Postcolonialism And Colonialism

Improved Essays
Decades have passed since colonialism first occurred but yet many repercussions can still be observed in several countries that were once colonies.
This essay aims to address the concept that is colonialism and also to clearly define the relationship between colonialism and imperialism in order to get a clearer understanding of colonialism. It will also address one of the contested legacies in a postcolonial contest and specifically define what the aim of postcolonialism is. Readings by Daniel Butt will be used as well as various other sources to strengthen the argument.

Colonialism

In general, colonialism is confused with imperialism. Daniel Butt makes this clear in his article on colonialism: “A recurrent problem concerns the relation
…show more content…
This means simply that postcolonialism looks at the legacies which are still carrying on, decades after colonialism. One of these contested legacies are deeply imprinted into the minds of many people, the idea that not everything left behind from colonialism was bad. This can be seen in a tweet from Helen Zille (2018) “… I said the LEGACY of colonialism (i.e what was left behind) was not ONLY negative.”. Is this a fair statement? It is important to take into consideration that what most people know of colonialism is what is taught by Western literacy, this paints a lovely picture of advanced (mostly European) countries entering a specific community and “saving” them from their “backwards” ways. As Butt also states “What this suggests is that a literature on the ethics of colonialism written by Western academics with little regard to the voices of those who have suffered domination runs the risk not only of misunderstanding the nature, but of compounding the effects, of historical injustice” (2013: 6). This means that for people to say that the effects weren’t all bad, is just as unfair as colonialism itself because they would be judging it from the Western point of view and totally ignoring the voices and stories of people that actually suffered through colonialism. The idea that colonialized countries would not have developed if it was not for the countries that colonialized them is not a fair judgement because they would have progressed in their own time and in their own way. Many cultures are now completely extinct due to colonialism. Thus it can be argued that the idea of what was left behind “… was not ONLY negative” (Zille, 2018) is a very Eurocentric way of thinking and fails to address the actual people that

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In addition, it can be noticed that Said was preceded by other anti-colonial assessments of the Eurocentrism of colonial discourse which were an essential part the decolonisation struggles. The originality of postcolonial criticism can be sum up in two facts; primarily, the fact that it was anti-colonial and critical of Eurocentrism as well as critical of the governing elite of previously colonised nations; Secondly, the use of poststructuralist theories by postcolonial critics to draw attention to the position of the text within power…

    • 1311 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Many writers in their writings try to show and analyse critically the kind of relation between the colonisers and the colonised that were before as well as the impact of that relationship on the colonised minds so many years after Independence. They reiterate their themes on the political, linguistic and cultural experiences of the colonised people. In India too, many regions which were not then part of Indian subcontinent were former European colonies especially the British. However, after the British left, these regions came directly under the supervision of Indian Government. Some of these regions were independent princely kingdoms ruled by Kings and Queens.…

    • 3065 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    There are many difficulties with anthropology and taking a narrow view, led me to ask at the start of the course in my tutorial presentation “Is Anthropology and Ethnography worthwhile?” Difficulties with suspicion of intellectual voyeurism such as in Margret Mead’s "Coming of Age in Samoa”, did it sell because it was scientific or because it titillated. There is difficulties as revisionist view that it is just cultural imperialism for it seems to be a western study of people under colonial control, looking at some of Kathleen Gough’s arguments (Gough 1993). Difficulties seen from premises that the author can overcome the effect of power and inequality, for it is not poor natives writing about comparatively wealthy western scholars. Furthermore,…

    • 1436 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    It also deals with realities of nations and peoples emerging into new imperialistic context of domination and the economic, material and cultural conditions that determine the global system in which the postcolonial nation is required to operate. A transformed historical situation and the cultural formation that have risen in response to changed political circumstances in the former colonial powers is yet another aspect of postcolonialism (Young…

    • 6198 Words
    • 25 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    On Postcolonial Theory/ists And Beyond The history of colonialism has been one of turning points in today’s cultural discussion. One major criticism is directed to modernism. Within its history, eurocentric perspective becomes major narrative rejecting that of the third world countries as part its progression. This is linked to the power that narrates the history through colonialism. Furthermore, this issue relates to the idea of representation.…

    • 1846 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Several discourse on the subject of the existence of neo-colonialism has attracted several modern and postmodern theorists. One of the common argument among the neo-colonialism intellects of the modern dawn of knowledge is its simplistic nature to say that imperialism came to an end when the European empires relinquished their colonial quest. The darn of this new phenomenon, neocolonialism, is a reason enough the continual manifestation of imperialism in the modern days. Various models and frameworks have been adopted by the Kenyan and foreign researchers to evaluate and analyze the effects of Neo-colonialism to trade and trading activities in Kenya and other developing countries in general. Neo-colonialism has become extremely flaccid in…

    • 1454 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Colonialism and globalization are two terms, which are frequently mentioned in the field of international events. They are both very important in the study of humanity progress and social progress. There are a lot of studies and debates about if globalization is the repetition of colonialism. This essay will focus on comparing and contrasting differences and similarities between colonialism and globalization. According to the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, colonialism is defined as: “Colonialism is a practice of domination, which involves the subjugation of one people to another.” (Margaret Kohn, Colonialism, 2002) However, colonialism is different from imperialism in some ways, though these two terms are always considered as synonyms.…

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At first glance, European imperialism and thus colonialism seems ridden with atrocity and demise for those upon whom it is imposed while serving the pride and prejudice of those who have imposed it. The question that this paper seeks to answer, however, is one that is layered and cannot be superficially analyzed based on popular views and discourse. For the findings of this paper to prove academically valuable and sound, one must aim to consider with as little (if any at all) bias as possible. Therein lies credibility. Cases for the value of colonialism have been presented amidst an ocean of cases that plead otherwise in both historical as well as modern context.…

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the same vein, British imperialism was blindly accepted and thought of as a “positive good” for the “ignorant” natives, though its atrocities and injustices were obvious if anyone took the time to think about it. A voice of logic and a guiding moral force of the novel, Mr. Murthwaite tries to help the other narrators realize their own hypocrisies but instead, he is often…

    • 1367 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What is post colonialism? When and how did the term originate? Why is the study of post-colonial theories never ending? To start with, post colonialism is one of the most complicated fields of study as it ranges from the distant past and continues to evolve even today. Essentially, the term post colonialism emerged from a complex history of struggle between the dominant European powers and the colonised countries.…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays