The Power Of Man The Suffering Of Animals Analysis

Improved Essays
Overuse of antibiotics in animals is nothing short of abuse and ignores the call to treat animals humanely. Antibiotics are forced onto animals merely as a growth factor; they fatten up the animals and speed up the period of time for growth to put more money in the pocket of the business (Reardon, “US”). While the FDA has called for a voluntary end to this practice, the cruelty does not end there. According to Matthew Scully, the author of Dominion: The Power of Man, the Suffering of Animals, and the Call to Mercy, a novel critically evaluating the humane treatment of animals in a free market, some animals in farm factories will spend their whole lives “kept alive…only by antibiotics, hormones, laxatives, and other additives” to their food …show more content…
Joel Salatin, the owner of Polyface Farm and a third generation organic farmer, runs his farm without medicating his animals, showing that animals can live healthy lives without the use of antibiotics (Salatin, 180). Salatin explains that his animals are healthier than the factory animals because they can enjoy the symbiotic relationship that animals are supposed to have with nature (Kenner, “Food”). Salatin maintains a small farm, but the decision not to medicate animals can be transferred to large businesses. Denmark is the top exporter of pork in the world, and remains so even though it has completely banned nontherapeutic antimicrobials from animal husbandry (Hungate, et al., “Ominous”). According to Martin, because of Denmark’s strict restraints on antibiotics, the levels of resistant bacteria have dropped in the livestock and humans in under two years (Martin, “Antibiotics”). Neither Salatin nor the Danish pork production have been met with negative consequences to their businesses because of the policy they have implemented (Kenner, “Food”; Martin, “Antibiotics”). If big businesses would follow these models, a decrease in antibiotics resistance could be seen …show more content…
No laws exist that ban the use of medically important antibiotics on animals and monitor antibiotic use is a serious issue that is uprooting our food system. The industry cannot continue with the heavy dependence on medically important antibiotics to keep the animals alive in cruel conditions and to force them to grow faster; passing stringent laws is the only step we can take in order to fix the damage being inflicted on these animals. Self-policing will not work. There must be concrete right and wrongs of antibiotics use in animal husbandry. It is critical to monitor the use of antibiotics because the health of the future depends on having the ability to use antibiotics. Bacteria and infections will never go away, and there must be ways to treat them, or else there will be no need for the food industry to be this large; there will be no one to feed. We must go to war against the abuse of antibiotics, and it is turning into a war of resistance, with the government reluctant to change and bacteria following the natural call to evolve under the conditions of antibiotics they’re exposed to. The government must adapt quicker than the bacteria and make the hard calls of passing laws labeled ‘mandatory’ to cease the spread of antibiotics

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has updated its regulations on how antibiotics can and will be given to food-producing animals. The main way that these drugs will be given is by veterinarians for specific animal health issues and is outlined by The Veterinary Feed Directive. Allied Cooperative, Wisconsin’s leading co-op, offers extensive services and supplies including agronomy, grain, auto parts, hardware, convenience stores, and more, and they want you to understand The Veterinary Feed Directive. The Veterinary Feed Directive requires veterinarians to issue all feed directive drugs within the context of the state’s veterinarian-client-patient-relationship (VCPR).…

    • 302 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Therapeutic usage of many antibiotics, including penicillin,was conducted on animals. In medicine we owe much to these creatures. In the future, animals will be needed to test newer and more advanced viruses that have the potential to cause deadly diseases. I believe that in order to keep saving thousands of lives each year, we need to continue with animal testing. I do not necessarily agree with animal cruelty, but I do believe that animals are needed in order to keep creating ground breaking treatments.…

    • 1376 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Farming Up Trouble” “Farming Up Trouble”, by Beth Mole is an article that tells people that antibiotics are being used more in the animals that are on the farm than in humans. The article talks about how this could be the where the antibiotic-resistance bacteria comes from. These antibiotic-resistance bacteria are spreading swiftly across farms, and the scientists are scared that this bacteria is traveling out of farms by the farmer’s meat products as said in the article, “Scientists and health experts fear that it is, and the drug-resistance bacteria from farms are escaping via farmworks or meats.”. But in the article, it gives us different view from others such as the agricultural industry had said that the scientists fear is over the top,…

    • 412 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One key fact is that over 80% of all of the antibiotics produced are put directly into the animals themselves, our food supply. So each time we eat animals, we are constantly being exposed to antibiotics (possibly leading to drug-resistant diseases). The author points out that these drugs are given to make up for the extremely poor living conditions the animals are exposed to, “like living on top of one another 's waste.” She goes on to point out that most of the antibiotics “were specifically administered to artificially increase rapid growth.” This article was helpful in putting into perspective that although the intention of the antibiotics seems positive, the end result is much worse than the intention, and we are also paying the cost.…

    • 1339 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many of these animals being held in captivity are overly dependent on antibiotics and other drugs which is not an ideal situation (Berry 3). Crops are also dependent on toxic chemicals such as pesticide which many consumers may not be aware of. Berry states the fact that food companies have and are attempting to keep consumers from discovering too much about the issues of the quality and health of their food (3). The only true way to better the treatment of animals to be killed for meat and prevent the spraying of toxic chemicals onto crops is for the public to develop an awareness of what is truly happening in the food…

    • 1360 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Many foods now either have some sort of hormone or antibiotic in them to promote growth or stop growth. These drugs have help fight of infection or help with deficiencies and that's a great thing but what the food industry force feeding livestock that’s a bad thing. With to many antibiotics and hormones being fed to livestock it bound to stay in the meat and cause very harmful effects on consumers and producers everywhere. Also all of the sugars and other thing that we consume.…

    • 674 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Farms that are not properly maintained can develop salmonella and E. Coli which is passed onto humans through meat, dairy, and eggs. To fight off the bacteria, animals are fed or injected with large amounts of antibiotics. Industrial farms have been adding antibiotics to livestock since 1946. Shortly after, studies began to show that antibiotics were making animals grow faster and gain weight more efficiently. All of which were qualities that were increasing meat producer’s profits.…

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cheap Food

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the article Walsh tells us about the antibiotics that are given to the animals, and us as the consumers of those same animals we are also consuming those antibiotics. Once you consume a certain amount of antibiotic you eventually become immune to it, so how healthy could that be for us? We all know how expensive it can get going to the doctors. Maybe it's more important to spend a few more dollars trying to eat healthy food and become more aware of what we are consuming, than settling for the unaware and dealing with health complications later…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    704301623 Congressional Hearing: Controversy on the use of Antibiotics in Livestock and Agriculture The use of antibiotics in Livestock and Agriculture has been widespread ever since the discovery of its positive effects on animal growth. It was around the 1950’s when discoveries were being made on how greatly it increased the growth rate and size of livestock, which overall lead to many benefits for the farmers that utilized antibiotics (Ratcliff 1951, 282). These antibiotics were first discovered through the utilization of waste from antibiotic creation through vat fermentation. These benefits as a whole led to an overall increase in the availability and accessibility of meat.…

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    By collaborating our work from various resources, we established that antibiotics have harmful side effects on the environment. When animals are administered antibiotics, it kills off other bacteria and allows antibiotic resistant bacteria to survive and multiply. This causes contamination of animal waste, which then comes into contact with water, soil, or air (Food, Farm, Animals, and Drugs 2014). Horizontal gene transfer is also a big concern for the environment. In recent years, there has been an increase in antibiotic resistant bacteria found.…

    • 1092 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Cattle Industry Analysis

    • 1641 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In the last two centuries the beef industry has undergone many changes. From the coming of refrigerated train cars to Government regulations. As the population of the earth has grown, cattlemen have had to change their operations in order to feed the world. But as we try to feed more cattle in a smaller area, sickness spreads like wildfire if not treated with antibiotics. Cattle were first brought to the America’s in 1493 on Columbus’s second voyage.…

    • 1641 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Antibiotics in livestock are a crucial part of the farming industry in many ways. The impact of antibiotics on the economy is crucial because “keeping animals healthy allows farmers to produce food more effectively which has the added benefit of making food more affordable” to the common citizen (Dorman N. Pag). With a massive amount of people eating meat every day in the United States, it is a…

    • 1506 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article “The Moral Status of Animals” examines how humans perceive themselves as having moral status, while at the same time they also justify that non-humans obtain no moral status. Lori Gruen who is the author of this article states that these people often suggest that animals cannot be harmed in a moral sense like humans. But membership to a specific species does not justify the moral claim made by those who belong to the Homo sapiens species. Species membership does not explain why animals are considered to have no moral status. There are distinguishable characteristics that come along with Homo sapiens, but they do not condone morality.…

    • 2501 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    From day one, January 1st 1928 when the first fully automatic photographic film developing machine was patented, it was clear this year would be significant to history. Day by day, events were occurring that would improve the overall lives of the average American. RCA and GE installed test television sets in homes, NBC set up a permanent coast-to-coast radio network, and what no America realized would forever impact human and animal health, Alexander Fleming discovered the first antibiotic. Flash forward to ninety years later- nearly every home has not one, but multiple television sets, there are hundreds of coast-to-coast radio networks as well as digital networks, and on average 4 out of every 5 Americans will be prescribed some for of antibiotic…

    • 1280 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Eventually all the animals will pick up on the treatment of antibiotics given to them before being slaughtered, that will result in depression from many of the other animals. No animals want to have to go through that process. The…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays