Analysis: The Immigrants Turned Away

Good Essays
Election day is approaching and regardless of the outcome, it will definitely become a historic event. Timothy Egan (2016) shares his opinion towards Donald Trump in his Op-Ed article, “The Immigrants Turned Away.” He is certainly not a Trump supporter and uses the time remaining, before Election Day, to warn U.S citizens about Trump’s plans concerning immigration. Pathos is applied the most throughout Egan’s argument because he prefers to connect with his audience on a personal level. Ethos and logos appear in the argument to provide evidence and strengthen his writing. The primary purpose of why Egan (2016) decides to share his opinion is to address Trump’s immigration plan and how it is a reflection of his ignorance. Egan (2016) perceives …show more content…
Although the answer is very obvious, Trump still fails to understand the objectives of immigrants. “He would have shut off the flow of people whose best and perhaps only asset at the time was desire for a better life”(Egan, 2016, para. 3). Egan (2016) presents and depends on emotional appeal to make his argument towards Donald Trump powerful. Egan (2016) does not sugar coat his purpose, in fact, he ends his op-ed by stating the obvious hoping it can change Donald’s Trump perception of immigrants. “What forces someone to leave a home, family - everything- is desperation. And then, more often than not, having seen the worst that life can offer, those families becomes the best”(Egan, 2016, para. 14). Egan (2016) firmly believes that should be no resentment towards a person who wants to prosper in life. If their own country cannot supply them with the proper care, job, education, why is it a crime to seek more? These are the people who should be filling up college campuses and job interviews! Immigrants do not settle for less and are so quick to give up the little that they have, and take a risk. Egan (2016) does not want his audience to give sorrow or pity towards immigrants. Understanding and consideration is expected from citizens when their time of voting …show more content…
Egan (2016) supported his opinion with evidence that makes his argument worth listening and or reading to. His argument is more credible than someone who just despises Donald Trump for personal reasons. Egan (2016) still manages to convey his audience by breaking down Donald Trump’s plan. He ridicules Trump’s plan and reminds citizens how absurd it sounds to him. Logic is present but pathos takes over Egan’s (2016) op-ed, aiming for a personal connection between him and each citizen. This op-ed emphasizes Donald Trump’s ignorance and why it is considered ignorance in the first

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    7. Donald Trump has promised since day one of his bid to become president, that he would build a wall between the Mexican/American borders, and stop the flow of illegal immigrants once and for all. From a philosophical principle Trump is applying the teachings of Stuart Mills idea of the greater good, or utility, but also using the “Veil of Ignorance” among his supporters to get what he wants. Using Mills idea to of a greater good, Donald Trump is skewing it as a utility for the greater good of the United States. Trumps campaign slogan during the 2016 presidential election was “Make America Great Again”, one the aspects Trump attacked that made America not great.…

    • 985 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    They move people”. Luntz has the courage to state that the way Obama uses his language could be an example of “political plagiarism” however Trump does not do this at all. The one thing that Trump has done throughout all of his speeches is been truthful and as precise as he can be. Trump decided to tell the audience “For those here today illegally who are seeking legal status, they will have one route and only one route: to return home and apply for re-entry under the rules of the new legal immigration system that I have outlined above”. While Trump has hope that he can make America great again, he also has expectations that gives the audience who supports Trump a sense of trust.…

    • 1093 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Analysis Of Melting Pot

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages

    What if Andrew Carnegie never emigrated to the United States when he did? Mostly likely The United States would not have evolved to the great nation it is today. As 2017 is around the corner, the topic of immigration is controversial and popular matter. As president-elect Trump has promised during his campaign that he will deport all illegal immigrants…

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Pence was not happy with his comment and continued discussing his answer to the question that was originally asked. Kaine went on to reference a point in the first presidential debate where Donald Trump referred to himself as “smart” for not paying his taxes. I believe Tim Kaine’s further comments about how the unpaid taxes effects out country, was an incredibly important mention. The taxer payer money is money that supports our military, our veterans, and many other aspects of our nation. As far as I am concerned, not paying his taxes is in no way justifiable.…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    He uses the majority of the country’s disapproval of President Trump to gain viewers and get his point across. He makes sure that it is known that Trump is the one that appointed Ajit Pai to head of the FCC, and combined with that fact that Trump doesn’t even know what net neutrality actually is, he hopes his viewers will realize how essential it is to take action against Pai, Trump, the FCC, and ISPs. He shows how Verizon even recently aired a commercial where they defend themselves against these accusations and say they will not take away net neutrality as there is no evidence of this happening yet. Oliver makes it a priority to point out that the ISPs have not done anything to net neutrality yet because they are not able to without the bill being passed so they most likely will get rid of it as they have done similar things before. This is where the example of Google Wallet vs ISIS comes in.…

    • 1139 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Donald Trump Is Wrong

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Author Yoav Fromer argues that Donald Trump displays the "bullying, imperiousness and ignorance" that the American public feels secretly and that this mind set is what helped develop the country into what it is today. Aside from the hasty generalization that all Americans possess some level of prejudice, Fromer 's argument fails to acknowledge that behaving like we have in the past will not propel us into the future. It will chain us to a cycle and inhibit further development in the U.S. Learn from your mistakes. It 's the reason that while we were growing up our parents instilled in our minds that making mistakes was valuable.…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Donald Trump wants protection for our country just as the people of the U.S., and those on the opposing side. In conclusion, Donald Trump should not be elected president. His racial inequality, lack of respect, and ideas are going to cause the U.S. many problems. Both sides just want a good economy and protection. Trump wants to create a wall on the border to protect the U.S. from future terrorist attacks.…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Even though he was doing the best he could in his position to help ease tension, which was seemingly insincere and temporary, he only made this speech in order to "appease" the angered Americans, the people that were criticizing him. When President Trump finally comes forth and gives this speech, he creates a criticism sandwich, beginning with something good, then saying something that was heartbreaking and needed more attention than it received, then he concluded with positives on what he would be doing to make things better. “I am in Washington today… Justice will be delivered.” (Quartz Media, Donald…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Because undocumented immigrants are willing to be paid less, Americans struggle to compete for the jobs. We have Americans out of work, but foreigners having more jobs than American citizen does not make sense. According to Donald Trump’s website, he wants to “put the needs of working people first” (“Immigration Reform”). This idea leads to Trump’s big plan of building a wall which is needed to prevent illegal immigration. Even though many may think building a wall is rude, I personally think it is just a clever way to prevent undocumented immigrants from entering; however, I do not agree with Trump’s plan to make Mexico pay for the wall.…

    • 923 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Its in fact hypocritical, in an article on the New York Times website “Donald Trump vs. American Democracy” reads “...He needs a reason so that his self-inflated self-image as a relentless winner is not undone should he lose this election by embarrassing margins. But to take that need for a diversion and distraction and turn it toward questioning the integrity of the electoral process itself and leaving open the possibility of not conceding should he lose beyond the pale.” And after the election what did Democrats protest... the electoral college saying that they wanted it dead and buried. And that since Hillary acquired the popular vote she should be President-Elect. Only due to the fact that they didn 't get the result that they wanted. This Democrat obviously rued the day he declared and gave voice to these words after the results of the election came out or maybe he proceeded to be an unreasonable person and kept making America unpleasant, either way this is an example of how even though we all know where we should be and are striving to be joint as a Nation, we…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays