Ordinary Men In The Holocaust

Improved Essays
There are two sides to every story, and, sometimes, while both sides are not right, both sides have situational factors that allow both sides to come to the conclusion that they acted appropriately. In Poland, Germans forced and were forced to commit genocide on the Jewish population, but with help from Poles at certain times; therefore, is it possible to defend a man who pulls the trigger, but is placed in the situation through potentially no fault of his own? Throughout the Holocaust and systemic killing of the Jewish population in Poland, the victims were the Jewish population as well specific sects of the Polish and German population; however, not counting their commanders and sadistic individuals, the circumstances that made ordinary Germans …show more content…
I am not arguing that all the men in the police battalion were victims; I am arguing that some of these Germans could be victims, too. Most of these men would not have been murderers if not put in this horrible situation, but Browning disputes this by saying that “Evil that arises out of ordinary thinking and is committed by ordinary people is the norm not the exception.” However, I believe that most “ordinary” men will not think evil thoughts and do evil deeds if not put into situations where atrocities can be committed without punishment and where there is peer pressure to do evil. Today there are a multitude of studies in psychology that attempt to explain some behavior previously thought unexplainable, such as how someone seemingly “ordinary” can become a violent killer, such as studies by Stanley Milgram who specifically tests conformity and how peer pressure can influence a decision. With the extremely authoritative Nazi government, it then becomes more difficult to distinguish what could happen to someone who disobeys orders—not only by the reaction of the commander but also by the reaction of his peers. While about one fifth of Germans avoided, were dismissed, or somehow removed themselves from being the firing squads in Jozefow, they highlight that these Germans were an unfortunate example of victimization due to a …show more content…
Before the Holocaust expanded, Polish lands were invaded and divided by the Soviet Union and Germany. At the risk of generalizing, I will specifically focus on the Polish population in Jedwabane and on non-Jewish Poles. After first being manipulated by the Soviets when Soviets took control of Jedwabane and its assets, then Poles were under the rule of the Nazis—neither occupier was known for being gracious to residents of the lands occupied. The Wyrzykowski family, for example, who sheltered the seven Jewish survivors of the massacre at Jedwabane, was a victim of their surroundings. The Poles went from depending on the Soviets for survival to being persecuted and facing punishments from the Nazis for previously cooperating with the Soviets during Soviet occupation, as illustrataed by Jan T Gross, who writes, “When reflecting on this epoch, we must not assign collective responsibility.” This is true about the non-Jewish Polish people—even learning what some sadistic people are capable of during the Holocaust, we cannot forget that the perpetrators were also the victims who, for a variety of reasons, helped with the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Next we are told about the how other Police Battalions were involved in the slaughter of Soviet Jews. Hitler started to not take prisoners, but to execute every Jew. To portray how some Germans were evil he talked about an incident in which German soldiers urinated on their Jewish captives. He continues to go into detail about different mass killings in Europe of Jews. Browning then tells us about the socioeconomic status of the men in the Battalion.…

    • 1001 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Franz Stangl has guilt towards what he had done to the Jews in the Holocaust. When there aren’t bystanders in the concentration camps, there are some just on the street, witnessing the events. “We got sympathetic looks from people on their way to work. You could see by their faces how sorry they were they couldn’t offer us a lift; the gaudy yellow star spoke for itself” Said Anne Frank in a diary entry on July 9,1942. This proves the point of saying that people just don’t want to get into danger by helping a Jew.…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Holocaust was a time of pure evil and grief. From when Hitler became Chancellor of Germany in 1933, lasting to the day the war ended in 1945, the Jewish population was taken from their homes, put to work, and faced with shocking living conditions. One of Hitler’s goals was to racially cleanse the society of Germany and areas in Poland to become a complete Aryan race. In 1933 the first concentration camp was established. These camps were used as either work camps, transit camps, or killing camps.…

    • 1357 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the year of 1933, people were taken from their homes and sent to concentration camps where most worked there until they died. When a human being is stripped of his or her right and treated like they are less than nothing that is called dehumanization. In Europe, these people lost all of their dignity and pride. In addition, they thought that the Creator of the Universe had given up on them and had left them. These people thought that he was the reason that all these terrible events happened to them.…

    • 767 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Im Gisella Renate Berg and, I am going to tell you how I survived the holocaust. I was born on May 1,1993 severely months after the Nazis came I lived with most of my family in Inge. My parents were always scared of my safety so, every time I asked them if i could play outside they said no. When I was five the Nazi’s did a nationwide pogrom known as Kristallnacht (the Night Of Broken Glass).…

    • 401 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “One more stab to the heart, one more reason to hate. One less reason to live.(109)” Throughout Night by Elie Wiesel, Nazis show time and time again how relentless they will be with their physical and emotional abuse towards prisoners in concentration camps. Through understanding the ways Nazis dehumanize Jews and other minorities, we can see three very important steps to bringing them back into normal life: Non physically abusive treatment, giving them goals, friends, a reason to live, and a non-fluctuant lifestyle, and providing former prisoners with more diverse lifestyle choices. One of Nazi Germany’s most well known ways of dehumanizing people is by physically abusing them.…

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Holocaust In the middle of World War Two, in German occupied Poland, with the Holocaust starting to form, the majority of the Jewish population were executed by simple civilians as well the “ordinary men” who had been recruited into the numerous police battalions who were ordered to execute Jews on site. To some degree, the Jewish chances of survival depended on the aid of the polish civilians and the gentiles that were at just as much risk for German persecution as they were. As Niewyck assesses, the question between whether bystander reactions were due to pre-existing conditions, such as anti-semitism, or by conditions that bystanders had very little or no control over, with things such as the German rule and availability of hiding places (Niewyck, The Holocaust, as cited in Niewyck, The…

    • 1453 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Auschwitz was built by the Nazis as both a concentration camp and death camp. It was the largest of the Nazi 's camps and the biggest killing center ever created. In Auschwitz, 1.1 million people were murdered. It became a symbol of death during the Holocaust and the destruction of European Jewish population. (Rosenberg, J. n.d.)…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Martin Luther King Jr. was one of the most powerful African American leaders of all time. Most known for his I Have a Dream speech, King wrote many other works that support African Americans and their fight for equal rights, including his “Letter from Birmingham Jail.” In the letter, King addresses many key points, including the fact that “groups tend to be more immoral than individuals.” Getting together with others in groups can be a good thing, but for the most part, groups tend to bring out the bad side in people.…

    • 597 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The reason many individuals become fascinated with the topic of the Holocaust is due to the question, how could a well-educated nation allow the mass extermination of innocent civilians. Christopher Browning is one of many historians who has tried to understand how the Holocaust could occur. In the book Ordinary Men, Browning focuses on Reserve Police Battalion 101, who were question about their role in the 1940s. After analyzing the information found in the investigation, Browning comes to the conclusion that individuals without any military background such as, Reserve Police Battalion 101, could kill innocent civilians because of their duty to follow orders not for blood lust. Reserve Police Battalion 101 consisted of men who came from different classes of within Nazi Germany.…

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Nazi’s extermination and torture of Jews and other’s lasted for a period of twelve years. “The principal images you see today of the Holocaust are of barbed wire, disease-ridden barracks, malnourished prisoners, gas chambers and crematoria’s.” (Levi, 535) This is different from the atomic bombings because the effects of the bombs were still being seen seventy years later. The value of the survivor testimonies from these tragic events in history is to remember the effects that Warfare has on civilian population, it is important to record each survivors experience as to add to the big picture of the brutality of men of power before the survivors are forgotten, and remember what can happen if tyranny and technology are not kept in check by the morals of the…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    If the men of Reserve Police Battalion 101 were neither brainwashed nor were they killed for choosing not to shoot Jews, then the question arises: why did they do it? Rather than giving one simple answer, Browning proposes several theories as to why these normal men became killers. All of the people do not fall into the same category for “why they did what they did,” but, rather, a combination of many of the reasons best explains these men’s motives. One of the most compelling of Browning’s arguments is that it took a group to make everything happen in the Holocaust.…

    • 1502 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Holocaust Survivors

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Liberators/Rescuers/Resisters of the Holocaust The Liberators of the Holocaust were people who were allies and went to Nazi concentration camps and saved the people there. The people who liberated camps were not just Americans though, Soviet troops liberated Majdanek in July 1944 and continued in liberating camps all across Eastern Europe, another camp that the Soviets liberated was Auschwitz in January 1945. Starting from the Western side of Europe, the United States forces liberated Buchenwald and Dachau in April 1945, the British liberated Bergen-Belsen that same month as well. The groups of liberators encountered the wretched conditions of the camps they went to, terrible nutrition, all of the diseases about, and the corpses that were not…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ordinary Men written by Christopher R. Browning is a book about Reserve Police Battalion 101 and their role in the Holocaust. It details how a group of middle aged, average men went from barely being able to pull the trigger to having no remorse when exterminating the Jewish population in Poland. Battalion 101’s story starts at the Jozefow massacre where many men were unable to kill the Jewish population. The book then details the rest of Battalion 101’s duties during the Second World War. The book leads up to the Harvest Festival where the Battalion had become hardened and could easily kill Jews.…

    • 1876 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both articles of Browning and Goldhagen investigate the issues regards to the Police Battalion 101. It was a department of the German Order Police that amid the Nazi control of Poland assumed a major part in the execution of the Final Solution against the Jews and the suppression of the Polish citizens. Both authors primarily agree that the members of this unit were “ordinary” Germans, they were selected to commit to the genocide of the Jews and the killing of the Jews expressed their ethnic nepotism and superiority. However, Browning investigates the backgrounds and the motivation of the men in the unit of killing Jew, the Reserve Police Battalion 101 was similar to the German society during the Nazi regime, was strongly impacted and "brainwashed"…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays