Young 9th grader Philip Malloy was suspended for being patriotic. If you think I am lying, I wish I was. As he was singing the National Anthem, Ms.Narwin therefore had kicked him out of class for creating a ''disturbance". Patriotic or Disturbance? Although Philip was suspended for singing the Anthem, there is no such rule against singing it. Philip was suspended for being patriotic, later we interviewed people to see what side they would be on, Patriotic or Disturbance? "He was just singing it for our country!" Mr. Malloy had said as he was mad for Philip being suspended. The Anthem was written for our freedom and people can sing it if they want to. "He did not create a disturbance, I do not think, he was just humming it." Dr. Doane had said
