Orientalism By Vera Tolz Analysis

Improved Essays
The notion and study of orientalism in the West reached a different understanding from an iconic book called „Orientalism“, written by Edward Said. Nevertheless, contemporary discussions have highlighted various types of orientalism in the Western world, their perception of the „East“ , frailty of epistemological distinction made between "the Orient" and "the Occident“ and have moved way further than Said's description of the phenomenon.
The author, Vera Tolz, wrote this book as a study of Russian Orientology in the late imperial and early Soviet eras. The book is consists from an introduction, six chapters, conclusion, bibliography and index. Each part has a direction, clearly stated aims and a conclusive paragraph that lets the reader have a better digestion of the main terms and the context, without
…show more content…
Tolz begins with introduction of the historical background and main figures involved in the study, and each following chapter covers a certain issue, giving the reader a chance to analyse the nature of Russian orientology from many different angles. For example, In first Chapter she is concerned with notions of empire and nation, Russian nation-building tendencies and regional integration. In the second chapter, Tolz discusses the perception of orientologists considering such concepts as „East“, „West“, „Europe“ and „Asia“ and argues that Rozen school did not only challenge the superiority of the west, but also succesfully promoted their critical approach among Russia‘s cultural and intellectual elites. Chapter 3 analyses the inter-relationship among political trends and academic scholarship. Chapter 4 surveys the critique of European scholarship, chapter 5 talks about input of russian orientologists to the admission of minority nationalisms as well as policy making related to non-russian ethnic

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Peter The Great Decrees

    • 651 Words
    • 3 Pages

    3. Peter the Great wanted “to transform his country through a process of state imposed Westernization.” He was convinced that Russia could overcome its backwardness only by adopting “the institutions, customs and attitudes of the technologically superior, wealthier and more powerful states of Western Europe.” Many were opposed to his decrees and edicts because they would “mean discarding much of Russia’s distinctive past.” Those “devoted to Russia’s unique Slavic and Orthodox Christian traditions” …” argued that abandonment of Russia’s past was too high a price to pay for Europeanization.”…

    • 651 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    James R Gibson Analysis

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Throughout the article, he clearly identified with two main points that Russia was “lack of opportunity and lack of necessity”2 to be a sea power. Gibson provides new insights on many aspects of the absence. He approaches his piece along with questions which leads readers not only in reading but also thinking. Providing a basic background of Russia, which helps general…

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “Russia in the Mongol Empire in Comparative Perspective,” Charles J. Halperin makes the argument that past scholarship on the Mongols has been distorted by a Europocentric premise. This premise holds that the influence of the Mongols on Russia as minimal and negligent, or at the very least had a negative impact on Russia. In his article, Halperin disputes this, calling instead for a comparison of Mongol rule in Russia, China, and in Iran. By examining and comparing these three areas in terms of the influence of the Mongols, Halperin claims that the impact of the Mongols on Russia was greater than it had been in both China and Iran.…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The continuous struggle of powerful Russian interests attempting to impose control on the restive North Caucasia region, define the Russian-Chechen relationship and associated policies. Since the beginning of the 10th century, Russian influence has been resisted by the indigenous Chechen people. The persistent militancy in Chechen opposition leaves little room for doubt in the general wishes for independence and autonomy. Despite this, Russian governments ranging from the Tsarist rulers of the past, to the nominally democratic government of today resolutely call for Chechnya to be Russian territory. Consistency in the policy of Russian hegemony from these varying governmental structures shows the importance and reasoning in pouring vast amounts…

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Family Romanov Murder. Rebellion, & The Fall Of Imperial Russia Author: Candace Fleming. Publisher: Schwartz & Wade Topic: This book is about more than the last rulers of Russia, it is much more than that, a book of different views of peasants and their conflicts on their every day life.…

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The history of Russia has gone through numerous drastic phases, with the transition from an autocracy to communism, and a communist regime to a relatively democratic state, just to name a few. The tragedy that befell the last ruling Romanov family has long been blamed on the Bolsheviks, with just cause, but the demise of the Romanovs began many years prior to the Bolshevik emergence. Historical writings have shown us that interpretations and biases can overtake the writing. It causes monumental differences in how events were perceived. Over the course of the last century, much research has gone into the final years of the ruling family reign and the contributing factors to their assassination, some of which was not available for decades.…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    POG 100 - PROPOSAL This proposal will rebuttal against the resolved issue of Week 6: “State break up is better than federalism in resolving internal state conflict.” Neither the concepts of economic dispute nor social injustice can fully explain the cause of state breakups. This essay argues the reasons why state breakup is not better than federalism to resolve state conflict because it leaves a majority of negative impacts, such as, corruption of state, revocation of citizenship rights and leads to economic decline.…

    • 1014 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In other words, the image of Hitler was seen by the people of Germany as a unifying factor designed to pursue German nationalism and the reestablishment of Germany as a leading German power following the devastation that visited Germany in the aftermaths of World War I. Thus, Gurian in 1945 utilized an approach to history that was parallel to that of Kershaw who was writing in 1987. Although these two historians were separated by over 42 years, they both realized that nationalism was a vehicle that had tremendous history changing affects. This is precisely why their methods of historical analysis are comparable. The theme of nationalism as a medium for change was also evident in the Soviet Union in the aftermath of the 1917 Bolshevik Revolution.…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “The revolution happened because I didn’t kill him in time to stop it” Felix Yusupov How far did the political and personal influence exerted by Rasputin lead to the downfall of Tsarist Russia?  General information on this topic Nicholas II of Russia was the last emperor of Russia (1st November 1894 to 15th March 1917). His reign saw the dramatic fall of the imperial Russian empire. After the Febuary revolution of 1917 Nicholas was forced to abdicate the throne. In 1918, Nicholas and his family were tragically executed by the Bolsheviks.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Allied Intervention

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages

    There has been many times throughout history the United States government has decided to intervene in foreign matters. From the Spanish-American War, the Bay of Pigs, Vietnam, and the War on Terror among others, the United States has played some sort of role in foreign affairs, making their mark upon the world and history. Many people are not educated upon the Allied intervention in the Russian Revolution and the Civil War that was commencing in the years after World War One. Very few people know about the Polar Bear Expedition, the American force from Michigan that fought against Bolshevik forces in Northern Russia during this Civil War. This intervention and event played a significant role in American Politics for years to come.…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sergei Podbolotov is an instructor of Russian and European history, teaching primarily on the courses of Russian civilization. He is the author of multiple scholarly articles, covering subject matter from national problems in the Russian Empire to Russian nationalism and conservatism. In addition to this, he is a recipient of IREX awards for research. In his work, Monarchists Against Their Monarch: The Rightists Criticism of Tsar Nicholas II, he addresses the criticism of Tsar Nicholas II from the point of view belonging to the monarchists. Though there was a positive side to the monarchist movement, there was a very negative side to it as well, and they believed that the Tsar himself caused the crisis of the autocracy.…

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During 1683-1908, both the Ottoman and Russian empires dealt with internal and external challenges that affected their methods of ruling their empires. Three similarities they both encountered was they both faced Westernization and constitutional challenges directly, they both had many members of the rising education urban middle school class deserted constitutional nationalism and lastly, they were both able to attain the Western industrial challenge. While experiencing these internal and external challenges, they also faced many differences including how the Ottoman Empire was able to develop a pattern of responses to the Western challenge, how the Russian Empire was more focused on reforms regarding politics and the Nicholas I implemented…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The late 19th century gave rise to the “Positivist Age”, a period experienced in both Europe and America in which scientific progress and rational thought was beginning to be widely accepted and trusted. This transformation in political and religious ideals was paralleled in the arts through the rejection of Romanticism because it did not show accuracy of the real, observable world. Konstantin Makovsky’s painting The Russian Bride’s Attire, is a decorative piece that depicts the revival of Russian folklore, but when inspected closely, displays a mixture of styles, expressive lighting, and postures that present a muted criticism of past Russian traditions. A student at the Russian Imperial Academy of Arts, Konstantin Makovsky was one of fourteen…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If one were to have asked a Russian peasant what revolution means to them, they might answer samovol’shchina, or, translated “doing what you want.” In Sheila Fitzpatrick’s book The Russian Revolution she traces three broad themes through the course of the revolution that existed before 1917 and would continue until about the time of 1934. She examines the class struggle that was an important part of the revolution as well as the leadership that lead the Russian citizens through these tumuloous decades and she also examines the modernization that Russia experienced. Fitzpatrick breaks her book down in a chronological order in which she spends her introduction writing about the immediate events that happened prior to the outbreak of the revolution so that the reader, whether an undergraduate student, graduate student or just a fan of Russian history, can gain a true understanding of the air of change that was happening in…

    • 1258 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Only then will we be able to make sense of any political change or turmoil a country faces. Even if she only focuses on Eastern Europe, I believe following her “cosmic” approach to the subject it can be used to understand in greater depth the territorial claims of countries who have newly separated but share a similar sense of culture. For instance, when looking at post-colonial India and the emergence of Gandhi as a great freedom fighter, many Indian subcontinents and newly formed countries that used to be a part of India do not recognise or offer any solidarity with him. This is because when national identity is raised, they (Bengalis and Punjabis) believe that theirs was mostly subdued in the making of India. Therefore, the theoretical approach may have been intended to explain post-socialist Eastern Europe, but on a global scale there are many resonances that Verdery’s book offers.…

    • 1564 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays