Possible Worlds: Why Do Children Pretend? By Alison Gopnik

Great Essays
In the essay “Possible Worlds: Why do Children Pretend?” by Alison Gopnik she explains her theory of counterfactual thinking and the result of that being possible worlds. Gopnik suggests that counterfactuals are the possibilities of what could have occurred in life. These counterfactuals are the cause, and the effect is the creation of possible worlds. Gopnik defines possible worlds as “the productions of hope and imagination” (163). Possible worlds are seen as the result of a counterfactual; they are the possibilities of what could have happened. Alison Gopnik also speaks on how knowledge and imagination coincide to form these possible worlds. According to Gopnik causal knowledge is knowing that because two things are connected you can figure …show more content…
One of her first claims is after she conducts an experiment between a fifteen-month-old to an eighteen-month-old baby. Her trial was to see if the younger baby can think counterfactually. The way she did this was by taping the whole of a ring piece and leaving the other rings empty, to see if the baby would place that tricked ring on the pole. Evidently, the fifteen-month-old placed the trick ring on and realized it didn’t work and tried the other pieces. This method is known as trial and error. On the other hand, the eighteen-month-old baby was aware of the trick piece and avoided that piece altogether. Gopnik claims “as they got older and learned more about how the world worked, babies would behave entirely differently” (166). This quote comes after she notices that the older babies weren’t fooled by the ring. It relates to how growing older and learning more about the world gives humans the ability to think counterfactually. In turn, this experiment relates to how the young chimpanzees use the trial and error method like the fifteen-month-old babies. With this understanding, it can be implied that animals are similar to babies, both need growth to learn. With growth it is clear that familiarity occurs. As seen in the span of three months, the trial and error method was not used by the baby likewise, if the chimpanzee matures, he as well will not be fooled with the tricked ring piece. It is …show more content…
This quote is what she describes as causal knowledge. This means that one must grow and be familiar with things around them in order to think this way. Not only does causal knowledge come with time to create counterfactual thoughts, as seen in the experiment, but so does imagination. One must learn things about the world in order to form imaginations and visions. Gopnik suggests that “learning language gives children a whole powerful new way to imagine. Being able to talk gives you a particularly powerful way to put old ideas together in new ways, and to talk about things that aren’t there” (169). This statement relates to how young babies are able to say “no” and the power of that word. Learning language by hearing other people use it around them, is what gives them the ability to speak. The use of the word is for the child to say it when they know something isn’t true, therefore having an imagination of what the truth really is. On the other hand, animals lack the ability to speak, but that doesn’t mean they can’t imagine. According to Gopnik imagination and causal thinking coincide, therefore if an animal becomes familiar with how things react and what occur, they too have the ability to imagine. Gopnik states “animals, may act on the world effectively without necessarily understanding the world in a causal way.

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In the essay “Children Need to Play, not Compete”, Jessica Statsky writes about the importance of children being able to have fun playing a sport without the pressure of winning or losing (152-157). Playing sports can be a huge part of a child’s life, but parents and coaches need to remember that sports are here to keep a child busy and active. Children use sports to make friends not compete with each other to see who is better. When sport oriented parents and over controlling coaches try to have kids play at a professional level this causes children to lose interest (152, par. 1). With this being said the parents and coaches need to realize how they are taking the game to an unsafe and unsportsmanlike level.…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Imagination In Just Kids

    • 659 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “I had this rare privilege of being able to pursue in my adult life, what had been my childhood dream.” This quote by Andrew Wiles might as well represent what happened to Patti and Robert in terms of their art, which seem to be the opposite of who they used to be as children. The book Just Kids explained how both Robert’s and Patti’s childhood influenced their work of art. Just Kids begins by explaining the core of Patti’s and Robert’s art, which is their childhood. Patti and Robert both come from a poor family.…

    • 659 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jessica Statsky, the writer of the essay, “Children Need To Play, Not Compete,” describes how children’s sports have been changing in recent times. She speaks of how the parents and coaches near fanatical criteria being imposed are negatively affecting many of the children involved with the sports. The concerns she feels derive from the potential dangers that children in the age ranges of six to twelve are exposed to in all organized sports activities. The dangers she covers are the physical well-being, mental health and anxiety, drop-out rate, and the stresses created by the adults involved in the sport. Statsky’s first observation is the physical risks that young, growing children are being exposed too in sports programs.…

    • 1030 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Summary Jessica Statsky endeavor to convince people in her article "children’s Need, to Play not Compete," that there is something wrong with games by upsetting them over the hazards of such games. Statsky tells about both noncontact and physical games, played at six to twelve years old might contain time-consuming lug outcome for a child as a player and a supporter. Statsky describes many justifications about her point of view as well as the risk for physical and mental harm, and people those who churn out to be conquer. Jessica Statsky gives her comments about the aim and organization of destructive games.…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Jacob Bronowski was a distinguished scientist who spoke at the Blashfield Address for the American Academy of Art and Letters in 1966. He gave the speech “The Reach of Imagination” to an audience of top class artists and poets. The speech covered the subject of imagination within the human mind. Bronowski opens his speech with,“imagination is a specifically human gift” (193).…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I was very intrigued with the TED videos that were assigned to this paper. I am always interested in learning more about how children at such a young age develop everything that is essential for when we age in adulthood. In the first video “What Do Babies Think?” The first experiment included babies that were the age of fifteen to eighteen months. I was amazed to find there was a significant amount of difference between a fifteen-month and an eighteen-month baby and how their brain processes information.…

    • 1095 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My Virtual Child Essay

    • 1298 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Is your virtual child at risk for any nutritional deficiencies? What puts your child at risk? If your child is not at risk, what has protected your child? My child was born in a developed country, which decreases his risk of nutrimental deficiencies.…

    • 1298 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    PHI 1000 Fall 2016 Prof. Drain Essay #2 Thoughts on Thought After examining the several angles to the issue of animal cognition, it is my conclusion that non-human animals are in fact capable of thought. Although humans certainly display a superior cognitive ability, I believe the cognition of animals is not of an entirely different type, and that whatever difference remains is simply one of degree. While Davidson and Descartes tend to argue that language is a necessary component for rational creatures, Hobbes and Searle give non-human creatures more “cognitive credit,” citing their ability perceive, and to have and correct beliefs, as proof of being conscious, thinking, beings. Pointing to the immense biological similarities between humans…

    • 1802 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Great to Watch,” Maggie Nelson talks about the ways in which violence has become a norm in everyday culture and the process through which people’s “blameless ignorance” leads them to ignore the ramifications of violence (Nelson, 300). In “Selections from Alone Together: Why We Expect More from Technology and Less from Each Other,” Sherry Turkle claims that when children spend a lot of time around life-like toys like Furbies and Tamagotchis, children experience a shift from a “psychology of projection to a new psychology of engagement” (Turkle, 290). In “The Ecstasy of Influence: A Plagiarism,” Jonathan Lethem discusses the gift and market economies and how they overlap in their primary purpose. Nelson’s view of people accepting violence…

    • 1737 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Later, after watching the orangutan learned to wash himself, and wash clothes by observing them do it. If a toddler watches their mother, they can often repeat back what you say or do. This is similar in the life of a chimpanzee, a child can learn how to make tools, or create independence. Chimpanzees have also discovered Herbal medicines that helps when they’re…

    • 1457 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A long long time ago there would be children, un-surveillanced by adults, playing in a nearby cool pond on a summers day or playing cops and robbers in the neighborhood streets, but now, Hanna Rosin would argue, there isn’t much that we let our kids do without the constant supervision and “protection” of an adult figure around. We all want to be able to do fun/potentially dangerous things when we are kids and growing up, but often times are stopped by parents because of the negative side effects that may come. Are we being too cautious with our children? With almost physical blinders on for other views, the author makes a great case for us to examine with vivid evidence that relates to all of us in some way, persuading language, and valid points…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction There is no doubt that early childhood experiences have a tremendous effect on all aspects of development of a person. This essay looks at the role of nature and nurture in the cognitive development of individuals using case studies of two feral children and the psychological impact of the Holocaust for the children who survived it. 1. Examination of the role of nature and nurture in cognitive development of a child using Isabelle and Genie case studies It is generally agreed that the development of a child is influenced by both nature and nurture.…

    • 1455 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Jean Piaget got what develops in children, right most of the time, but did he get when it develops, right? Piaget was a biologist who was particularly interested in knowledge (epistemology). He viewed intelligence as a mechanism of adaptation and argued that children’s cognitive development is based on the ability to adapt to the environment through accommodation or assimilation processes (Piaget, 1952). Assimilation uses existing schemas to interpret new experiences, while accommodation modifies existing schemas or create new schemas to fit reality. Piaget’s theory consists of four stages, which he proposed, occur in fixed sequence and are never skipped.…

    • 1879 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Imagination Vs Reality

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The way we view reality then shapes our actions, thoughts and expectations. Imagining positive things can help to change our mindset accordingly, leading us to see, act and behave in a positive manner. Imagination can help us perceive situations in a new light, seeing ‘problems’ as ‘challenges’ that…

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Children literature includes books, magazines, stories and poems that children enjoy. It can be traced to stories and songs which were part of the oral tradition that adults shared with their children before the advent of publication. The development of children literature is difficult to trace. However, from the 15th century AD, a large volume of literature, often with a religious or moral message, has been targeted specifically at children. Many of the children books acknowledged today as classics can trace their origins to the late 19th and early 20th centuries which become known as the Golden Age of children literature.…

    • 1541 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays