Phar Mor Fraud Case Study

Improved Essays
Phar-Mor Inc. was a discount drugstore chain that was founded in 1982 by Michael J. “Mickey” Monus. Within ten years of their first store opening, Phar-Mor had 310 stores, and over 20,000 employees in 34 states. Mickey Monus also owned Tamco warehouse, which was the distributer for Phar-Mor. Mickey Monus also owned 60% of each of the ten teams in the World Basketball Leage (WBL). While everything seemed to be growing, and succeeding rapidly, in reality the company was losing money. Between shortages and overbilling of inventory, moving company funds for personal uses, and the embezzlement of funds from Phar-Mor into WBL, Monus was finally in the spotlight and being investigate. In 1992, Phar-Mor went bankrupt after being accused of embezzlement. Due to this investigation, it also came to light that Phar-Mor’s independent audit company, Coopers & Lybrand LLP, was also involved with the fraudulent …show more content…
In the Phar-Mor case, we can see many instances that would’ve been brought in the open by the SOX titles, and I will investigate them. Ways the SOX could have prevented the Phar-Mor …show more content…
This is due to the fact that SOX regulations require a change in partner every five years (Williams, 2011). SOX would’ve also prevented the hire of Patrick Finn, Stanley Sherelstein, and Jeffrey Walley because of their recent employment at Coopers. This gave them inside knowledge of how the company was going to be audited, even before the audit would begin. While SOX includes codes of ethics in regards to management, we can safely say “the code of ethics for senior officials, would’ve been ignored” ( Williams,

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    RELATED CASES: None SUPPORT DOCUMENTS: Eight Pages Bank Of America Fraud Affidavit/Transaction History. On 12/09/2015, Sandra Agrait contacted the Pasco Sheriff`s Office by telephone to report fraudulent use of her Bank Of America ATM/Debit Card ending in 5457. Ms. Agrait advised she reviewed her bank account transaction history and observed two unauthorized cash withdrawals that she did not make. She said her houseguest, Timothy Midkiss took her debit card out of her wallet, used it to make the cash withdrawals and returned it to her walle without her knowledge or permission.…

    • 206 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Rachel Varley Weston Smith Courtney Bouchez ACC 4313 9/4/15 W. R. Grace vs. SEC W. R. Grace trouble all started in the early 1990’s. W. R. Grace is a catalyst manufacturer, they specialize in petroleum refining and chemical processing catalysts. The relatively successful company had run into some unexpected spike in profits. The executives knew that they could not keep up this growth and eventually the profit would decrease again and investors would be concerned. So instead they decided to take the 30% growth and stash it in a secret fund, they participated in profit management.…

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    As mentioned earlier, as a result of all this fraudulent activity, Rite Aid was ordered to restate their income which was the largest financial restatement in history. They were also ordered to cease-and-desist from any more fraudulent activity. Rite Aid chose to settle and cooperate with the SEC as well as agree to waive its attorney-client privilege so the SEC could locate the information…

    • 65 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Fraud Case Analysis Rita Crundwell started working for the City of Dixon’s finance department as a high school student, but she eventually became the city’s treasurer and comptroller in 1983. Seven years after her appointment, she began a twenty-two-year fraud scheme that enabled her to embezzle approximately $54 billion dollars from the taxpayers she was serving. To embezzle the municipality’s funds unnoticed, Crundwell discretely opened a bank account at the Fifth and Third Bank where city’s bank accounts were housed. She listed the bogus account as the Reserve Sewer Capital Development Account (RSCDA) Reserve Fund. Soon after, Crundwell began transferring funds from various accounts to increase the Capital Development Fund account.…

    • 1029 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Although I have written a Joint Statement that was included in the Presentence Report describing how and why I was involved in the offense, I wanted the Court to know more about me personally and the impact this case has had on my life and my family. First of all, Your Honor, I am truly sorry for what I did. I 'd like to apologize to the banks, the Government and this Court, my family and friends. It seems the only way I have ever learned anything in life has been through trial and error but I never expected to make an error like this.…

    • 1346 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Dage Michael Martinez Fraud Auditing May 1, 2016 Fraud Audit Program: Hollate Assess: Fraud: Type/Scheme Control Opportunity Occurs/Fraud Scenario Concealment Red Flags Conversion Journal Entry Scheme The scheme likely occurred due to management override of controls.…

    • 1732 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    KPMG was in charge to keep the interests of the shareholders well protected. Independently, Halliburton’s external auditors, KPMG should have taken into consideration the audit of the entire company. Any unethical or fraud founded should have been sent to the management. These slight events would have prevented any unethical situation from occurring at the end. However, the external auditors didn’t commit to it, and failed to keep the ethical environment and its corporate governance in Halliburton.…

    • 908 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Within Delta Airlines, the stakeholders are employees, government officials, suppliers, and customers. Delta Airlines’ Directors are responsible monitoring the performances of management, while being loyal to the company’s standards. Under the guidance of the CEO (Chief Executive Officer) are managers, officers, and employees (Corporate Governance, 2012). Delta’s Market Strategy Within the airline industries, the most useful marketing tool has been the frequent flier program.…

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ernst & Young LLP was founded in 1894 and its located in New York, New York with additional offices in the United States, Middle East, Australia, Europe, and Asia. It specializes in providing auditing, assurance, technology and security risk, enterprise risk management, transaction support, merger, and acquisition, actuarial and real estate advisory services as well as many other services. The company the company in the scandal was Weatherford International is one of the biggest multinational oil and natural gas service companies. It provides varies services and products such as for drilling, evaluation, completion, production and intervention of oil and natural gas wells.…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Crazy Eddie Case Analysis

    • 1384 Words
    • 6 Pages

    It is often argued that this practice impairs an accountant/auditor’s independence. For this reason, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 imposed a one year cooling-off period before publicly held companies may hire former auditors as employees of key positions. (Wright & Booker, 2005) The purpose of the cooling off period is to ensure the former auditor can maintain his or her independence. Public companies try to hire their former auditors in hopes of increasing investors’ confidence.…

    • 1384 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The auditors had much blame and liability for the incident, since they accepted some “drinks” and other sorts of bribes by Minkow to not proceed when the “weird” financial information was analyzed by the auditors. The auditor’s main responsibilities were too keep any unethical behavior done by the company away from being speculated. The issues would have been taken cared off before growing into a huge dilemma, but the auditors decided to remain quiet and not analyze the concerns of the financial information that was being falsified by ZZZZ Best. Throughout this case, In the company ZZZZ Best, there were a couple of red flags that existed as a result from the fraud committed and the falsifications by the company. To begin with, the company ZZZZ Best didn’t have the best internal control.…

    • 1404 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Mrs. Wardlaw, I am reaching out to you today to discuss the possibility of fraud within the Apollo Shoes financial statements. After reading through some company documents in preparation of this Audit I have noticed multiple red flags that although in themselves do not constitute fraud outright, they do demand that we investigate this issues further to ensure fraud is not taking place. Through my initial research I believe the possibility of fraud at Apollo Shoes to be very high, and as such we must take precautionary measures to avoid risk falling back on the firm. In my next paragraphs I will outline some of the questionable practices I have noticed from the board of directors meeting minutes, and my analytical review, and why these factors…

    • 1781 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Fund embezzlement, employee assault, intended false advertising, fraud, are just a few in many unethical practices in the market place since a long time ago. This raises a question: Does business ethics really exists? Of course, does exist given that each one of every company is given an ethical conduct of some sort, and all required to submit Social Responsibilities Report at the end of every year. However, business ethics is different, because it is more twisted in the market place. It is usually not taken very seriously and even sometimes changed to fit certain situations, such as it is not “right” for the employee to go around and talk about how his or her CEOs or coworkers are cheating with accounts.…

    • 1291 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Abstract The purpose of this paper is to give an outline the fraudulent activities that take place in the healthcare world. This paper will provide information about the fraud that is ever so popular in today’s healthcare world. Overview/Summary Healthcare today is one of the most profitable businesses in America any many criminals are trying to take advantage of that and make a quick buck.…

    • 1489 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    One of the schemes in finance is called “pump-and-dump” and refers to a stock fraud that involves inflating the price of an owned stock through misleading positive statements, in order to sell the inexpensively purchased stock at the raised price. The Securities and Exchange Commission’s goal is to protect investors and maintain fair, efficient markets. They have exposed multiple cases of pumping and dumping, which has become a fairly common practice in finance. In July 2015, the SEC released information about three men who pumped the price of penny stocks as high as 1800 percent before dumping the shares for almost three million dollars. In November 2015, the commission announced fraud charges against several alleged perpetrators behind a $78 million pump-and-dump scheme involving the stock of Jammin’ Java.…

    • 1923 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays