Carlo Collodi's Adaptation Of Pinocchio

Better Essays
To most audiences the story of Pinocchio is a lighthearted one, filled with the adventures of a jovial puppet and his cricket conscience with the occasional unnerving scene. Yet this is not the dark and death defying tale that author Carlo Collodi originally wrote in his 1883 novel. As is the case with many Disney adaptations, the original story of Pinocchio has been erased from the public consciousness and replaced by that of the adaption. This erasure is due to the quality of the film and its impact on popular culture. In addition, modern adaptations employ the modifications made by the 1940 film while eschewing the darker aspects of the original novel. Furthermore, the sheer cultural and economic power of its creator company, the “Disney …show more content…
Collodi’s narrative is rather demented and bitter. Due to this contrast, producers chose to base their adaptations after the kid-friendly Disney adaption rather than the original. The original Pinocchio is laced with cruel scenes that are rather inappropriate for a children's story. In chapter 4, for example, Pinocchio crushes the sagious “Talking Cricket” with a hammer. In the film, however the “Talking Cricket” is the now famous “Jiminy Cricket” and acts as Pinocchio’s kindhearted conscious. Author Carlo Collodi originally wanted to end the story with the poor puppet hanging from a tree. Hanged by the characters of Fox and Cat (Honest John and Gideon in the Film) disguised as assassins. Collodi’s description of this horrible event is graphic “A few minutes went by and then a wild wind started to blow. As it shrieked and moaned, the poor little sufferer was blown to and fro like the hammer of a bell. The rocking made him seasick and the noose, becoming tighter and tighter, choked him. Little by little a film covered his eyes.”(ch15) This part of the book, along with most other explicit content was omitted from the Disney adaption, and with good reason. The few remaining violent scenes are reactions to the puppet’s most grievous sins, such as not going to school, and partaking in the sins of “Pleasure island”. Collodi’s editors had a similar mindset to Disney when they forced him to write a more pleasant ending. One where the “Fairy …show more content…
In classrooms the original story of Pinocchio is seen as strange and off putting. It is not for the demented content within the book, rather it is the contrast between the original work and the Disney rendition which astounds us. The public is no longer aware of Collodi’s vision due to the 1940 film’s success as a piece of art. The film was too influential culturally for the novel to keep up. Leading many to be unaware of its existence. Any other adaption would be taking a risk if they tried to emulate the comparatively dark novel, so instead producers follow the successful and kid-safe Disney adaption. The branding power of the “Disney Corporation” allowed the film to become the standard edition of the Pinocchio fairy tale. When put against one another the 1883 novel was out-marketed and underexposed. While still one of the most popular books of all time, the public is now blinded to Pinocchio’s original adventure by the big

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Reading the Grimm Brother’s version was a shock to me. Growing up, I loved Disney’s Cinderella and reading the original tale had me in disbelief. I couldn’t believe they were the same tale! The original tale was dark and gruesome, but a little more realistic and then it turned into this enchanted tale that ends in a happy ending for everyone. It was easy to spot the changes between the two, due to the fact that they are obviously drastic.…

    • 1289 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Harry Potter Book Vs Movie

    • 1141 Words
    • 5 Pages

    One of those details most fans were mad about was that Peeves didn’t make it into the movies. Peeves is a mischievous poltergeist that caused trouble for Harry and his friends. One could argue that Peeves really isn’t essential to the plot and they would be right, but he does become more important when he fights against the bad guys in Order of the Phoenix and the Deathly Hallows books. Also he…

    • 1141 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    If Lotso was a moral person, he would help out the people that saved him. But, since he is an evil being, he was ungrateful and did not do as he was asked. Lotso made all the toys in Sunny Side Day Care go through terrible experiences, all because of his traumas. Lotso was like a dictator to the toys. In the movie, “ Lotso switches Buzz back into his original “space ranger” mode, and he makes him imprison all of his friends.…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Teddy Bear Analysis

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Not only he does the voice for the protagonist as he also wrote, produced and directed the film. This is one of the main problems with the movie as he is unable to direct and give a correct direction to the film. He tries to recreate a "Family Guy" episode instead of making a film. Yes, a musical number in his TV show at work a lot of times, but when you're going to watch Ted you are no expecting to have a huge musical number as the opening act of this movie. His inexperience behind at directing a movie is what gives this movie a big drop of quality and makes it feel insipid.…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the infamous play, Midsummer Night’s Dream, the chracter known as Robin Goodfellow AKA Puck is, against all odds, is the most powerful character in the play. There is no one who has more power and influence than little Puck. Puck is a mischeivous little fellow, and he does indeed find a way to strike fear into people’s hearts, while still being a great guy who is loved throughout the land. Oddly enough, but the fun-sized fairy of Puck is, in fact, feared by the society in Midsummer Night’s Dream,…

    • 1218 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    They turned a relationship with nature into magic, but they also just made the Native Americans look stereotypical. In the film, the song “Savages” is played. If you listen to the song, Disney was absolutely out of their mind when writing it for a kid’s movie not to mention the fact that it makes the Native Americans out to be that bad people (Pocahontas). The song states, “What can you expect from filthy little heathens? Their whole disgusting race is like a curse.…

    • 1206 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Squeaky Boots Analysis

    • 1036 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In “Tell Tale Heart” the narrator in the end confesses his guilt to the police officers, just like Mr. Krabs confesses to everyone in the Krusty Krab. When the narrator of “Tell Tale Heart” confesses he says, “Villains I shrieked dissemble no more I admit the deed tear up the planks” (Poe 306). This quote shows how the narrators’ guiltiness leads him to confessing. In SpongeBob, Mr. Krabs took the boots from SpongeBob because he hated the squeaking sound. SpongeBob feels terrible thinking that he lost the boots, because he thought they were important to Mr. Krabs.…

    • 1036 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    There was a long jagged scar that ran across his face; what teeth he had were yellow and rotten; his eyes popped and he drooled most of the time” (Lee 16). When Boo comes to their aid at the end of the book, Scout learns that he was nothing like they described him. He was a good man who was unfortunately the victim to the gossip of the town. The reason he had become so feared by the townsfolk is the simple fact that people like Stephanie Crawford had written his story for him, and were incredibly fallacious. He was hated for something illogical by children he cared about.…

    • 1750 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The chemistry between Daniel Radcliffe (Harry Potter) and Gary Oldman was just too amazing to be unnoticed. Oldman was actually a miscast, since he didn't really resemble the character description in the book, but you can't simply imagine anyone else playing Sirius Black since he portrayed him absolutely fantastic. However, there is one other role that would totally make you wonder why he didn't win an Oscar, and that is his role in the film, Tinker Tailor Soldier…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Radley passed by, Boo drove the scissors into his parent’s leg’ This also implies that humans are quick to judge. This rumour makes Boo sound extremely violent but when it says ‘and resumed his activities’ it makes him sound ‘psychotic’ which would scare the children even more. Lee uses Jem, Scout, and Dill to imply that humans are quick to judge throughout the novel. For example: Scout sees that her teacher is strongly against Hitler but supports the unfair conviction of Tom Robinson. She says: ‘it’s not right to persecute anybody is it’ this shows the hypocrisy between the adults in the town.…

    • 1103 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays