Plug Into The Experience Machine Analysis

Better Essays
P1. If pleasure is what we value most and we will experience more pleasure by doing x rather than doing y, then we should do x over y
P2. We will experience more pleasure by plugging into the Experience Machine than not plugging into the Experience Machine
C1: If all that matters to us is maximising pleasure then we should want to plug into the experience machine. (P1&P2)
P3. We have reason to not want to plug into the Experience Machine
C2. Therefore, experiencing as much pleasure as possible is not the only thing we value
We can see that in premise three that Nozick is relying on an assumption that people would not want to plug into the experience machine. Nozick assumes that everyone, or at least most people, are unwilling to spend their
…show more content…
And yet to this counter-argument, people may be further inclined to say: “What is the point if I get everything I want? Pleasure without knowing pain is nothing. It is neutral. What is happiness without sadness?” The Experience Machine, and additionally the reasons to not plug in, can suggest that we need more from life than pleasure in order to be satisfied. Pain and pleasure for many are two sides of the same coin and you cannot define much of one experience without the other. Some may say that the Experience Machine that has only the ‘inside’ or only the ‘outside’ view is not a human experience.
However, this judgement seems to come from another common assumption that something can only be appreciated through comparison. It is interesting to question: Is our intuition the same in the reverse scenario? For example, would we feel right in claiming that a person who has been abused since birth and has therefore only known negative experiences, is not worth rescuing from their situation because their lack of positive experiences means they have never experienced negative ones either? The gut reaction for most I assume is “of course not”. So with what reasoning can we assume that this alleged
…show more content…
For example, you could go into the machine with the knowledge that your family and all the animals on earth will be taken care of and the environment will be maintained. However, one can also argue that once you begin to alter the parameters of the experience machine you are essentially affirming Nozick’s conclusion. Nozick might respond with: “Well of course you find the Experience Machine more appealing now because we addressed concerns other than your own individual pleasures, such as a responsibility owed to our family and the environment." As a result, we are just illustrating that we need something other than our own individual pleasures it order to be satisfied. Furthermore, it seems that we 've already started to transform the real world into some kind of experience machine and if so, why bother leaving it at that point? If this is the way that Nozick intends for participants to be able to choose their reality, then the thought experiment is basically immune to any kind of objections that one can think of, and, as a result, we cannot find a solution to it through empirical

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    In ignorance, I assumed that when treated as exactly equal, they would become equal. While my stance has not altogether changed, it has become less clear-cut and monochrome. I have very little experience with those that have a mental disorder, so I can only speak from what I have learned through the past few weeks. Those with mental disabilities cannot be treated as totally equal to those without, that would be illogical. Ignoring the differences does not help the individual get the assistance that they desperately need, and it does not help our consciousness as a society by blind ignorance.…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Some would contend that if we may feasibly die tomorrow, should we not live today as hedonistically as possible? While I can understand the reasoning behind this claim, I would continue to say that recklessly unjust acts can only grant temporary pleasure. This instant bliss may be all that is needed for some people who are perfectly fine with acting unjustly. For others, however, these actions may have long-term effects that could result in feelings of dissatisfaction, guilt, or pain. The concept of time when applied to the question of how we should live our lives plays a huge role in determining whether it is more reasonable to act justly or unjustly for each individual.…

    • 1130 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This “disease concept” implies that the user has no control over the addition and possibly even inherited the addiction (Wilson and Kolander 271). This correlates directly with Szalavitz’s claim that the majority has a wrong view of how addiction works. However, in “Can You Get Over Addiction”, multiple times Szalavitz states that “addiction is a disease.” Even though Szalavitz states that addiction is a disease, she claims it is different because it does not affect overall intelligence or control over the drug. With this in mind, addiction might affect the brain…

    • 2363 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This is a better analysis of the word “value” because even a normal, fully conscious person is not aware of all that they value. For example, most people would respond to the question “What do you value?” with “My friends, my family, my significant other, etc.” However, there could be many other things that they value (such as health care and a driver’s license) that they do not think about. Thus, valuing something is a greatly subconscious act. To wrong someone, the person who is wronged needs to have interests – they need to be losing something of value in order to be harmed. Otherwise, there would be no harm done and the person would not be suffering.…

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    There are more cases regarding those whose desires do not coincide with their self-interest and these contradict the theory of psychological egoism. In cases where a psychological egoists would claim that everyone would expect even just a little bit of benefit, does not take into account pessimistic people or people who know that the action will not benefit them at all (Shafer-Landau, 2015). Using sincere love as an example, the claim that our actions are motivated our strongest desire would not hold up because our self-interested desires would not be our priority; rather, you would want the other person to be happy even if it caused you pain (Jorati, 2014). There are times that people go after their own self-interest, however if they did it all the time, there would be no sense of morality. Even Shafer Landau (2015) states “If all we can do is look out for Number One, then there is little point in demanding we do otherwise.” (pg.104).…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Happiness is complicated because of all that it takes to reach this end. There may be times when you are happy and can also be unhappy but either way you will go through trials and tribulations to meet the goal of happiness. This is why happiness is considered to be more of a state of one’s mind and not how a person may feel. External goods encompass vast feelings and can maneuver from one feeling to another whereas, happiness is just that or unhappiness. Taylor talks much about these external goods which are things such as wealth, fame and glory that are all a part of happiness.…

    • 822 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    RECONSTRUCTION Robert Nozick argues that most people would chose not to plug into an experience machine, since it would essentially be a form of suicide, and since most people more than likely care about more than just experiences. The motivation behind this thought experiment is hedonism’s claim that pleasure is our sole aim in life. Nozick argues that if hedonism were true, then everyone would plug in, but since most people would not plug in, hedonism must be false. So, the purpose of this thought experiment is to find what matters more than experience – or pleasure. To do this, he begins by asking us to “suppose there were an experience machine that would give you any experience you desired [for two years at a time].” You can manufacture whatever experience you like, or you can choose from a wide selection of generic experiences most people desire.…

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When obtaining pleasure, acts that we prefer are seen to be more pleasurable than acts that we dislike. For example, someone who really enjoys exercise will gain more pleasure when exercising than someone who does not enjoy exercising. Therefore, how we feel about an act affects how much pleasure we obtain. Thus, pleasure is also subjectively understood. The subjective understanding best describes what we think of pleasure.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    First, most people know from experience that the harder you try to obtain happiness the less likely you are to succeed in obtaining it. This poses a problem for Hedonism; if happiness is to be our ultimate goal in order for us to have a good life, then it makes sense to try to obtain happiness. However, as stated above, typically the more focus you place on something such as finding happiness, the less likely you are to get it. Though this contradiction seems like it could prove Hedonism to be wrong, it fails to do so. A Hedonist could simply say that there is no direct path to happiness, and attempting to obtain happiness this way is incorrect; instead one should focus on things which make us happy for their own sake, such as a…

    • 2068 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The reason behind their belief is that labeling doesn’t really have any effect on the offender unless they accept those labels and view them as someone who is bad like how they are being label. Generally, when young offender get label they believe that there’s no way for them to turn back and fixed their mistake because now everyone will treat them differently compare to a normal person. This also apply to people that live in poverty and…

    • 1427 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays