Procedural Justice Case Analysis

Good Essays
In our readings this week, we discussed procedural justice, due process and whether they are related, in my opinion they are. Procedural justice is the perception that decisions are implemented in fairness and transparency. Due process is when the employer advises the employee with a written notice of the reason for the termination and is presented at least 30 days prior to termination. A copy of the notice will also be sent to the Department of Labor office where the employee’s office is located. When the true process of procedural justice is implemented, people feel they have been treated with respect and dignity allowing the individual to accept outcomes they may not like (Burgess & Cast 2013). In combining the aspects of procedural justice …show more content…
There was no consistency in the selection process of how to downsize, the way in which the downsizing happened was not fair across offices, or in the way the elimination process was thought out in the first round of layoffs. Lauder made the decision to downsize based on the organization having too many offices and not for economic reasons. The downsizing did not improve the company’s long term financial health because there had to be a second round of layoffs for that very reason. . He should have reevaluated the closing of the Vail office because it was the office that was making the most profit and had the opportunity of eventually bringing back the top client. Everyone saw the closing of the office to be unfair, particularly the head of the Vail office Mike Rollins. Although the downsizing resulted in lowering the labor costs, it cost the company in the area relating to its skilled workers, relationships between the organization, it clients and staff was interrupted as well as feelings of negativity from the surviving offices and managers. The Vail office had highly qualified people that could have been transferred to other offices, but wasn’t given the opportunity to do so. The downsizing did not improve the company’s long term financial health because there had to be a second round of layoffs for that very reason. In this case the layoff appeared to be procedurally unfair because of the manager perceived the anxiety and …show more content…
They were more concerned with how the organization was going to look at the announcement of the earning rather than the effect it was going to have on 110 people at the Vail office plus managers and other employees it had around the world as well as the Vail community (Delong and Vijayaraghavan, 2002). The decision to close the Vail office was a biased one. The procedures were not impartial or neutral in that they did not communicate with anyone at the Vail office to even give consideration to what the company could have done differently. Lauder did not ask for the opinion of Rollins or whether what he was doing was fair across the board of the organization. The company did not gain the trust of the employees before deciding to announce the layoffs, thus leading Rollins to not defend Lauder when the employees were asking the questions of him. Lauder did not offer any transparency to the employees or senior management of the organization. It seems that only three people in the organization knew what was taking place and that was Jim Bradley, Alberto Marquez and Andrew Laude; no one else in the organization seemed to have mattered to them. The procedures by which the organization chose to take the steps were in secret. Lauder had no clear way to access where the layoff the first round of layoffs should have taken

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    They could use the money to get the company out of the jam they were in that they had to have layoffs. The company also wastes time on paper work to fire employees Matthews states in her article. In the end, we just find layoffs are negative in many more aspects, not just for the person being let go. Layoffs do not spare the company time and money that they…

    • 1523 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Another important thing to note is that no one felt like they were being micro-managed from Joe’s team. Later in the next year when the new employees were hired, the new supervisors set up very strict scheduling and forced certain quotas to be met. This was all alongside the fact that the new supervisors micro-managed the team to the whole new level to the point where the employees had their job satisfaction rating decrease. This is a very negative thing to do because it shows that the supervisors did not trust the company employees. When all these negative points add up for an employee, they lose motivation to want to succeed in the company.…

    • 1473 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Case Study: The Body Shop

    • 1903 Words
    • 8 Pages

    They could structure it in a way that only benefits them; they could also do it wrong so they can fix it later causing the business even more harm. One way a management consultant could cause problems is by structuring the business as a flat one meaning the entire burden will fall on one or few managers; the better option could have been a tall structure meaning the business could have distributed the load using division of labor and become more efficient. The main idea of the owner could be lost which would interrupt the actions of the business and lead to it failing. If I was a customer I would feel lost as I would not know who to go to if I wanted to buy a product or have a complaint because if the business themselves have a messy structure they would have too many internal problems to solve before they could help me. If I was the supplier, I would not know which department to supply to which would affect my own sales and I may have to cancel my contract with that business as an unbalanced structure will only cause me harm.…

    • 1903 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    However, the purpose of the plan failed because the employees became demotivated by the incentive system, as a result of not receiving their bonuses for seven months. The root cause of organizational issues of Engstrom Auto Mirror Plant was due to lack of motivation and poor communication between management and the employees. The company’s incentive system implemented was an ineffective technique of motivating workers as it failed to support employees’ needs. Engstrom management must understand that to motivate employees, it is important to first find and comprehend each employee’s needs. Management should willingly take care of the necessities of their workers.…

    • 1952 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Narcissist usually are self-motivated however, they seek admiration from others about their superiority (Judge, LePine, & Rich, 2006). The tactic of seeking admiration is self-defeating in the long run, because it undermines personal relationship (Judge, LePine, & Rich, 2006). Meaning that it can damage relationships and could cause a subordinate to veer away from a narcissistic manager. They won’t listen to their manager, thus productivity will decrease. This can cause turnover in corporations and could lead Human…

    • 2384 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Minimum Wage Debate

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Entry level workers will be the first to be fired because they are not the source generating high profits. This then leads to further complications such as poverty. Another solution for businesses and companies to prevent profit loss is raising the prices of their goods and services. As previously mentioned, it has been a trend for inflation to rise as the minimum wage increases. If this trend were to continue there would be no significance in raising the minimum wage because people would continue to struggle to afford expenses.…

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Firstly, the problem is that the sales team did not meet their sales targets due to the leadership skill of David Seymour is poor. A good leader would know the approaches to push them to activate their talents. He did not have truly motivated the team again the sales targets set for each of the member are low. Therefore, sales team do not feel the motivation from leader to push the sales until the max, they are just trying to reach the targets sales and let it be. Furthermore, David Seymour as a manager of the team, he did not get to know the rest of the team.…

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Case Study Rak

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Pfizer senior director hired some genius employees to do the job well and more efficiently but in reality, performance was not satisfactory, A situation is same up to top level management, Jordan (CEO) decided a supportive work will do another organization for Pfizer, so it reduces waste time, increases efficiency and works effectively. So this is different planning, on the other hand, Rakon also has issues in top level management planning and organization skills can do this. Chairman of Shareholders Association John Hawkins wants to vanish out Robinson family from director post. However, they can protest for shares percentage and reduce their wages and keep it on their performance basis because Robinson family has experience of handling business and in starting time Rakon has excellent remuneration, so suddenly cannot remove from an organization. It will impact on productivity and in a competitive market.…

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Enron Ethical Dilemmas

    • 1030 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Basically they ignore what would bring the pros to their company yet only pay attention to their own benefits. Greedy mind made them lost their interest in working and bring the company to another next top level and also led them to act unethically. Decision made by their leaders did not benefit the company but only themselves is also the factors that led to the failure of Enron. The leaders also loan from their subsidiaries company without thinking to return it and traded in company stock worth millions dollars with the help of insider information. Some of the federal tax payment also been avoided even though some tax payment were collected from their subsidiaries customer.…

    • 1030 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Trade does, from time to time, create losers and, unfortunately, there is no way of protecting them. When a company relocates its plants to another country, as mentioned above, it costs many people their livelihoods. Protecting these jobs, however important and morally correct it may be, will stunt economic growth in the long run. If a factory is not relocated for the sake of saving jobs, it no longer has the ability to produce more at a cheaper rate. The economy is no longer growing, it is stuck in the same place it was when the company started.…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays