Peyton Manning Case Study

Improved Essays
The Indianapolis Colts have been put in an extremely tough situation. After winning only a few games in the previous season the Colts now have the 1st overall pick in the 2012 NFL draft coming up at the end of April. As of right now Andrew Luck (senior quarterback at Stanford) looks like he has all of the tools to become the next great NFL quarterback, ironically analysts say that he is similar to Peyton Manning. This is Ironic because currently the leader and starting quarterback of the Indianapolis Colts is Peyton Manning. After over a decade with the Colts and a few injuries, many people feel that the great quarterback's time might be over in Indianapolis. The Colts owner along with the coaches have been considering to start a new era, …show more content…
In 2011 Peyton sat out the whole season with nerve problems in his arm. He went to a doctor only to find out that the pro quarterback was going to need surgery. What appeared to be a quick fix turned into three neck surgeries to try and fix the damaged nerve. One of the surgeries was a single-level neck fusion, which is when two vertebra are fused together limiting the motion between them. This injury creates a few problems the Colts organization needs to consider when making the decision between Peyton Manning and Andrew Luck. Most importantly is the strength in his arm, which has directly been effected from the injury. The main tool of any quarterback would be his arm, and without his arm at full strength Peyton Manning might see his stock drop tremendously. Another problem would be Manning's ability to have full motion rotating his neck. When a patient undergoes a neck fusion they lose some motion in their neck, and being and NFL quarterback neck motion is crucial when scanning the field. The final problem with Peyton Manning's injury is the possibility of re-injury. Although Manning is one of the toughest quarterbacks of all time, with his neck one vicious hit could end his career playing football. The Colts cannot give up the chance to get Andrew Luck and bank on a quarterback whose career could end at any …show more content…
A track star since he was little boy, RG3 (Robert Griffin III) is an unbelievable athlete. Griffin III lead Baylor to its first BCS bowl game in school history this year and won in a shootout. RG3 won a lot this year, including the most prestigious award in all of college football, the Heisman. When career stats are compared between Andrew Luck and Robert Griffin III it is quite close. Griffin III is ahead of Luck in total rushing yards along with rushing touchdowns. When it comes to passing RG3 threw three more touchdown passes than Luck. Andrew Luck however has an overall passer rating 30 points higher than Griffin III and wins in the category of total passing yards. The amazing thing about these stats though is Robert Griffin III played all four seasons at Baylor where as Andrew Luck only played three. If the Colts are going to get rid of Peyton Manning they are going to want someone who can fill his shoes. This means a pure passer, and although Griffin III has great talent Luck has proven to be that pure passer. Andrew Luck is the real deal when it comes to a pro style

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    He has 62 rushes on the season, more than any other player on the team, while also leading the team with 5 touchdown rushes. With a talented front seven of Tennessee, Hurts ability to make plays outside the pocket will be the difference maker on Saturday. 2. Ryan Anderson LB- Through the first six games of his senior campaign, the 6-foot-2 253 pound linebacker has clearly played his best ball since arriving on campus. Anderson has established himself to be one of the most lethal pass-rushers, not only for Alabama but one of the best around the country.…

    • 1301 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When discussing the greatest competitors in NFL history the name that resonates above all is New England’s very own, Tom Brady. Number twelve has been competing for a spot on the field ever since his days at the University of Michigan. For two years Brady worked his way up a dense depth chart. When he was afforded the chance the future superstar took advantage of his opportunity. When talking about earning the starting spot during his Junior season Brady is quoted stating, “Looking back, that was the turning point in my football career” (Rust).…

    • 1299 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Almost 90 percent of all college football scholarship recipients are either middle or lower class. With no other way to afford college and better their self and family many young boys in poverty turn to playing football at the high school level to get recognition from colleges. With the scholarship college football offers to the talented few, they are able to get a full ride which includes dorms and food that their families wouldn’t be able to afford. Also with college football gaining more and more support from Americans annually these 19 and 20 year old players are becoming instant celebrities. Although the NCAA forbids universities from bribing talented high school football players to commit and play for their school, many of the highly rated college football programs are constantly being caught doing it anyways.…

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tom Brady threw for 3,684 yards in just the regular season.Tom Brady completes about 78% of all his passes while Eli Manning completes about 65% of all his passes. Even though the last three times the New England Patriots played the New york Giants and lost to the New York giants individually Tom Brady is the better Quarterback statistically and shows when is comes to super bowl wins. Also Tom Brady will be conducted in the N.F.L. Both Tom Brady and Eli Manning are two great ELITE quarterbacks in the National Football League, but only one can be the best not one person can be the same exact skill wise as the other person. They are both great but Tom Brady is the greatest quarterback of all…

    • 1060 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Biases In Football History

    • 1052 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Coming into his junior year Montee started to have a name for himself and the people of Madison and the whole country knew who he was. He was a balanced back with stability, talent, and vision for the game. Earning his third letter and starting all 14 games he was right where he wanted to be. Montee had made this year special, tying Barry Sanders NCAA season record of 39 touchdowns. This season he was also leading the country in 1,923 rushing yards making that the third best in school history.…

    • 1052 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    TB: I have an incredible ten Super Bowl records, four from my last Super Bowl alone. The four I set or broke in Super Bowl fifty-one are, most passes completed in a single Super Bowl, most pass attempts in a single Super Bowl, most passing yards in a single Super Bowl, and most Super Bowl appearances at seven. Some of my other records are, most wins by a quarterback and most passing touchdowns. I also hold some other unimportant regular season records. SW: Tell us about your relationships, how did they go?…

    • 1927 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The reason I bring Belechik into this argument is that he can literally put anyone in at QB, and they will shine. This has been proven twice. Brady was injured in the first game of the 08’ season and was out for the rest of the year. His replacement, Matt Cassel, jumped right in and fit like glove. The Patriots went with 12 wins and 4 loses that year despite not having their “star” quarterback.…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the years he was playing, he was arguably the best running back in the league. He had won the Rookie of the Year Award, and also named the Most Valuable Player a few times. In all of Barry’s years playing for the Lions, he was selected to play in the Pro Bowl each of his 10 NFL seasons, because Sanders held nearly every Lions’ rushing record and numerous all-time NFL records. With all of his achievements Barry was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame back in 2004. The next player is John Elway.…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Not only guiding the Broncos to the AFC West title, Peyton was also named the AP comeback player of the year. (Biography) That wasn’t the end as the next season was even better. His next season in 2013 Peyton started with an amazing season opener throwing 7 touchdowns tying a league record. Peyton continued to play at such a high level throughout the season winning his 5th MVP. That year Peyton and the Colts made it to the super bowl, but lost to the Seattle Seahawks.…

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    he eventually got signed with the Rams. (Biography.com Editors) In 1999, he got to second string quarterback where he then due to Trent Green tearing his ACL was able to be the first string QB to play. That season he led the Rams to the Superbowl where they had won against the Tennessee Titans. After leading the to the super bowl he continues on his journey of being an NFL player, Staying with the Rams until June 1, 2004. He enjoyed playing for the rams but, unfortunately, he started to decline in the seasons playing poorly, due to an injury to his hand.…

    • 965 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays