Prima Facie Case Paper

Improved Essays
Eight years ago my uncle was diagnosed with stage 4 throat, lung, and spine cancer. He began treatment immediately, but saw very little relief from the treatments. He spent four years in and out of hospitals and medical facilities for surgeries, therapies, and pain management. During this time he asked several doctors to end his pain and suffering and allow him to die peacefully before he was unable to make the decision. Each time he was told that it was illegal in the state of Georgia to offer such assistance, but hospice could keep him comfortable until the end. Tracey was just as worried about the pain and suffering of his family and friends as we watched him waste away and the money we spent trying to keep him comfortable. He wanted to do what was best for everyone despite the never-ending pain he endured. No amount of hospice care was able to truly take away the physical, emotional, and psychological pain that accompanied the terminal cancer.
Tracie was very much a Utilitarian. He always wanted what was best for family
…show more content…
The agreed that doing what was best for the greatest number of people was important. However, in this case, according to the doctors, the duty to not cause harm outweighed doing what was best for everyone including allowing Tracey to make the decision to take his life, it was just as important, if not more so that he live. They were bound by the oath to do no harm as well as the oath to provide the best treatment they could for the patient. The problem was deciding what was more important- keeping Tracey alive no matter what or giving him and his family relief from the suffering we were all having to withstand. My father and I, along with other family members watched him suffer through four, almost five agonizing years of cancer, kemo, and failing organs. At last, his body failed him and he died. As stated in his will he was not resuscitated and was finally able to

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Terry Fox A Canadian Hero

    • 283 Words
    • 2 Pages

    That was when he stopped his journey. He was later diagnosed with lung cancer. The cancer spread to his lungs and he could barely breath. He then later died of lung cancer.…

    • 283 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Other limitations found in the qualitative studies were a lack of response from physicians in sub-specialties outside of the oncology setting. A larger sample size may provide a more diverse collection of information. Many of the studies reviewed only focus on the physicians’ knowledge of hospice care and their perceived barriers to end of life care. Further qualitative and quantitative studies are needed to investigate the patients’ and caregivers ‘perspective to barriers to terminal care. Failure to incorporate both perspectives creates bias among the literature and leaves out some of the most important knowledge that can be obtained and applied in the area of receiving timely end of life care.…

    • 1635 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    But for terminally ill patients, medical advancements only prolong an inevitable and often painful death. California resident Brittany Maynard was 29 years old when she was diagnosed with terminal brain cancer and given only six months to live. She did not want to face the inevitable suffering her doctors said she was likely to endure and decided she wanted to end her life on her own terms. Since California had not yet legislated Death with Dignity laws, Brittany moved to Oregon so she could end her life with dignity on Nov 1, 2014. As Barbara Coombs’ article, “Medical Aid in Dying: The Cornerstone of Patient-Centered Care” points out, “…adopting policies that support giving terminally ill patients the option of medical aid in dying is a hallmark of person-centered care.”…

    • 1336 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With the understanding that their patient does not want to die, the doctors should act according to their oath as physicians to provide the best possible care. There is a chance she will live, albeit in an altered state mentally and physically, if her legs are amputated. It would be unjust to allow the infection to spread thus prolonging the suffering of the patient. Although I agree with the court’s decision to amputate Mary’s legs in order to save her life, it is a decision that was not determined in a timely manner.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Everyone Deserves to Die with Dignity” Anita Freeman talks about the agony and struggle she and her sister went through after her sister was diagnosed with stage 4 cancer. Freeman tells us that her sister Elizabeth Martin was diagnosed with cancer and had limited time to live here on earth. Freeman explains how she took on the responsibility of Elizabeth and tried to carry out her every wish. Freeman explains that Elizabeth’s biggest fear was dying in pain; this is when Freeman issued palliative care to come in. After multiple visits from palliative care, Freeman says that she knew this was not her sister’s plans.…

    • 1740 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “The whole notion of pain, and how every individual experiences pain, is up for debate. We don 't know how another person experiences pain - physical pain or psychic pain. Some of these clinics where assisted suicide or euthanasia is practiced, they call it 'weariness of life. '” (Toews). For many years, those dubbed with the burden of cancer and other terminal illnesses have to suffer through a slow and painful death in the end.…

    • 1733 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Price Fixing is an illegal practice to when a heath care provider will charge an artificially high price for a health care service, or when a group of health care providers will set a standard price for a procedure so there is no competition. “Physician practice The illegal practice by a group of health care providers of establishing a standard price for procedures, thus creating a monopoly on a particular market segment.” "price fixing. " We see this in the United States quite often, we have one of the highest medical cost in the world. Granted we also do have very good health care and several advancements that most of the world do not have.…

    • 1968 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nursing 304 Assignment

    • 1106 Words
    • 5 Pages

    He had his wishes respected, he and his family had support and room to process death, and he went with well-managed symptoms that gave the appearance that he was sleeping when he passed. Unfortunately, I have seen both with my friends and family, as well as patients and families, being deprived of the hospice palliative care services that my grandfather was provided. Although I understand that as a professional I must be mindful of how my opinion might affect a patient’s care, I feel that patients with either life-threatening or life-limiting should be given the opportunity to choose a hospice-palliative care approach. In addition, I hope that I will be able to explore further my knowledge and understanding of hospice palliative care to become a better advocate for patients and continue to improve my nursing practice. Lastly, I believe that my grandfather’s passing marked the start of my life’s journey with death and is one that I will continue to learn and grown on until it is my day to meet him for…

    • 1106 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I think the best way to approach these situations is not to ask the doctor for assistance in dying, but refusing treatment. For those who cannot consent and are in very poor condition I think families should be allowed to decide to take their loved ones off any machines and let their body take their natural course whether that is living or eventually dying. That is more morally right than expecting another human being to carry the burden of deaths on their shoulders and taking away their duty to save lives. This is more morally correct because many years ago we did not have the medication and treatment we had today, so those who wish to die can do so naturally through their disease or condition. Citizens should have the right to live, but not the right to ask doctors to help them die.…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As Bill C-14 has been legalized in Canada on June 2016, there are still a lot of questions and concerns regarding physician aid in dying (PAD), and whether it is lawful and ethical. Some people debate that only God has the right to terminate a life or that a doctor must abide by his Hippocratic Oath swearing “I will keep [the sick] from harm and injustice. I will neither give a deadly drug to anybody who asked for it, nor will I make a suggestion to this effect.” while others argue that a terminal ill patient has the right to a dignified and peaceful death on his/her own terms.…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For instance, the Oregon law requires the elderly or the terminally ill to make two requests orally and one written request. In particular, there should be a mandatory 15-day waiting period between the two oral requests and an additionally two-day lapse between receiving medication and the making of the decision (Lachman, 2010). Additionally, the Oregon requires medical practitioners to provide palliative care as an alternative option. Asides from the above, among others, procedural steps, there lies other several inherent regulations, which are subject to personal opinion. For instance, patients need to be diagnosed with less than half a year to live as well as be declared of impaired judgment (Lachman, 2010).…

    • 1675 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Argumentative Essay On Mercy Killing

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages
    • 7 Works Cited

    We are being inhumane to force people to continue suffering in this way (Newman, 1996). Choosing for a more painless death comes a lot easier for patients along with family who witness the pain of their loved is enduring with all the medications and treatments (which tend to cause severe side effects). I believe that is justified. Especially knowing that the chances of survival are very slim for the patient. Supports of the mercy killing ask whether it is rational or not to keep a terminally ill patient who’s hopes of survival are slim and alive on a support system when our medical infrastructure is under immense pressure (Naik, 2011).…

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages
    • 7 Works Cited
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    If doctors are enabled the decision to terminate a life on behalf of a unconscious patient, they would be then granted a power over society that not only breaches the Hippocratic Oath, but also empowers them to “play God”. This responsibility could then reflect upon society, altering their views and their trust within doctors and medical professionals as they could then be seen as “providers of death” (Cosic, 2003. 25) In addition to this, a doctor’s decision to terminate a life may not rely on the condition and best interests of the patient, but instead of amount of hospital beds and facilities that are…

    • 2101 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Ethical principles are not laws, but guiding principles about what is good and what is bad, that should direct doctors and other health care professionals in their work and decision making. Issues arising over end-of-life care involving decisions that affect the nature and timing of an individual's death raise difficult ethical conflicts for all concerned and can be a source of discord between health professionals within a team, health professionals and family members, or between different family members. Ethical dilemmas arise when there is a perceived conflicting duty to the patient, such as a conflict between a duty to preserve life and a duty to act in a patient's best interests, or when an ethical principle such as respect for autonomy conflicts with a duty not to…

    • 3174 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Medical Case Study

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Mr. Jones repeatedly insisted that the treatment be discontinued and that he be allowed to die, but the doctors continued the wound care, skin grafts, and provided nutritional and fluid support. I will argue that the physician in this case did not act justifiable because he refused the patient’s bill of rights to refuse treatment. The patients’ bill of rights was made in 1973, which allowed the patients the right to refuse treatment, right to consent, right to an informed consent and right to religious beliefs. The patents bill of rights also has maxims which are right claims and some examples are “always get informed consent before surgery” and “a patient’s medical information must be kept confidential”. This code of ethics wasn’t upheld because of the situation or situationalism.…

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays