Physical Abuse Case Study

Great Essays
Section A. Shelli Rose Dewey, Petitioner, v. Carolyn Myles, et al., Respondents. On September 12th, 2004, Shelli Rose Dewey, a Nevada resident, called Elko County Police frantically stating that her husband, Steven Dewey, was stabbed by an unknown assailant. Upon police arrival, Dewey was moderately intoxicated. Witnesses stated that the couple had been at a nearby bar earlier in the day when the bartender asked the two to leave. Thirty minutes following their ejection from the bar, witnesses claimed to see the Deweys arguing loudly in the parking lot. A witness then saw Shelli Dewey “draped over” Steven Dewey, yelling hysterically “Please don’t die! Please don’t die on me!” (Dewey v. the State of Nevada, 2007) Dewey was brought into custody …show more content…
Lenore Walker, author of The Battered Woman, states that battered woman syndrome, an “identifiable cluster of symptoms” present in women that were victims of long-term physical abuse, occurs in three distinct phases. These three phases, tension-building, acute battering, and contrition, define the “cycle of abuse” suffered by the female victim. (Costanzo & Krauss, 2015) This cycle of abuse typically leads to learned helplessness, the point in which a victim “becomes resigned to their suffering and fail to resist or leave their abuser”. (Costanzo & Krauss, 2015) Women suffering from battered woman syndrome typically display certain submissive characteristics as a direct result of the psychological trauma. Trial counsel will often use battered woman syndrome in trial to defend a female batterer’s killing of her significant …show more content…
Oftentimes, testimony from an expert on the syndrome is often excluded from trial, however, by a judge that acknowledges the “scientific validity of [battered woman syndrome], and a concern that expert testimony unfairly bolsters the credibility of the alleged victim.” (Costanzo & Krauss,

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    The prosecution claims that Mrs. Stephens is not suffering from battered woman syndrome, that she can reason normally, and so she pre-mediated the murder of her husband the night of his death. The defense argues that Mrs. Stephens acted in self-defense on the basis of Battered Woman Syndrome and claims she experiences certain symptoms that correlate with the syndrome.…

    • 2831 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Introduction Domestic violence is everywhere around us and for some of us it is not something new. It comes in many forms physical, emotional, and psychological. The abuse is very real and when it starts we are the last to notice it. Nothing is worse then being the person on the outside looking in watching mothers, sisters, and friends go through it without being able to do anything is hard.…

    • 1505 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Anywhere from 1­3 million women are battered each year for asinine reasons, such as the dinner was too hot or too cold. As if you had just wandered into the “The Three Little Bears den.” Women have been violated because the bed was not made right, the house was not clean, they looked at someone, they were too fat or too skinny or “I” just felt like…

    • 1634 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jane Stafford

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages

    553). Conclusion Ultimately, this paper examines the underlying reasons to justify why battered women kill their abusers, and subsequently plea for self-defence, in the presence or absence of an imminent threat. Through literature review, a battered woman who kills and pleas for self-defence can be justified as rational thinking, however, does not produce a self-defence verdict in the absence of an imminent threat; on the contrary, in the presence of an imminent threat, a self-defence verdict is rendered.…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An article in the Social Science & Medicine discusses the variance between males and female victims, and their abusers. According to their studies, results varied depending on the source of data. When collecting data from the justice system and police, they found intimate partner violence to be higher among females. However, when analyzing results within communities, women are the same if not more likely than men to instigate one act of physical aggression towards a male counterpart in their lifespan. This demonstrates the natural tendencies females have towards violence as…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Men are often expected to be assertive and dominant, while women are often portrayed as vulnerable and emotional. These gender roles suggest that men are more likely than women to turn to aggression during times of anger, which has correlation to abuse against their female partners (Campbell and Muncer 286). As a result of domestic violence, women often suffer from mental and health problems such as chronic pain, traumatic brain injury, eating disorders, diabetes, asthma, and if the abuse is severe enough, even death (Tremer). Although there are already certain programs and laws that exist to help women who have experienced domestic and sexual abuse such as the Violence Against Women Act, women’s rights activists work to change traditional gender roles, educate women on how to prevent or cope with abuse, and provide support groups for individuals and families that have been victimized by abuse (Zimmerman, et al.…

    • 1304 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    R. V Lavallee Case Study

    • 1753 Words
    • 8 Pages

    In law, it is the duty of judges to be objective and have the same rules be applicable to all its subordinates, but is it fair to expect men and women to behave the same way in certain circumstances? In many cases judges must apply the objective standard of reasonableness to understand the actions of the appellant in the case. Women who are in an abusive relationship have a different state of mind therefore perceive and react to threats in a different manner. Such conditions may cause the women to suffer from battered woman syndrome. Thus, in such cases if a woman was to kill her abusive partner as a result of her fearing for her life, it should be justified in court as a valid self-defence claim.…

    • 1753 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Approximately 900,000 children are abused in the U.S each year Three times as many children are mistreated as are reported to CPS agencies. About 80 percent of the children that die from abuse in the united states are under the age of four. Children are abused at home or by someone they know. Children are afraid of them, so they don't tell or talk to anyone. Physical child abuse can happen to any child of any race, religion, or economic status.…

    • 453 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A person is only able to use force when it is self-defense and they are threatened with imminent harm. If a person strikes another person on the condition of future harm and self-defense, they may not be entitled to rely on self-defense (Brody & Acker, 2010). When a woman assaults or kills her abusive husband, it is especially relevant (Brody & Acker, 2010). Battered Woman Syndrome theory was developed in the 1970’s for abused women. It is sometimes used in court as a mitigation in homicide cases where the battered spouse kills their abuser.…

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Battered Women Syndrome

    • 1572 Words
    • 6 Pages

    “Be completely humble and gentle; Be patient, bearing with one another in love. Make every effort to keep the unity of the spirit through the bond of peace”(Ephesians 4:2-3, New International Version). Patience, love, and humility are important virtues in the sacred vow that is marriage. An absence of these virtues often leads to a destructive relationship between man and wife. Due to extensive abuse by their partner, there have been many instances in which victims of Battered Women Syndrome have assaulted and/or killed their abusers.…

    • 1572 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is a double standard when it comes to female and male sex workers in this risky industry. Much like society, female workers are expected to be submissive and catering to men’s needs. Therefore, any man who chooses this as his trade of choice is compared to a woman and seen as feminine and thus weak. (Stoddard, 2014). Most male prostitutes that do partake in the trade, regardless of their willingness and consent to work, have been stereotyped as weak victims of overpowering, more dominant men.…

    • 2053 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Around 25-45% there are women that are being abused while they are pregnant. Most of these domestic violence incidents are not reported. When a woman that suffers from BWS, she often share the same features of other victims. Some of these features are Taking full control of the assault and start to find it hard or difficult to accuse her abuse. She feels that this situation is not safe for her being.…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    S., Quiroga S. S., (December 2000), Meeting the Needs of Survivors, Department of Status of Women, City and County of San Francisco. Retrieved August 9, 2014, from http://sfgov.org/dosw/violence-against-women-girls-san-francisco This source is a survey conducted by members of Department of Status of women, city and county of San Francisco regarding why women don’t fight back against domestic abuse. This survey was conducted via telephone interviews with approximately 25% of the female population in the county participating. Results clearly showed that females tolerated the abuse to attempt to maintain a stable relationship, and positive appearance to society.…

    • 1681 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Domestic Violence uses to be something that was hidden. It was swept under the rug and never talked about. What happened in one 's home was their business and it stayed that way, until about the mid 90’s. Now there are many laws, programs and domestic violence advocates to help women get away from their abusive partners and potentially save their lives. Unfortunately, the majority of those women have children according to UNICEF in 2006; 133-275 million children worldwide are witnesses to this violent crime a year.…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both men and women suffer greatly from abuse whether it be verbal, emotional, physical or financial abuse. Intimate partner violence is usually referred to as domestic violence, which is a real world problem since the dawn of time. When abuse is spoken of usually the first gender to come into someone’s mind is a female and not a male, but in all reality anyone can be a victim of abuse. Battered men and/or women are beings who feel that they are in danger or are in a life threatening situation and the only two choices are to kill or be killed, their lives are on the line. Their self-defense instincts kick in and they act on it and sometimes that results in the death of the abuser.…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays