Organ Harvesting Summary

Improved Essays
The author defines several definitions in progression in this narrative from the brain death, “beating-heart cadaver” and organ donor. The main point for me is, that if we make an early decision to be a donor, the death actually can be transformed to something extraordinary and gives live. “To be able, as a dead person, to make a gift of this magnitude is phenomenal.” (27) Roach appeals everyone to consider saving lives not only no loves ones, but to a stranger.
It is astonishing when we read the statistic that fifty-four percent of the families, whom doctors ask for permission to retrieve the organs of brain-dead patients refuse permission. I think that bolster Roach’s argument in the way that people need to be more compassion about other people’s lives and not be afraid of being an organ donor.
It is an
…show more content…
For transplant professionals it is a joyous when they take an organ such as a liver or kidneys or heart from a donor, and the comparison to “harvesting” is made to represent a future life, something good that will happen.
The informal language the author uses from time to time in her narrative, like “hoochy-loochy” or “Cherry Sno-Kone” is I believe to make her narrative more human and to distract the readers a little from the cadaver’s image. The language is appropriate and is in the spirit of her massage, that even after our death, we still can make at least “three sick people well” by donating our organs.
The implications of “the ethical footpath for organ transplantation” that was published in 1968 was to make us understand the concept of brain death “advocating that irreversible coma be the new criterion for death”, which open a whole new ethical footpath for organ transplantation.
I believe, Roach uses the image “vigorous chew” rather than “good coverage” to emphasize the importance of this issue and the public opinion on organ

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Stiff by Mary Roach Stiff by Mary Roach is a book comprised of several anecdotes of the lives of cadavers covering everything from testing the safety of cars to heart transplants. Roach’s humorous approach to this book allows the reader to understand the science behind things such as ruptured aortas and human decay. The biological insights that I have gained from this book help me understand the world better because I now understand how humans decay after death (and how it is prevented temporarily), all of the experiments cadavers are used for, and the future of cadavers, such as head transplants for quadriplegics. However, crazy procedures such as head transplants will not be coming to the U.S. soon because another insight that I gained through reading this book is that the U.S. is so heavily regulated on…

    • 1188 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mary Roach's 2003 novel, Stiff: The Curious Lives of Human Cadavers, explores rich and diverse experiences that post-mortem bodies undergo in the non-life phase. Roach gives a detailed description using open, uncensored episodes of interviews of people who work in close proximity with cadavers ranging from doctors to morticians to body farm personnel. Through personal fascination and humorous experiences, Roach shows how cadavers are the uncelebrated heroes of our past, present, and future time in medical and non-medical areas. The use of cadavers (both donated and non-donated) in all areas of life has been explained, going outside the expected medical use. Roach went out of her way to look into a rumor she heard about two brothers in China…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    INTRODUCTION For this week, we examined Leslie Sharp’s Bodies, Commodities, & Biotechnologies and Nancy Scheper-Hughes’ The Tyranny of the Gift: Sacrificial Violence in Living Donor Transplants. While they can agree on certain facts, the two women take on different views of what it means to be a donor and what the consequences are for both the donor and the receiver. Sharp examines the emotional side of the donation, stating that there is a “selflessness embedded” (Sharp 2007: 3) in the act itself while Scheper-Hughes’ suggests it is a violent act where “pure altruism does not exist” (Scheper-Hughes 2007: 508). Their essays pose a multitude of questions: Does altruism exist?…

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Organ donation is an amazing part of modern technology that has allowed us to save many lives. Unfortunately, finding organs that are available for donation can be very challenging. This has caused some to theorise about the possibility of organ conscription after death. In this essay, I will be critically assessing the statement `the needs of the living outweigh the wishes of the dead; so organs should be conscripted after death’. I will begin by clarifying what I mean by the terms organ conscription and death, and what the parameters around donation are.…

    • 1422 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Then she builds up to her point that while people avoid using whole cadavers when parts or alternatives are just as good as the real thing, that scientists have had the privilege to face down the onerous tasks of understanding the human body’s limits. Meeting up with injury analyst Shanahan, Roach seeks to understand the reality of the nightmarish incidents like Flight 800. Through an overview of the accident, Roach delineates the reason that more precautions aren’t taken in planes is because of the cost of human life to projected income lost is weighed in with the cost of safety being too…

    • 1168 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Growing up, I had never heard of individuals who have passed essentially giving living human beings their organs. It was not until I saw the film adaptation, Seven Pounds, starring Will Smith that I finally grasped just what donating organs was all about. Following the release of that movie, I immediately wanted to become an organ and tissue donor. I believe that everyone should desire to be one because organs of those who have passed help save lives each and every day. Upon receiving this essay question, I first wanted to do a little research regarding the issue.…

    • 422 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction: Since it's first introduction on the black market in the early 1980s, organ harvesting has become a global epidemic, with New Internationalist Magazine calling it the "new form of human trafficking. " Organ harvesting is being marketed to those living in poverty and third world conditions as a quick cash solution, while those who are truly profiting from the exchange are "organ brokers" and the recipients from rich countries. In a new form of global classism, the rich are by-passing long legal organ donor lists in favor of a black market organ without a thought of the care of the donor, while poor donors are pressured into a situation by a need to survive - often receiving dangerous back-alley surgeries from questionable surgeons - while being financially taken advantage of by organ brokers who make the real cash. Victimless Crime?:…

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    People have a deep interest in bodies, both living and deceased. Throughout society, there are examples of what the good-looking, healthy, and all over ideal body is, with a billion-dollar industry behind it. There is also an enormous industry behind bodies of the deceased: specialists such as doctors, pathologists, and morticians work with corpses on nearly a daily basis. However, interest in dead bodies has grown astonishingly in the past few decades for a variety of reasons.…

    • 536 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Organ Donation Religion

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The same can be stated for research and experimental medicine, as the pioneer era of organ transplantation has passed, and transplantation medicine has developed to a high tech routine. Within Eurotransplant, organ donation is seen as an act of altruism. There is no remuneration system. Ethical issues in organ transplantation are commonly related to well-known problems in health care. Among others, they have to deal with first and foremost, managing scarcely available treatment due to the shortage of donor organs.…

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Kazuo Ishiguro

    • 121 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Kazuno Ishiguro places a strong sense of organ donation throughout the novel. The main points in the novel are cloning and organ donation. It is almost that Ishiguro is persuading the readers of becoming an organ donor. During Kathy’s and Tommy’s visit to Maddams house, Madam explains to the Kathy and Tommy that they must be glad that they were given the opportunity of life unlike what the other clones are given. By that statement, Ishiguro places that a sense of humanity that each individual who has been provided with this wonderful opportunity of life should become an organ donor.…

    • 121 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Theories Of Organ Donation

    • 1066 Words
    • 4 Pages

    What is your first impression to the phrase Organ Donor? The mere cognition brings up a myriad of emotion perceptions and assumption, whether they are good or bad depends upon each individual’s experience. The reality is that many people have accepted illogical notions of what organ donation is and the good it does for thousands of Americans each year. Organ donations has a large amount of myths, facts, along with my own person ideological connoted theory.…

    • 1066 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The organ transplantation brought countless medical benefit to the nation and its people. Many’s life were extended because of the procedure. Patients were able to continue their lives without having to die due to organ failures and they could continue to contribute to the society. The success rate of organ transplantation has been relatively high after the accomplishment made by Joseph Murray and his team in 1954. Without their efforts, the development of such useful techniques would not exist until many years or even decades later, and many people could have died in between those years, and those who are only brain dead would not be able to donate their organs and extend on others’ lives.…

    • 1689 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In this paper, I will analyze John Harris’ argument structure in his 1975 article “The Survival Lottery,” then raise an objection to one of his arguments, then I will state what I believe Harris’ response to my arguments would be. After an analysis of Harris’ arguments, I disagree with Harris’ assertion that all lives are equal based on arguments involving society, virtue, and social effect. I believe that Harris would counter with arguments of utilitarianism, legality, and application of the veil of ignorance. Harris concludes through his arguments, a lottery to select those that would be killed for the purpose of organ harvest is not just morally permissible, it is a moral obligation.…

    • 1802 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Organ Trafficking

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages

    According to the American Transplant Foundation(1), "more than 123,000 men, women and children are currently in need of lifesaving organ transplants. Each day, an average of 75 people will receive an organ transplant. Sadly, an average 21 people will die in result of not receiving an organ in time." Among those 123,000 men, women, and children there is an expanding amount of desperate and frustrated patients looking for alternative ways to obtain organ transplant. Human organ trafficking is an illicit and inhumane trade that has circled the globe.…

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Organ transplantation has been a miraculous revolution in modern science. The facility to transfer an organ from one human to another has been nothing but an enormous blessing upon humanity. This process has allowed doctors to save endless lives around the world. Organ transplantation is a surgical process by which healthy organs, donated by individuals, are transplanted into a patient who is in critical need of a transplant. The operation itself is a standing symbol of human integrity.…

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays