Unfavorable Sub-Contract Case Study

Better Essays
Over the years the construction industry has developed a reputation for shady deals and untrustworthiness. Contractors specifically are the root cause of the mistrust between the industry and the public. When it comes to the relationships between contractors and subcontractors though there is still a mistrust even though both sides share the same unfavorable reputation. Often times contractors bully subcontractors into signing contracts that put them in terribly unfavorable positions. And after that subcontractors bully sub-subcontractors into signing equally unfavorable sub-contracts. However, not all contracts are terrible, what causes them to be so one sided are specific clauses that are inserted in an attempt to transfer responsibilities …show more content…
City of Carlsbad. Originally the city hired P&D to consult on engineering the redesign of a golf course at a price of $556,745. Their contract expressly stated that all changes and modifications needed to be in writing in order to be allowed. However, this protocol was not followed for amendments Nos. 1 through 4 which increased the contract price by $63,525.50. P&D was authorized by the city to begin extra work before the written change orders were completed. Amendment No. 5 was requested by the city to confirm the final scope and price of the remaining work, as instructed P&D submitted amendment No.5 which totaled $209,956. The city project manager came back saying that price needed to be engineered below $100,000. After negotiations, amendment No. 5 was signed at $99,810, as was customary on this job though the extra work began before the amendment was executed. Once the work was completed P&D tried to recover compensation for the extra work that didn 't fall under amendment No.5. The city refused so P&D sued them for the $109,093 that was chopped off of the original amendment No.5. They jury, as any layperson would, accepted P&Ds version of the story and awarded them the $109,093 that was requested. After all, P&D did the work asked of them so ethically they should be entitled to the added value of their efforts. Following this ruling, the city appealed this decision and won. P&D lost their award because as stated by the court …show more content…
By nature, a contracts are not erroneous and it does not mean that those signing or proposing said contract are inherently fallacious. As we 've discussed throughout this paper, the ethical-ness of a contract boils down to the people and the extent that each clause is enforced. There could exist a contract that favored the contractor far more than it did the subcontractor or owner and that project could go absolutely perfect and there could be no issues through the entire course of the project. People by nature want to be congenial and help each other and it is understood that we must first protect ourselves. But when we shift responsibility and blame from one party to another and put another party at a great disadvantage right from the start, we create an atmosphere of mistrust and hostility which leads to disastrous results. The contractors that treat subcontractors with respect and appreciation are usually the ones that end up with the best results and the ones that have the best reputations. To conclude, if we as the next generation of construction managers, contractors, and subcontractors continue the same detrimental practices as our predecessors, our industry will keep the untrustworthy reputation that has existed for decades. The companies that handle their business ethically are growing and expanding tremendously so let that be something that we as a generation can

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Ackman Case Study Summary

    • 960 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Within three years, Target claimed back 90.7 million shares with a total cost of $4.6 billion. In addition, they announced to continue repurchasing such stocks totaling $10 billion. After acquiring $4.84 billion of the stocks under their new plan, Target’s management announced the decision to suspend temporarily any further stocks due to their current business condition. This decision ultimately was made to decrease the amount of cash outflow. Shareholders such as Ackman thought that Target should continue such program- ultimately utilizing their cash for investing.…

    • 960 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Data suggest that the HRPs and line managers are siding together, which is very unfair on the target as the claims are about the managers and becomes very biased and one sided. Also, the HRPs allows the bullying claims to be a managerial ‘error’ which means the HRPs say they have acted towards the situation by not labelling it a strong word of…

    • 1650 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This may be because of the large amount of rivalry between the directors from claiming distinctiveisions. The mankind 's assets aptitudes need aid in the early stage, which makes it challenging should accomplish. Those conclusions of the ob want. There will be absence of seeing of the passionate Furthermore behavioural necessities of the workers. This prompts miserable employees, which thus declines their profit.…

    • 1206 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    81-82). Due to the division of labor, when there are lapses in ethics, the blame is passed around to the other contributors on that project or activity. This excuse is one that is harder to negate due to most people believing that the fault is not their own, and harder to correct due to the communal nature allowing people to feel as though they are not the problem. The third excuse in McDowell’s article, is known as the fault of machines, in which a maintenance problem occurred with a piece of machinery causing failure. and therefore a lapse in either productivity or care (McDowell, pg 83).…

    • 1199 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Holding Jim Snelling responsible for his unethical behavior. That would clear the bad reputation of the company at large and concentrate the blame on one person hence wining the client and competitor’s favor Contracts and Procurements Code of Ethics The code deals with all the contract processes that an organization does. Jim’s case involves violation of this ethical principle by using the competitor’s price list to bid. Also, Jim does not include a fair procurement contract amount. He does not account for all the charges that would be incurred to fulfil the contract.…

    • 1140 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Employees with proper moral standards are struggling to fight against other’s who may have many unethical behavior traits. To make it worse, many unethical conducts go unpunished because of legal insignificance, even though it is up to the employer to reprimand such behavior (Sigma, 2011). In some cases, it is unfortunately the entire business that performs unethically actions rather than a single person or group. Businesses who partake in unethical business practices harm more then a reputation is what we are saying; however, why do some still practice this way? To gain a completive advantage of course!…

    • 1481 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This type of contract leaves one party no real, meaningful choice, usually do to major differences in bargaining power between the parties. A contract is made unconscionable due to, undue influence, duress, unequal bargaining power, unfair surprise, or limiting warranty. Undue Influence is when one party experiences an unduly amount of pressure to enter into a contract with another party (Cheeseman H. R., 2012, pp. 228-229). Usually one party exploits the other.…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Our previous proposal was $384,000 for demo of all buildings, paving, and soils work. Randazzo was CSDC’s previous low bidder and is also the County’s low bidder. The County may want to move forward and tear down the building and have CSDC purchase the land. E.D. Flores will schedule a follow up meeting with the County to determine how we will move forward.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The stakeholder who was affected most was obviously the customer. When they would find out that he wasn’t truthful with them they would call up customer service and complain but by this time it usually was too late and they were screwed. The company is a major stakeholder as well. Deception is a really bad business technique and it brings nothing but a bad name to the business that my boss represented. There were customers who would never even consider our services because of the abundance of dishonesty within the company.…

    • 1089 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Actually, the workers raise doubt on its efficacy and correctness. These are said to be highly terrible and result in low employee morale. In this way, it is very well comprehended that the workers are not going through the best possible experiences and it impacts significantly on their competencies and caliber levels. The actual workplace organizational issues drawn from own experience are unfit workplace settings, dissatisfied workers, and improper use of Scanlon plan. By implementation of the Scanlon plan, the company was very hopeful.…

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays