Opening Skinner's Box Experiment

Improved Essays
Opening Skinner’s Box: Obscura

Having test subjects perform potentially damaging experiments on other test subjects is immoral and unethical. How would you feel if in this class we ran unexplained, undetailed experiments on each student in the class for a grade and to test how obedient each student is? In Opening Skinner’s Box: Obscura, such an experiment takes place where you were forced into a corner. Mentally you were cornered and had no choice but to cooperate with the experiment. Your mind is telling you that what you’re doing is wrong but you keep going because the guy in the white lab coat tells you to finish. You can hear them screaming for you to stop but you keep going, now in your mind you believe that you are past experimenting
…show more content…
For only four dollars you torture a stranger for an hour all in the name of science. The guy says he has a heart condition but the guy wearing the lab coat tells you that you have to keep going and finish the experiment. The stranger is screaming begging you to stop and now you are crying because you want to stop but you’re told that the experiment requires you to keep going(Slater, pg.35). Now you’re thinking what would be the right thing to do in this situation. Deep down in your heart you know it’s right to stop the experiment but the feeling of guilt and not following through is also hovering over your …show more content…
You believed that since you signed up for this experiment that you had to follow through with it even though you felt deep down inside that it was not right. What if experiments such as these took place in our class, where we would be used to conduct experiments on each other. some experiments that force us to abandon our beliefs for the sake of science. Exploiting a person’s weakness even for a moment just to run an experiment is unethical. In some cases these experiments could critically damage a person mentally or physical. A person who feels pressured to do something can be unpredictable. What is a student who is the subject of the experiment had some type of traumatic previous experience that causes them lash out on impulse and do something dangers harming their self or somebody

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The people were yet pressured by the authority to continue and keep causing harm to the student which would make the experiment unethical. Overall, I feel like this was a successful experiment and the studies were efficient or…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the chapter "Obscura" from Opening Skinner's Box by Lauren Slater, she wraps up the chapter by expressing her thoughts on her own actions. She wonders what she would do if she were to be in the subjects of Milgrams shoes. She states that she is unsure how she would react, but knows that it would depend on her situation. Slater talks about her “hot spot”, within her that sparkles at certain instances and makes her react more passionately than she would at other times. People change, sometimes they are good and sometimes they are bad, she doesn't know why they do, but she wonders why they do.…

    • 133 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, this is a largely simplistic view of the results of the experiments. The participants did not simply obey the person of authority named the experimenter. As demonstrated in the extensive video footage of the experiments, many of them exhibited great distress and tension, attempted to refuse participation, and tried to reason with the experimenter (Milgram, 1962). While it can be argued that a reasonable person could simply exit the room to leave or to check on the other participant receiving the shocks, the situation prevented this action, not physically, but psychologically. In turn, it may be argued that rather than obedience to orders, the participants of this study succumbed to incessant…

    • 919 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An experiment should not cause any harm to its participants, even if it is not physical, but mental. In the defense of Milgram, however, the debrief of the participants afterwards usually ensured a decrease in their stress level due to the knowledge that the learner was safe from harm. Therefore, the effects of tension were only short-term, and the debriefing usually solved their problems. The participants were assured that their behavior was common and that they were not sadistic or horrible people. About 83.7% of people stated that they were happy to be involved in the experiment, and only 1.3% wished that they hadn't gone through the experiment.…

    • 1464 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pressure from an outside source can leave people in an undesirable situation which causes them to change their beliefs. For example, in the Milgram experiment, individuals were tested to see how far obedience will take them into hurting other individuals. The objective of the…

    • 1029 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After the couple rounds, the majority of the students answered incorrectly so the experimenter could observe the one who was not in on the experiment. This person “is placed in a position in which, while...giving the correct answers, finds himself unexpectedly in a minority of one” (Asch 144). Asch finds that many, but not all, of the actual subjects will answer incorrectly with the majority because they feel pressured into doing…

    • 1739 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is no objectively correct answer on matters of ethics, as each individual has their own perspective on any given situation. The idea of a ‘Ulysses pact’ is an ethical issue that permeates fields ranging from medicine to literature. In these situations, a decision is made freely before the person undergoes drastic change that affects their initial decision. Although controversy brings forth the argument of whether or not the decision originally made is binding, there should be no debate. An initial decision is made freely with the uppermost clarity of mind and should therefore be irrevocable, regardless of any future changes to the person’s condition that would alter this.…

    • 1036 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Looking back now at the Stanford Prison Experiment, it is difficult to argue that this experiment was not unethical. I am a psychology major student, and this experiment always seems to pop up whenever ethics are being discussed. Many professors have made the remark that this experiment would never be allowed in today’s world. However, I think that while the experiment itself ended up being unethical, it was too difficult to have been able to predict how it would play out.…

    • 453 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The main conflict of Milgram 's experience which can be argued for both sides, that really settled the point where the experiment became unethical was the fact that patients could be considered to be psychologically harmed, even though the debriefing and explanations it could still have an effect on patient mind and…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Imagine participating in an experiment that uses memory and learning. Once you arrive you see an instrument that gives electric shocks to a man. This man is on the other side of the wall from you. As you move up in voltages the man begins to experience more pain. This man is in so much pain that he is even screaming.…

    • 2679 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    During the experiment, the experimenter (another actor) would encourage the teacher to keep giving shocks (which were fake), bringing in the idea of conforming to a higher power. Additionally, Philip G. Zimbardo wrote “The Stanford Prison Experiment” in which people were assigned a role and were either obedient or disobedient to authority. This experiment consisted of subjects who were randomly assigned to play the role of “prisoner” or “guard.” The guard’s role was similar to the teacher’s role in the Milgram experiment in which these two groups of people were to be in control of the other individual’s life. But why do people consciously decide to cast their morals away and follow authority figures?…

    • 1464 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Milgram experiments sound a little messed up when you first hear about them but then you go into all the details and you really start to think about what people would do for money. The experimenters took a person that agreed to be part of the experiment and a person that was in it. They sat them in a room together…

    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Bf Skinner Research Paper

    • 374 Words
    • 2 Pages

    B.F Skinner was born in Pennsylvania during the year of 1904, in a small town called Susquehanna. He was a psychologist,who studied behaviorism, at Harvard University. His father, William Skinner, was a lawyer and his mother, Grace Skinner, was a housewife. When he was a child, he always wanted to be a writer, but later in his life that changed because he decided to go more towards becoming a psychologist. After he earned his doctorate from Harvard in 1931, he began working on psychiatry and the ideas of human/society's behaviors.…

    • 374 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Replication is defined as the action of copying or reproducing something. In context to psychology, it refers to the replication of a study to ensure that the findings are accurate. In these studies by ______ Zimbardo and ______ Milgram’s they also enforce generalizable data. This means that researchers can take their conclusions and apply them to the population as a whole. Milgram replicated his obedience study on two different populations, one was unpaid college student volunteers, the other included only female participants.…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This may not be big traumatic event, but this experiment will still be carry with them leading them to have psychiatric problems later down the road. When it comes to the Stanford prison “experiment it was so unethical that it had to be stop on day six of their two-week experiment, and one of the participants had to leave earlier then that” (Green). the researcher did not care for his participants well-being by “allowed the guards to subject the prisoners to serious abuse and may cause them real permanent harm” (Green). these negative effects of these experiment may question the if the experiment is worth the information it gives…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays