Summary: The Effects Of Illegal Immigration

Good Essays
Over the years Immigration in the United States has increased rapidly due to the changes to admission rules adopted by congress in 1965 (Zong and Batalova 1). These modifications have impacted the United States workforce, education, communities, and economy. Today the United States is still a popular destination for international immigrants, and it will continue to be one in the future. The issue that is being discussed is illegal immigration and whether it has negative or positive effects. Loren W. Brown, a professor at the University of Houston, wrote “The Effects of Illegal Immigration on Organizational Efficiency and Effectiveness: A United States Analysis”, which states some negative effects of illegal immigration. Heliodoro T. Sanchez …show more content…
Sanchez and M. Sanchez does not include any information about birthright citizenship or anchor babies, it does not even include any counter arguments. Because of the lack of counterarguments within the article, it is difficult to believe whether it makes valid arguments. Unlike H. Sanchez and M. Sanchez, Brown does include a counterargument in her article. Besides the negative effects of illegal immigration, Brown adds in a couple of positive effects illegal immigration has on the United States of America. Brown states that some people view the presence of illegal immigrants as an economic benefit to America and those areas include taxes, consumption, and laborers (3). Illegal immigrants contribute to consumption by spending money on food, clothing, and other goods which benefit parts of the U.S. economy. They also contribute with laborers, because illegal immigrants usually are willing to do the work other people avoid and for much lower wages. For example, in Zong’s and Batalova’s article they incorporate the percentage of foreign-born workers in occupations that native born workers are less likely to do. “Foreign-born workers make up 25 percent of services, 15 percent of transportation, and 13 percent of construction and maintenance, while native-born workers only make up 17 percent in services, 12 percent in transportation, and 8 percent in construction and maintenance” (Zong and Batalova 9). This helps keep the cost of some goods and services …show more content…
Though all three were very informative, there was one article that was the most convincing. “The Effects of Illegal Immigration on Organizational Efficiency and Effectiveness: A United States Analysis” by Loren W. Brown had the best arguments and counterarguments. With each argument there was a significant amount of evidence to demonstrate its point of view. It also provided a counterargument, in which she stated facts about illegal immigration having positive effects. This article included a variety of different results caused by illegal immigration, unlike the article written by Heliodoro Sanchez and Mary Sanchez which only discussed one major effect of illegal immigration. One aspect that each article did encompass is that they had a similar tone and style. Both articles were written with a factual and formal tone, which lets the reader know that this topic was very important. Overall after reviewing both articles, the most compelling article is “The Effects of Illegal Immigration on Organizational Efficiency and Effectiveness: A United States

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Illegal Immigrants

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Although they do not have authorization to work in the United States, it is undeniable that they contribute to the economy. Illegal immigrants supply approximately $652 billion annually to the US gross domestic product (Perryman). The nation’s GDP would not only decline,…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    He was able to thoroughly explain several very controversial topics without adding in pages and pages of useless information. I think this goes to show the amount of dedication and leg work that went into this book. I would highly recommend this book to other criminal justice professionals in order for them to understand how many ironies if imprisonment exist in the so called “land of the…

    • 1257 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Undocumented workers lower the wages, which restricts Americans chances to get jobs that pay well. The increasing demand for cheap labor allows illegal immigrants to get jobs easily, while Americans in low income areas struggle to…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    By picking these immigrates a company can save million of dollars, while making million more. Companies can also be able to contract many more workers because they save money by paying those immigrants less. The labor the immigrants accomplish for these country is unbelievable. Their labor is really important for this economy.The economy gets their products and jobs done for a cheap price, which helps it to grow…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The positive effects of cheap labor and a boost of economy in depressed areas help the economy but the negative effects of high crime rates and the amount of tax dollars spent on public services threaten only the economy, but also the society. When argued that illegal immigration has a positive effect on the United States economy cheap labor is most often the first thing brought up. Illegal immigrants do in fact provide an inexpensive, or cheap, source of labor to business owners that are willing to take the risk of hiring immigrants. Americans argue that they are taking their jobs, but the truth is that these immigrants are working long hours doing physically demanding work for a very low wage. The work that the immigrants do…

    • 1159 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the essay “Illegal Immigration and Immigration Control,” it expresses “…With changes in U.S. immigration law and economic and political conditions in the United States and other countries, the nature and characteristics of illegal immigration have also changed” (Chiswick). I believe from this quote it explains due to the several events taking place in America at the time the U.S. was not worried about illegal immigration so it was an open opportunity to migrate (also at in this time the other countries were facing many events as…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Our United States government should allow legal refugees (Immigrants) from all over the world because they bring countless reimbursements to us which include a stronger economy, the breaking of language barriers, and employment opportunities. Immigrants are a progressive influence on United States of America which will be proven throughout countless arguments. Immigrants have been the great jump start of this nation. So why debate nowadays that permitting foreign individuals into America is hazardous? Some folks might argue that legal immigration is the reason of overpopulation.…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    They want to send their money back to their home Countries in order to pay for things. They will work harder labor at cheaper cost then most American citizens. In 2012 we found that approximately 8.1 million illegal immigrants were working or searching for work in the United States. This makes up a total of 5.1% of the United States labor force. (Krogstad, J., & Passel, J., 2015) As an economy that is decreasing and jobs being harder to locate we see that we would be able to free a large amount of jobs if it was not for this issue.…

    • 1940 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Furthermore, the authors also use the evidence about supply and demand — specifically how increase supply of workers drive down wages (9). The last piece of evidence used to support the reason is that undocumented immigrants do the same work but employers do not have to give them benefits (10). This evidence was used because all of those reasons mean employers spend less money on their employees and can sell their products for cheaper which impacts the economy. The second reason Lakoff and Ferguson use to support their subclaim is that the undocumented immigrants are mostly economic refugees (9). The authors use the definition of refugees as the first piece of evidence to connect undocumented immigrants to refugee status (9).…

    • 1135 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    One thing that is affected is the amount of wages. Employers choose undocumented workers because they can give them lower pay compared to the Americans and with this they can save a lot of money. So what happens is that the American will not have a choice but to either accept a low salary or don’t work at all (Davidson, 2013). For example, there is a vacant job at a certain restaurant as a janitor and both the illegal immigrant and a citizen are applying for the job. The employer sees that both of them are qualified and since one of them is an undocumented worker he or she can offer a lower pay for the job.…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays