Plan B Skip College Critical Analysis

Improved Essays
The central claim of the article that I read entitled “Plan B: Skip College” is that higher education in America is becoming more of an issue in the sense that college doesn’t equate to success for everybody as predicted by conventional beliefs. In fact, there are people who have earned their degree and are currently struggling to meet their financial obligations due to outstanding college loans or they have settled for a lower paying job out of necessity. I agree with the central claim of this reading for I have witnessed people struggle after college and I have witnessed others struggle because they don’t have a college education therefore providing other options for higher education is essential at this point in time. Everybody realizes …show more content…
Each college student is responsible for ensuring that they utilize the educational resources available to excel in their desired careers. Both of the readings are similar in the sense that they each point out issues that can be improved upon when concerning higher education and both agree that higher education is necessary stepping stone once the individual chooses what type of higher education is best for them and how they want to attend classes. Although both articles are in agreement that higher education is vital, “Plan B: Skip College” states that a college degree is not essential for everyone to be successful which differs from “Online Higher Educations Individualist Fallacy” idea that the college culture is vital to a person’s success not just as a student but to the well-rounded individual that college institutions sets out to develop. Also, the two readings are different in the rhetorical devices used, “Plan B: Skip College” uses a logical and expert approach and therefore I feel that the persuasive devices used are ethos and logos while, on the other hand, "Online Higher Education Individualist Fallacy" uses Kairos and Pathos to persuade the reader by finding the opportune moment to introduce his arguments and trying to evoke feelings about online college versus

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The Value of Education: A Liberal Approach Three Reasons College Still Matters, Stand and Deliver, Education’s Hungry Hearts, and Admiral McRaven’s speech at the University of Texas convey the value of education. Three Reasons College Still Matters by Andrew Delbanco discusses the major advantages of college education, particularly economic, political and personal development — the latter of the three being dismissed by college attendees and high school graduates alike. The economic advantage of college education is well known by parents and stressed to children by family and schools. For the many, it is the prime reason to attend college and serves as the first step towards working up the social ladder. In his essay, Delbanco includes the…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Should everyone go to college?” by Stephanie Owen and Isabel Sawhill examine whether or not going to college is the right choice for everybody and also what kind of return one can expect financially. The factors that they scrutinize are the institute attended, field of study, whether the student graduates, and post- graduation occupation. It is easy to say that college is always the right choice, especially so for parents and particularly in the world we live in today where every little boost we get can make a huge difference. But Owen and Sawhill argue that college may not be the best option for everyone and telling someone to go to college despite their ability or financial standing could be doing them a disservice. There will always…

    • 412 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Robert Perry is arguing that there needs to be more colleges, universities, and community colleges to offer Americans the opportunity to receive a higher education, because people with a post secondary education are in high demand. He begins his argument by presenting an opposing argument from author Charles Murray. Perry then points out what is wrong with Murray’s argument, and presents an alternative idea. Perry assumes that his audience will be not agree with Murray’s idea of completely eliminating most of the higher education student body and therefore presenting the idea that higher education is needed because without it we can’t lead the global economy, there will be more jobs that require a degree, and that the fastest growing job categories…

    • 899 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    College, Is it Right For Everyone? Linda Lee’s essay “The Case Against College”, which will be summarized here;entails an answer to the question, is college necessarily right for every high school graduate? Lee writes from the perspective of a parent trying to guide her child in the best direction. She declares that America is fixated on college, by referring to America’s college graduate rate which is the second-highest internationally. Lee expresses her opinion that a high school graduate who has no desire to get any further education will not reap the benefits of college, because they will not obligate themselves to go to classes or complete assignments.…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Charles Murray’s “Are Too Many People Going to College” makes key points as to why so many students now go away to college and why they should consider not attending the four years of continued education. Murray discusses many aspects such as why so many students feel the need to further their education, when to focus on the liberal arts in a child 's education, and whether all students have the mental capacity to attend college. He then questions if acquiring a degree is necessary for all jobs and comments on the labels that come with not pursuing a higher education To begin with, Murray suggests that a liberal arts education should be taught to students at a young age and should be the foundation of their education. He points out that young…

    • 1084 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For years’ parents have told their kids that college is a must and that you have to do it, but in The Basement of the Ivory Tower has another thought about that. Which is Professor X that explain why he feels that college is not for everyone and shares his experience of teaching people that are just not ready for that level yet. So an individual might ask themselves am I that student, or is it really that necessary to go to college just too higher myself and in reality its getting me more in debt; on top of that what if I fail and I have to retake the class and pay for it what happens then? All these questions are what we need to think about because these are very important believe it or not.…

    • 1047 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This statement is supported by the quote that “it is estimated that in the U.S., approximately 50% of students who start college never graduate” (page 680). This is because they are either not prepared academically and financially, or simply do not have a drive to learn. In addition to that, even if they do go,…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When is College your Friend When growing up, college has been so ingrained in my family that the idea of not doing so never even occurred to me. However for others, attending college has become one of the most paramount decisions in our life as a result of its extensive potential for consequence of both favorable and not. Due to its deeply controversial nature, the answer is not just in black and white. In Caroline Bird’s article “College is a Waste of Time and Money”, she has created a sensational work, but one that simply can’t hold up to scrutiny upon a closer inspection.…

    • 1084 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From the day we start school, it is drilled into our brain that college is the only way to have a good future, but that may not be the case at all. Just ask Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, and Mark Zuckerberg. Although it helps to have a revolutionary idea like these men, it is not necessary. Ordinary people can also achieve success without a college degree. At least, that’s what Charles Murray in his article “Are Too Many People Going to College?”…

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Matthews also declares the argument that someone would be better off in their career if they had decided to pursue a degree futile. We are generally unaware of what the lowest twenty-five percent of earners with a college education would have earned without their degree. This makes room to argue that up to one-fourth of college graduates should not have attended college. Most students planning to attend college, along with current college students would not take this suggestion seriously because everybody thinks that their degree will pay off in the end. Nobody wants to think that their investment of time and money…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A college education was once deemed as the finest ticket to a better life. However, the rising costs of higher education, the burden of student debt, and an insecure job market have left many wondering: Are too many people going to college? Political scientist, Charles Murray, wrote “Are Too Many People Going to College?” published in 2012 in They Say/I Say: The Moves That Matter in Academic Writing: With Readings, and he argues that there are, in fact, too many people going to college. While this seems like an easily disputable claim, it is important to realize that America’s graduation rate sits at an appalling fifty-three percent, including community colleges.…

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We view “college as a job” that gives substantial earnings returns to a college degree, irrespective of occupation, whether an individual is an insurance agent or a rocket scientist. This is not true because there are people with high degrees, like a PhD or a computer programmer, who have lost their jobs to layoffs. So having a college degree does not guarantee “substantial returns,” as Richard Vedder summarizes in his article, “For Many, College Isn’t Worth It." Vedder thinks the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) are fairly accurate and that college is not worth it for everyone because we are all created differently. An impartial understanding of the information is that school is justified, despite all the trouble, for some huge number of youngsters, but is a significantly more financially dangerous…

    • 1046 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the reading “Are Too Many People Going to College?” first published in 2008, Charles Murray argues that while the need and idea of going to college and getting a B.A. is becoming increasingly more important, not everyone needs a college education. Murray believes that any student that has already graduated from high school has already, in a sense, obtained a college education. He points out that by the time students finishes eighth grade, they should already have learned all the “core knowledge” they need to know (236). By the time they get to high school, students should be focusing more on the liberal aspect of education by taking courses in the “humanities, social sciences, and sciences” where they are “taught at a level below the demand…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the article, “College is a waste of time” by Dale Stephens, Dale gives his persuasive opinions on why college is a waste of time by giving out evidences of how college isn’t fully beneficial and describing people who are successful today without a college degree. Dale describes college as “rewarding conformity, regurgitation, and theory”, instead of, “rewarding independence, learning, and application”. Providing that college is also hungry for people’s wallet, The College Board Policy Center showed that tuitions have increased 3.6 times since 30 years ago. Not everyone needs college to be successful such as Mark Zukerberg who made it big without a diploma. Summing up the article, Dale states that in the end it’s people’s choice to look for…

    • 1046 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Should Students Go to College? Many students are faced with the demanding decision on whether or not to attend college. The entire concept of college can be overwhelming for some people because of the commitment; however, college degrees now seem essential for career development. When discussing college certain people have different opinions, causing confusion to some students. For example, in Bryan Caplan's article "The World Might Be Better Off Without College for Everyone," he provides his own views about college.…

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays