Pollution In The Middle Ages

Improved Essays
Today pollution has another meaning compared to how it was defined during the Middle Ages. Currently, pollution is the introduction into the environment of a substance that has harmful effects. Immediately one 's mind jumps to factory smoke or chemicals. However, for most people, a person judged to be simply out of place is not one of those definitions. Pollution was viewed not in its modern sense of bacteria or chemicals, but as in odd sense that confuses and contradicts cherished classifications. Gilman believes that it is this old definition of pollution that was used by those in fear to create a boundary from the “dirt.” And as soon as that wall was constructed imaginary or not, it would make everyone outside the wall as dangerous if they …show more content…
Douglas’s idea of pollution works at two levels. First are the social pressures that are used to influence one another’s behavior. One of the examples Douglas uses is the dying wish of an old man (Douglas, p. 3.) God was expecting them to follow the request of a now deceased person, if they didn’t follow they would be ostracized. The other form of pollution is of the mixing of social orders. Douglas uses the example of bodily fluids, especially sexual fluids to represent sexual order. The emphasis on sexual fluids is no coincidence; Douglas describes hybrids, the result of violating those orders, as beasts on the margins. The penalty of violation is that of the wrath of God. Specifically in this time period, the Black Death could be easily viewed as another disaster caused by those who did not yield to the ideal order to society. Those who are trying to explain the disease as a function of dirty ones encroaching the boundary allows for a false, but powerful sense of safety. If they believe the suffering is caused by the other, psychologically they are tricked into believing they are in no harm as long as that separation is maintained. That separation exists by the creation of a culture that defines what is disorder so to avoid it in favor of order. Douglas, through showing the process of “dirt” creation, is also …show more content…
Originally, the relatively unknown disease was assumed to be transmitted by homosexuals, heroin addicts, and Haitians. It was immediately directed towards the gay community even having the name Gay Related Immune Deficiency Syndrome (Gilman, p. 247.) The reality with AIDS was anyone was just as likely to acquire the disease: it was not exclusively those who were on the margins in the 1980’s. Gilman cites both perception of the increase of sexually transmitted diseases, and the growth of public awareness of homosexual emancipation, as creating the other mentality about those who had AIDS (Gilman, p. 247.) The obsession with sexual fluids during the Middle Ages was used to maintain order between those deemed pure and impure in the social hierarchy. Gilman quotes someone who refers to the cause of AIDS, “...as suffering an affliction of those who willfully violated the moral code [and] a punishment for sexual irresponsibility.” (Gilman, p. 248.) Class differences exist with AIDS as well: The heterosexual male is seen here as both the victim (of a polluted blood supply) as well as the source of pollution for his family. Homosexuals were seen by the greater population to be the cause and the source of pollution to heterosexual Americans. If one were to zoom out further at this time, Frenchman viewed the disease as an American born one, just like we viewed Haiti or now Africa. Geographically for

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    the media helped push this by using headlines such as "“Gay plague may lead to blood ban on homosexuals” this helped create the negative outlook on homosexual males this also help demonize and discriminate against them. In 1980s a report said that homophobic acts of violence heighten, this is directly related to the rumors of the Aids epidemic. Homosexual men were demonized and mistreated by people who believe that it was their fault. Even though the disease isn’t solely within homosexuals anymore there still a negative stigma. This disease has affected a lot people but the one that is mostly affected is homosexual males.…

    • 1273 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    However, it was discovered in 1986 that AIDS could in fact be contracted by heterosexuals, as accounts of AIDS spreading in heterosexual communities was spreading, despite efforts from the media to prolong the notion that AIDS was exclusive to homosexuals only. ‘Unexplained’ cases of women contracting AIDS through heterosexual activity emerged, although this revelation had some negative impact on the homosexual community as society blamed homosexuals for infecting their communities. This development in the AIDS epidemic saw the emergence of bisexuals, as men who were known to be heterosexual also sought pleasure from sexual acts with homosexual men, and therefore would be infected with the disease, thus transferring the disease onto heterosexual partners. The condemnation of the homosexual community for the infection of AIDS within the heterosexual community develops the idea that AIDS was originally socially constructed, maintained by the media and conservation groups in an effort to control the ‘sexual…

    • 1293 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I remember experiencing many of the same feelings as the characters in the movie. The feeling I remember experiencing the most was one of fear of being discriminated against because I was gay. The onset of the AIDS epidemic also brought about the added stigma of being part of the gay community. I believe the way that the film presented the issue of the AIDS epidemic chronologically was done well. When the AIDS epidemic first started, just the fact that AIDS was defined as a “gay cancer” that effected those in the gay community presented AIDS as a diversity issue.…

    • 1760 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When “I Want Your Sex” was released in 1987, the controversy surrounding the song stemmed from its sexually explicit lyrics such as “Sex is natural/ Sex is good/ Not everybody does it/ But everybody should” . However, as AIDS became a large issue in society during the 1980s, the song was not received as well as it could. AIDS became…

    • 1132 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This scene was one of the points in “Age of Aids” that made me frustrated. When millions are fighting and dying from the disease, it was swept underneath the rug and to the public they did something to deserve it. However, when Rock Hudson died, it was getting national coverage and a big issue. On the upside this was a positive, because it gave the AIDS epidemic a popular face.Although it did bring a negative context as well, since Rock Hudson was a homosexual, which only heightened the stigma associated with AIDS. Once it was public knowledge that Rock Hudson was a gay man, it made people believe that the disease was only spread between homosexuals even more strongly.…

    • 1353 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By the 1960’s the modern gay rights movement was gaining momentum and power, modeled of the African American civil rights movement. Both gays and blacks became more militant in their approaches- one lionized gay militant organization born was Queer Nation. The LGBTQ+ community began shattering the silence around homosexuality through the media, and by fighting off the stigma of being mentally ill. The LGBTQ+ community coupled its sense of oppression with a new sense of power, underscoring their movement and creating momentum for action, and this action was channeled into the Stonewall Rebellion. The Stonewall Riot was in no means the first or only way the modern gay rights movement fought for their rights and against heteronormativity.…

    • 930 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Two examples of irony in Letter 22 are seen when Screwtape calls God a hedonist and when Wormwood tried to get Screwtape in trouble. These examples are ironic because God is not a hedonist and Wormwood got a different result from what he was hoping would happen to Screwtape. 8. Noise for Screwtape represents hell for us. I associate noise with unpleasant sounds that cause disturbances.…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    According to Miller, society has become a subject of satire and ridicule. To emphasize, by mocking society of their utter habit to repeat actions that were inhumane to mankind, it proves that public executions will be no different. The outrageous forms of brutality inflicted on people should not be repeated but it has not been completely discontinued. Public executions has been changed into a practice that people have foolishly accepted. It is evident in Miller’s essay that he will never understand why society adapts to these kinds of horrendous laws all the name of jus-tice.…

    • 1757 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, the Furies, being bound by the sense of duty, are portrayed as villainous and unjust. If Orestes was just in fulfilling his duty, then by the same logic, the Furies should be justified in fulfilling theirs. By justifying the death of Clytemnestra, the death of Orestes also becomes justified. Therefore, the ruling in Orestes’ favor contradicts itself in that it both frees him and condemns him at the same time. The trial concerning Orestes and the madness that ran in his family is not an easy thing to judge.…

    • 915 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It should be against our moral standard to inflict such pain on a person to get information that may or may not be reliable, because people will say anything to make the pain stop. There have been reports that false information has been told to just stop the torture. I think that humans should feel morally bad about what torture does to people. We wouldn’t want that done to us. There are other ways to accumulate information from people.…

    • 880 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays