients look to the black market to purchase a kidney, because it is banned in the United States. MacKay's argument is that "Governments should not ban the sale of human organs; they should regulate it. Lives should not be wasted;…

    • 1367 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Ethical Organ Donation

    • 1514 Words
    • 7 Pages

    According to the World Health Organization, the illegal trade in kidneys has risen to such a level that an estimated ten thousand black market operations involving purchased human tissue and organs now take place annually. Organ donations can create a brewing ground for murky crimes! Everything from body snatching, transplantation tourism, involuntary donation, and, the black market organ trade. It is unfortunate that these crimes are on the rise. However, if government legislation were to gain control over organ donation and make ethical organ donation possible, then everyone can benefit.…

    • 1514 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Legalizing Human Organs

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Should the Market for Human Organs be legalized? Canada today is a country where hundreds of people die waiting for an organ transplant, according to Michael Friscolanti’s article, “Will sell organs for cash”. There have been laws in Canada that object the purchase of human organs, but surely do not have any objection with the donation of organs (Friscolanti, “Will sell organs for cash”). The selling of human organs should be allowed at certain scenarios to have less people die waiting for an organ transplant but not open for all.…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Increasing the supply of cadaver organs is an obvious solution, according to the article. Now some leading ethicists and doctors are re- examining the principle of informed consent in government organ donor programs, they are arguing that harvesting from cadavers should be a routine procedure just like autopsies in murder investigations. This routine recovery would be much simpler and cheaper to implement than proposals designed to stimulate consent. Because they won’t need for donor registries, no need to train requesters, no need for stringent government regulations. Using cadaver organs would increase the amount of organs, it could save many lives.…

    • 1978 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Selling Organs Essay

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages

    At already existed black market, you can purchase just about anything that a man have: kidneys, lungs, liver, eyeballs, bones, tendons, heart valves, skin and many more. However, it would encourage more violent crimes, criminals would hunt for organs and get rid of the rest of the body. [The damning evidence they uncovered suggests that tens of thousands of innocent people have been killed on demand to supply an ongoing illegal organ transplant industry.(5)] ,the most recent exposed China’s human trafficing. Often accomplices mafia group transplant draw up documents for the adoption of children abducted entire families, arrange travel or credit fraud, threatened by the court and paid, if the random victim does not give a "duty", and then offer to help in conflict resolution: a kidney as an exchange fee, newborn twins in exchange for life. For example, in Moldova entire villages mysteriously disappeared, supposedly “gone on…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sam Vaknin portrays a grim picture of the current black market trade in human body parts. Those who sell their organs are usually individuals in developing nations in extreme poverty who make very little from the sale, while those who transport the organs usually make a fortune reselling the organs to recipients in rich, developed countries. Part of the organ trade involves the abduction of individuals, including children, and the theft of their organs. Vaknin applauds the willingness of the American Medical Association to investigate "the effects [that] paying for cadaveric organs would have on the current shortage" of organs. He concludes that the current international ban on organ sales has produced the black market trade, and it would be "better to legalize and regulate the trade than transform it into a form of organized crime.…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays