Personal Identity Reflection Paper

Decent Essays
Personal identity is it obvious, or is it an obvious problem? How do I know that my teacher is the same person today as she was last class? This question applies to every person you know, your mother, father, friends, teachers, etc. There are three different views we can look at to help us understand how we may grasp the idea of someone’s personal identity. These views consist of the bodily, psychological, and immaterial soul view. We will try to find out if it is possible for a person to survive after the death of their body. By survival, I mean being the same person who remembers their past and anticipates their future experience. We will explore the differences between the three views and some of the features that make one view stand above …show more content…
An immaterial soul cannot be seen or touched, but it can smell and touch (Perry, 315). In this view, once your worldly body has died, your soul moves on to a different place. In this place you will still be the same person you were before, because your soul is the same. This view is highly appealing to people who believe in an afterlife, because they expect that they are the same person once they have died. They expect to see people and friends who have passed away before them. If they were not the same person once they got to this afterlife, how would anyone be able to find them? The idea behind same body, same soul helps ground the immaterial view to future anticipations of experience for people. Same body, same soul is the concept that your soul will stay the same as long as you have the same body. The last view we will look at is the psychological view of personal identity. The psychological view suggests that as long as you have very similar psychological states over time, then you are the same person over time. Your psychological states are not identical, because minute by minute you gain new memories that alter your psychology by fractions of a degree. As long as your personal self remembers who it was prior to each change, then you will still be the same person regardless of the differences between the two separate psychological personal …show more content…
To find the proper method for actual memory we have to make sure that we do not end up in a circular argument. We could say that the formula for actual memory is, seeming to remember plus the person remembering is actually you. The problem with this formula is we would end up in a circular argument, due to the fact that we are originally trying to find out how to define personal identity. No one has been able to figure this out yet, meaning we can’t use the criteria of: the person remembering is

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The four theories of personal identity—body theory, soul theory, memory theory, brain theory— are very well discussed in John Perry's book, A Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality. In an argument between Gretchen Weirob, Sam Miller, and Dave Cohen, all these theories are put into question in a discussion about the possibility of life after death. Overall, throughout the book , in these discussions it seems as if the body theory wins the argument for having more pros and fewer cons than the memory, brain and soul theories. However, this theory is contradicted and deemed not possible because when the body dies the person identity no longer exists.…

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Perry, through the character Weirob, claims that “it seems clear as anything in philosophy that from A is B and C is B where by ‘is’ we mean identity, we can infer, A is C” (A Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality, page 32). Thus, if we were to duplicate Person B twice, resulting in Persons A and C, both Persons A and C would be Person B. Thus, both Persons A and C would have the same memories as Person B, which would mean they both have the same identity. However, personal identity is supposed to be unique.…

    • 1193 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In John Perry’s “A Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality,” there are many arguments that discuss the criterion of personal identity. Within The First Night, Gretchen Weirob and Sam Miller begin to discuss the idea of an immaterial soul and its reasonability of existence, which is the main idea. Miller discusses the various reasons why an immaterial soul exists while Weirob argues its existence and eventually, its relevance. Throughout the dialogue, Miller introduces various theories to support the idea of an immaterial soul and its use of allowing the survival of a person after death. His main theory represents the principle of “Same body, same self” (Perry, 325) otherwise discussed as “same body, same soul.”…

    • 960 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Everyone has their own, unique identity, but in society people try to conform and fit in. They even at times change their selves while doing this. As explained in the book, Personal identity, by Harold W. Noonan “Everything is identical to itself. Nothing is identical to anything else” (85-99).…

    • 1854 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is unique according to experience, the disassociation or stronger connection of mind-body, the ability to cope, and the support available from others. The traditional accounts do make sense in a clean way, not burdened by the social factor. What these accounts failed to recognize was the real world, and how our perceptions of situations and other people can change our thoughts so rapidly. Bodily and emotional trauma can cause change so fast that identity is lost in persistence of memory and emotion, but can also be healed or recovered in some way from the empathy of those around…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Personal Identity Concept

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages

    However, other theories come into play and reject the psychological approach to explaining personal identity and it’s persistence over time; claims that continuity of the brain and memory are not enough to explain and confirm personal identity are made. These theories include the biological approach, the dualist theory, and the materialist theory. Through the review of these theories respectively, a clearer understanding of personal identity can be developed and argued for. Following this, we can begin to see how cases of multiples personalities or identities can be argued to exist as…

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Race And Gender Analysis

    • 1347 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Race and gender are usually questioned whether they exist, exist as natural kind, or exist as products of the society. In this paper, I will talk about Nagel and Wilkes’ ideas on personhood, and how they are related to natural kinds. Then, I will present and compare between Haslanger and Sveinsdottir’s accounts on gender and between Mills and Spencer’s account on race. Finally, I will explain why race and gender can’t cease to exist.…

    • 1347 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As you come into this world, your identity is a blank canvas, yet to be painted to your own unique image. Yet, as we slowly grow, learning how to speak and how to walk, we are so quickly attributed with certain characteristics and traits. From the moment of birth, people are compared to each other. Who do we look like the most - our mother our father? We are identified in the most simplistic of attributes and are quickly associated with that of the people around us, our relatives.…

    • 1009 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Identity and its flexibility Everyday our minds change and develop. One will go through a series of life altering events, and not only will these events be life changing, but they will be identity changing as well. Ones identity is flexible and changes constantly. Change can be slight or change can be major, but identity is never fixed.…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    With memories comes emotions, reactions, and unfiltered thoughts in any given situation that shows the person’s identity. This may give us glimpse at their personality but their memories are also determined by their identities. This is the problem of…

    • 1890 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This clearly cannot be true, as it is not logical to disagree saying they are not the same person. This then could lead us to think of personal identity being down the physical continuity of a person, where they remain in the same body and that is what is important for personal identity. It seems absurd for Locke to claim that they are not the same people. Lockean theorists refuted the argument by saying that this example can prove that psychological continuity is what is important, as although the Old General does not remember flogging, the Solider does remember it, so there is still a continuous line of memories. It is not essential that all memories are remembered for the duration of a person’s life, according to Locke, it’s whether the memories overlap and could be remembered at different stages of the person’s life that is important for personal…

    • 1500 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Just because someone shares the same mental connectivity, the proceeding individual does not constitute immediately that the preceding individual has preserved personal identity. Memories could be perceived in a different view. If P2 received memory of P1, two different outcomes may…

    • 1074 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This view might seem to go against our natural beliefs that there is some matter of fact that makes a person the same person, and not just to an extent or gray area. But, this is exactly the problem Parfit thinks we have with identity, which we must change our views on. If we were to follow these natural beliefs then even ordinary survival would be detrimental to our identity because as previous shown, it is hard to determine why or what makes a person the same. We are physically changing from moment to moment and in a sense dying at every moment. We can only conclude that we are mostly the same due to our psychological continuity.…

    • 1315 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    J.C.C. Smart, a founder of Identity Theory, lays out his philosophy in The Topic Neutral Approach. Identity Theory suggests that the mind is created solely by mind states— its singular suggestion being sensations are brain processes. (Smart, 169) (Smart, 170) However, Identity Theorists believe behavior is caused by theoretically understandable mechanical processes. Smart claims this theory should be taken seriously since it parallels physics and therefore seems plausible.…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What is going to occur once we die? Some people, have never considered what will happen, yet some have wondered about the after life since ancient times (Mufti, 2015). For many, death is a fearsome event, as they do not know what to expect (Wilkins, 2011). Nevertheless, others are concerned about what will occur once they die, due to their beliefs. Good morning/afternoon teachers and students.…

    • 1231 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays