Intertextuality Analysis

Superior Essays
Life in the 21st century has brought about incredible advances in technology, reasoning and creativity. With the development of the World Wide Web, we have seen ideas spread faster than ever and questions answered that no one ever thought existed. The reason for such advancements is credited to the progression of social networking on the medial platform, as well as the access to limitless resources that allow us to familiarize ourselves with topics that even the most extensive libraries in the world fail to include. The limitations of our world today haven’t even been brushed and we see no end in sight. Although modern technology has allowed us to advance in the ways that we write, there are certain ramifications to the access of information …show more content…
Does intertextuality damage the originality and validity of our claims, or does the idea of borrowing bits and pieces of information contribute meaning and credibility to our arguments as a whole? In this paper I will examine the fact that intertextuality has allowed the world to advance in the way that we write. Intertextuality does not in fact inhibit originality, but rather it is the sole reason people are able to generate new and influential point of views—by building upon writing of the …show more content…
Individuals in the modern world have become much more concerned about what belongs to them. One of the issues that has come to the world’s attention even more recently is the topic of plagiarism or borrowing writer’s ideas without permission. With the use of intertextuality and idea sharing, many of the writings that we see today are constructed of similar meanings and even exact references to other writing works. The problem that we see is that few people can differentiate between what is plagiarism and what is an original argument. Johndan Johnson-Eilola adds to this conversation by commenting that high school and college students often find difficulty in differentiating between their own ideas, and the ideas of someone that has made similar connections before. Johnson-Eilola asserts this by stating that “Because students still recognize the primary value placed on original text, they sometimes hide their borrowings and appropriations”. This is a compelling connection because with the modern emphasis on referencing borrowed work and giving credit to the owners, we often lose track of who is originally making the claim in the first place. Is the claim theirs, ours, or someone that we don’t even know exists? In the four years that I attended highschool, I never wrote a research oriented paper that didn’t require a formatted works cited page after the conclusion. Although this requirement was essential

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Elbert Jose Maria D. Hidalgo Jeffrey Garcia ENGLTWO 19 October 2015 Plagiarism in Literature My high school teacher once told me that plagiarism can be the same as copying a classmate’s homework. Since it’s also taking part of a work from another person without proper credit. But it doesn’t necessarily mean that we have very serious offenses similar to those who have practiced the real plagiarism.…

    • 133 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the essay, “Something Borrowed,” Malcolm Gladwell argues that there are three problems with plagiarism. He first describes that in the past plagiarism was merely seen as bad manners, and that it was not acceptable. In recent decades, it has become almost a criminal offense, which could actually tear a person’s life to shreds. Throughout the essay, Gladwell zeroes in on the idea that we must learn the difference between “borrowing that is transformative and borrowing that is derivative.” He states that creativity is being suppressed due to the inability for another person to use an idea and use for a greater good.…

    • 236 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Being a first-year college student, you are introduced to the idea of critical thinking early in order to gain intellectual knowledge for creating your own structure of writing. Not only is critical thinking an essential learning process, a student’s ability to understand a comparison of sources is especially imperative for a college education due to a variety of reasons. A rhetorical analysis not only explores the content of a given source, but it also refers to what the author is trying to portray to his or her audience. Learning about the skills of rhetorical analysis teaches you how to apply these comparisons and differentiate between types of writing such as a popular or scientific article. For instance, breaking down the context of a…

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thompson believes that the use of internet helps improve a writer’s ability to help clarify their thinking process, help clarify the audience’s mind even more, help improve memory of a writer, and help build connections with their audiences. The paper will investigate Thompson’s claims and evidence in order to prove that his argument is unsuccessful by examining his use of the of the following, logos and pathos. Thompson first states writing helps clarify our thinking. The type of evidence that he uses to support this claim was expert testimony using logos. He quotes from Cecil…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Arnie's Failing Grade

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages

    After reading and thinking carefully about the Unit 2 Case Study, I would rate the four characters in this way: Responsibility for Reggie's failing grade ***************************************** Reggie - 1 (most responsible) Arnie - 2 Sally - 3 Prof. Lovelit - 4 (least responsible) In my view, Reggie is most responsible for his own failing grade, due to his decision to: 1) not do the homework (reading), and 2) willfully take the essay from the internet and plagiarize. Arnie is number two on my list (in Reggie's failing grade), not because he also plagiarized, but because he was complicit in allowing his classmate to plagiarize. Arnie's response should have been to strongly remind a fellow student that plagiarism will only lead to a failing…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Plagiarism is taking others words and ideas verbatim. Understanding another person’s idea and using it to invoke your own unique idea is not plagiarism. In article “The Case of the Purloined Paper” Brigid Schulte argues about how students now a days are not putting enough effort in studying. Students are using internet to cheat on essays such as getting ideas from internet and using them to do their school assignments. I disagree with Schulte because understanding stealing others ideas and claiming them as your own is wrong and should be punished however, understanding others ideas to create your own point of view is not.…

    • 638 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We all can agree that wherever we go, we are told to not copy anyone’s work and to be original. Everyone gets ideas from other people and builds upon that which can make it hard to understand what can be plagiarism and what is not. This last issue with plagiarism that Gladwell described really puts the issues writers face into the light. People can write about anything, but what they do not realize is that somewhere it has been written before in a separate way and somewhere down the line somebody else will write about the same thing in their own unique…

    • 1091 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Is There “Generational Plagiarism”?” by Drucker and Gumpert, is an article that works in the sense of an informative essay, to brighten the horizon on “originality, a foundational concept of plagiarism as well as copyright law” (Drucker & Gumpert). The essay argues; “Is this case of copying truly the expression of a youth culture of authors, artists, and musicians who borrow and sample freely and thereby breathe new life into old works? Or does this example suggest the need to revisit traditional notices of plagiarism?” (Drucker & Gumpert). The motivation Drucker and Gumpert struck, was from the lack of disciplinary action being done to people plagiarizing work.…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “Cutting and Pasting: A Senior Thesis by (Insert Name)” is an essay about plagiarism and how cheating in high school and college is becoming more prevalent in classrooms. The structure shown in this essay focuses on a central thesis and is explained in a paragraph outlining reasons more specifically as well as using an outside source of a friend to further prove his thesis. Brent Staples, the author of this article, gives continuous evidence that relates entirely back to his thesis, as it should. This paper focuses on the integrity of the student itself, the threat to the learning process, and also shows how students are quick to the easiest route possible without actually comprehending the material. In the third paragraph, Staples talks about…

    • 156 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Order will always war with chaos. Consequently, there is a struggle for power between two technologies in use today, electronic media and print media. The internet, with its vast collection of information, inclines its users to read at a surface level, while a printed book, void of distractions, urges a close relationship with the reader. The benefit of a book lies in its ability to encourage introspection, creativity, and the pursuit of knowledge.…

    • 407 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Google Ruining Our Lives? I. Introduction A. The computer age has begun erasing our ability to think for ourselves, but in actuality has it. B. Search engines such as Google, Bing, and many more has increased our ability to become more reliant on computers other than books. C. Before the invention of the internet people use to read books and be more focused on skimming.…

    • 279 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Plagiarism Scandal

    • 185 Words
    • 1 Pages

    One of the suggested ways to avoid plagiarism mentioned by Abeer was to Document ones sources and keep those records for future use. It reminded me of a story I read last year about the importance of keeping drafts of your work. The plagiarism scandal occurred at The New York Daily News .the scandal began when readers noticed that Shaun King`s article on April 19th is similar to a previous article by The Daily Beast. The article contained coinciding text and it was without citation and there was even a typographical error found in the original.…

    • 185 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    plagiarism involving the Internet, paraphrasing or copying and pasting"(article, rimer Sarah page 196,197) students will quickly resort to using someone else's work if it means saving them mental agony and stress or time. A lot of students go on the Internet and believe that copying a piece or changing around someone's words is acceptable in small quantities or large. However what they don't realize is that taking someone's work without crediting it is actually a crime. Plagiarizing someone to work it's like stealing their long hours, mental stress and accomplishment in the click of a button. "There's a lot of students were growing up with the Internet were convinced that anything you find an online is public knowledge and doesn't need to be cited.…

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Intertextuality and Body-Mind Duality No matter how modern society might insist upon the ideas of copyright and intellectual property, no person’s work is truly his or her own. Texts ancient and new, contemporary or separated by centuries, invariably influence and build upon each other. In Ab Urbe Condita, Livy’s depiction of the Carthaginian leader Hannibal interacts with the depiction of the Roman conspirator Catiline featured in Bellum Catilinae, a work by the historian Sallust, a predecessor of Livy. The intertextual dialogue that occurs between Sallust’s description of Catiline and Livy’s description of Hannibal reveals the recurring theme of the relationship between the body and the mind.…

    • 1323 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Revenge Of The Text

    • 1210 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Goldsmith’s “Revenge of the Text” chapter strips down our normal, narrow understanding of language and widens both the definition and our minds, to include the raw material behind digital imagery (coding, binary etc…) It deliberates the ways in which data is preserved, carried and handled through the affluence of the digital world, and turned into information, often by way of what Flusser terms ‘black boxes’ (Flusser, “The Future of Writing, 67). He feels that having such powerful technology at our fingertips, with laptops, tablets, “apps” and social media networks, opens up endless possibilities for people as writers and we should, as a result, question our positions, as well as think about the changes to the “what” and “how” of the things we’re writing… “The writer’s role is being significantly…

    • 1210 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays