Police Body Cameras Argumentative Analysis

Improved Essays
Researchers from the University of Wyoming College of Criminal Justice, Associate Professors Scott Culhane John Boman, and Psychology Department Associate Professor Kimberly Schweitzer published their 2016 study in the journal Police Quarterly regarding the role body worn cameras play in public perceptions of whether police use of force is justifiable. Professor Culhane completed his post-graduate degree at the University of Texas El Paso in Legal Psychology from the University of Texas at El Paso. He is credited with co-authoring twenty-seven published peer-reviewed articles for a variety of criminal justice related topics (University of Wyoming, n.d.). Professor Boman received his post-graduate degree from University of Florida and Professor Schweitzer from the University of Wyoming (University of Wyoming, n.d.). Philadelphia Daily News and WHYY-FM news journalist Dana DiFilippo published a web article on the news website Philly.com regarding police body worn cameras. This material is utilized for background perspective on the pros and cons of police body worn cameras. DiFillippo’s article outlined several poignant points, both positive and negative, associated with the use of police body worn cameras. DiFilippo’s journalism covers crime, criminal justice, and breaking news stories (Muck Rack, 2016). Will Erstad researches and writes student-focused articles on a variety of topics for Rasmussen College where he published a (2016) web article published a web article regarding the police perspective on police body worn cameras. Erstad’s information provided background perspective on the pros and cons of police body worn cameras. Professor Mary Fan published a (2016) article regarding the court systems views on body worn cameras with emphasis on how the courts create new criminal procedures for police use of body worn cameras while also complying with constitutional mandates. …show more content…
Police body cameras are rapidly changing the landscape, not only in regards to public opinion, but also in regards to personal privacy for citizens. Fan’s article explored the judicial review and criminal procedure law impacts of police enforcement actions captured on body worn camera as evidence which overshadowing the long regarded standard of written police reports. As a special note, Fan’s article discussed rules for resistance by the courts of becoming seduced by overreliance on video evidence and explores the interpretive analysis on video (Fan, 2016). Fan is a University of Washington School of Law Professor and was a former federal prosecutor and a United Nations criminal tribunal legal officer with experience in international criminal law, domestic law, and criminology. Professor Fan works with the Harborview Medical Center's Injury Prevention & Research Center on interdisciplinary violence prevention research and she is an advisor with the American Law Institute Sexual Assault and Related Crimes Project (University of Washington School of Law Faculty Directory, 2015). The Constitution Project (TCP) counsel Madhuri Grewal, testified before the President’s Task Force on 21st Century Policing, Listening Session on Technology and Social Media on January 31, 2015. After several flashpoint incidents deaths related to law enforcement use of force of Eric Garner, Alton Sterling, Michael Browne, and countless others, Grewal testified on the use of law enforcement body-worn cameras to help counteract procedural injustices and help repair damages relationships between law enforcement and the communities they serve. The TCP (founded in 1997) serves as an organization watchdog promoter of constitutional protections, and criminal justice reform through protecting civil liberties much like the American Civil Liberties Union by developing and conducting research, issuing reports, policies, and legal or legislative briefs before Congress (Grewel, 2015). Grewel’s (2015) testimony included protection guidelines regarding police body-worn camera use for law enforcement …show more content…
Michael D. White examined benefits of use of police body-worn cameras based on available research and determined that agencies should not rush to implement body-worn camera programs without first establishing proper protocols of how and when the cameras are to be used. Dr. White (2014) contends the benefits of body-worn cameras including deterring poor behavior from officers and citizens, evidence supporting arrests, and increased law enforcement transparency resulting from body-worn cameras may bolster police legitimacy, but his study concluded current research lacked corroborative support for these claims. Additionally, citizens and police officer alike express privacy concerns, and officer safety issues, while agencies express concerns of cost output along with additional extended costs for training and policy

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Therefore, he is an expert in this field and has much experience dealing with cases regarding the consequences of police brutality due to the government not implementing body cameras. In addition, the author provides a reason to believe by uniquely expressing his viewpoint and boldly stating his opinion on the effect of body cameras on police officers and citizens. O’Mara states, “People act better when they know they're being watched -- or recorded. Cops act better, and the people they encounter on the street are more cooperative.” O’Mara references a studied commissioned by the Police Foundation in 2012 that displays statistical evidence proving few force incidents with body cameras.…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his essay “For Cops…” Kevin Johnson claims that videos of police officers are placing their actions under new scrutiny and changing the way that claims against officers are played out in court. Police have responded by trying to limit such recordings when they feel that they interfere with police actions. The fear that is most present in law enforcement is that these videos will cause officers to change how they behave in a life or death situation. To combat this, officers are now receiving training to deal with being recorded.…

    • 978 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Body cameras change the way police officers interact with the public for the better. One quote from journalresource.org that emphasizes my point is ¨Officers who did not wear cameras performed 9.8% more stop-and-frisks and…

    • 488 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Argument for Police Body Cameras Recently, there have been several cases of police violence brought to light by media coverage. Some people think it is justified while others see it as racial profiling or unnecessary brute force. No matter what perspective people look at it from, the cases have to be solved and justice must be served. However, many times there are several different sides to the stories told by witnesses or people involved that contradict each other, making it hard to reach a verdict.…

    • 233 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    This however could be contradictory if the officer does not tell or report the whole story. Without clear limits, body worn cameras may become just another tool for law enforcement rather than a mechanism for police accountability. Several studies on police body cameras have encouraging…

    • 1270 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Many cases arise where police or the civilian can not recall certain events or specific details that occurred in the situation and the police body cameras will solve that and provide a valuable extra piece of information for misconduct situations. The investment may prove to be costly, but can end up saving law enforcement time and money because body cameras can prevent court trials based on misinformation. The body cameras can help strengthen and enhance transparency and accountability in the police department. Police can also feel further protected from the possibility of false complaints. (Ferrarin, par.…

    • 1811 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The article Police Body Cameras analyzes the possible outcomes of this idea. The article states that using body cameras could offer protection to both parties, equating to a win-win scenario. Not only would the footage “protect the public against police misconduct”, but it would also “protect the police against false accusations of abuse” (p. 8). The footage collected from the cameras would offer accurate account of incidents which have in the past been blurred with bias against police as well as the blue shield of trust which protects fellow officers from their wrongdoing with cover up stories. The same article further explains that body cameras could be the bridge of trust needed between the public and law enforcement through the feeling of security they provide.…

    • 1279 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the biggest police shootings was the one that occurred in Ferguson, Missouri when Michael Brown was murdered by a police officer. Police reports stated that Brown was the aggressor even though all eyewitness reports say that was not the case. This led to an uprising in the police body cam movement because with these cam, police and other law officials would have a proper account of what actually happened. After this shooting, officers, Scott E. Culhane, John H. Boman, and Kimberly Schweitzer decided to take it into their own hands and create an experiment to test out the effects of police cameras. They compared real life police events when suspects knew police were wearing cameras to when the police…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Police body cameras can be the next big thing to help and protect officers and get the accused criminals. Although opponents say that police body cameras can invade privacy it does not because it is a way that officers can get evidence of what happened that day and it can help in court cases if an officer is being accused of something they didn’t do or if the officer did something wrong that he did not supposed to do. Police body cameras can also get evidence if the police officer is doing his or her job well. It can also help in having…

    • 1266 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With all the police brutality claims now there is so much controversy over police officers wearing body cameras. Some people feel that the officers should wear the cameras so that there will be a video of everything happening and there will be proof of what is going on between the officers and the civilians. Other people do not want the cameras because it violates people’s privacy. This has been an ongoing debate for a while now. In this essay I want to show some of the benefits for the body cameras.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Body Cameras

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This study has won multiple awards in excellence in law enforcement and excellence in evidence based policing. When it comes to body worn cameras, there are multiple reasons as to why they should be an essential part of the officers’ uniforms. For one, it provides a clear image of what the officer sees from his perspective. Another reason why is that with these cameras on, people tend to behavior in a more mannered way knowing that they are being filmed. On top of this, they are relatively small, about the size of a tube of chapstick.…

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Records show that the public’s trust in the police is at an all time low; therefore departments using body cameras have a greater advantage of increasing trust and improving relationships with the general public. Police body cameras benefit all parties, they provide documented objective video evidence that can be used to prosecute or exonerate a suspect (Gass). All in all, the launch of police body cameras protects civilians, and provides a record of the interactions between police officers and…

    • 1036 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many court cases have ended up in a flip lately because these body cameras are capturing the real live story. Did the police officer make the right decision or are they caught in the middle of a crime where they are the real criminal? In the article “Police Body Cameras: Should law enforcement agents wear body cameras?” it explores the pros and cons of body cameras, as well as real life stories that have occurred in the public. This article carries valid evidence that police body cameras have both positive and negative…

    • 861 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Police Discretion Essay

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Police Discretion is at the core of policing, allowing officers to approach different situations with different approaches. Discretion is seen as the most essential element of policing, yet discretion is also the source of many problems. Over the year’s discretion has become a more prominent issue amongst the public, and due to social media and the increased use of the internet, videos and new reports can be shared with millions in a matter of seconds. Yet the truth is the discretion an officer’s use is comprehensively subjective to real-world situations rather than adopted by a certain agenda. Police discretion an essential and required part of police work (Schulenberg, 2015, pg.247).…

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Importance Of Body Cameras

    • 1505 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The citizens of the United States have been debating whether the police should wear body cameras. Recently this debate has gotten a lot more prevalent after the unjust deaths of an unarmed teen in Ferguson, Missouri , and the death of Eric Garner in New York City. The United States death by police rate is by far higher than any other country, “ In 2011 police killed six people in Australia, two in England, six in Germany, and according to an FBI count, 404 in the United States.” (Stanley 2). Body cameras are small compact cameras that police would have to wear in order for law enforcement agencies to see what exactly occurred if there was a problem.…

    • 1505 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics