Utilitarianism In The People Of Omelas

Improved Essays
Utilitarianism is a moral principle that holds that the morally right course of action in any situation is the one that produces the greatest balance of benefits over harms for everyone affected. We might not notice it but most of us use this kind of morality every day in our lives. For the most part, utilitarianism is a very straightforward process to help us decide whether our moral reasons are correct or incorrect. In utilitarianism, we must always first determine all our possible outcomes of our decision. Secondly, we determine the harms and benefits for each possible outcomes and the people affected by it. Lastly, we choose the action that brings the most benefits after everything has been taken into account (Garcia, 4). There are two …show more content…
The title of this short story represents the small percentage of people who don’t believe in utilitarianism since they literally walk away from it. In this story, utilitarianism applies because they sacrifice a child’s happiness for the whole city of Omelas. In the city of Omelas they are using act utilitarianism. As mentioned before, act utilitarianism is supposed to increase overall happiness which in Omelas, sacrificing a child for happiness of mostly all of the citizens is the perfect example. People are aware of what they have to do in order to keep their happiness. All of the citizens have visited the child at least once. Some never go back while others visit very often. In Omelas, you never have to worry about your happiness or others happiness. Everyone is always happy and stress-free. Although mostly all of the citizens are happy, some still don’t agree with what is done in the town. The young people of the town are disgusted. It is hard for them to understand why the kid is there since they were born into act utilitarianism and don’t know any other way of living. Some adults still don’t agree with this act because they can relate if it was their son or daughter in that …show more content…
I wouldn’t be able to live my life in happiness knowing that a kid is suffering for me. How can someone not care about a child? The child did nothing wrong to deserve that place. If you were to put a grown adult in there that has done many wrongs throughout his life, he will suffer as well but I would understand why he was put in the room. Our life shouldn’t revolve around happiness. There a are other important values in life. Our world today has similar patterns as those from Omelas. Although the government might hide information from us, jails and prisons are similar to the room the child is kept in because our purpose for putting them in there is related to Omelas. Although the people that go to jail did something bad, we put them in there to be more safe and happy in our life. Another thing our world loves is cheap labor. Many of us may benefit from it as the prices might be cheaper, but those that are victims of cheap labor are very unsatisfied. Why does society avoid this issue so much? Because their cheap labor provides the greatest good for the greater number of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The town of Omelas was a façade, the people weren’t truly happy because they know the cost of their so-called happiness, but they feared what would come if they released the child. Like social media for people today they post pictures showing their happy perfect lives, to get validation. The society we live in is more concerned with their own happiness than the welfare of the world. They speak of equality for all but reject anything that is different. The people of the town of Omelas are similar they are more concerned with their perfect lives than the welfare of the child in the basement even though they knew the child could be replaced with one of their own, out of sight out of mind.…

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Throw Away The Key Analysis

    • 2405 Words
    • 10 Pages

    I somewhat agree with this, but we will never know unless they are given the chance to learn from their mistakes because after all they are human like me and you. This author is making the decision that will benefit society by keeping them in prison. Is are they not also part of society. They have made mistakes as a normal human would but don’t get a second chance because it would be a threat. There are solutions that are working, but we as society don’t want inmates to go…

    • 2405 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Restorative Prisons Essay

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The first, is that restorative prisons give the offender more of an opportunity to rebuild their life after they are released from prison. The prisons also help the perpetrator see the good in themselves as well as others see the good in the perpetrator. Restorative prisons do not just give the offender freedom right away, they have to go through a set plan to prove that they want to be a better person as well as make sure the perpetrator is not just getting away with their crime. Another way restorative prisons are more beneficial for the offender is that they are more humane compared to other prisons where prisoners are treated poorly. Restorative prisons allow offender to get in and out of the prisons faster, while they learn more about themselves as well as their future, which results in them still having a chance to have a successful life once they are released.…

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Then you hear it “But mommy I don't want this, why did you get me this?” “I hate it!” Now I am not a parent but I can assume that that hurts parents like kids would not believe. Why do the kids act like that? Because their parents were never strict with them and never spanked them, so the kids got big heads and started to think they deserved the…

    • 1614 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When I did not get everything I wanted for Christmas I was okay with that and the things that I got I was happy to have because really I could have not gotten anything, instead I was happy for my things.It's bad to compare yourself to others because that can really lower your self esteem and you feel bad but really for no reason. At first when I saw my friend with a lot of stuff I wanted I was kinda jealous. Many people around might be spoiled or don't have as much as you so that's why you should like what you have caused many people around the world probably needed or wanted those things.Appreciate what you have because if you do, you will be able to succeed and get more life. This can also help you in the future, you can have this habit and be able to work with the little you have and achieve…

    • 1075 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It was wet before I got in there”. I actually laughed, he had obviously forgotten and his first response to my anger was to push blame off of himself. I can’t really blame the kid (yes the kid) because he hasn’t grown up into the man he is supposed to be, he is still a child and it is OK for children to not fully grasp consequences for their actions (annoyingly long seemingly irrelevant intro story over). Taking responsibility for your own actions is something that most people in society accept is a major step of growing up into an adult. Which begs the question why is the plague of fat acceptance being allowed to flourish in our society now.…

    • 1649 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Treatment for Drug Offenders Should drug offenders be punished and sent to jail or get help from treatment? Although some people believe that drug offenders deserve punishment and be sent to prison, drug offenders should be sent to treatment facilities rather than jail because it would help improve the community, prisons would improve and money spent on them would decrease, and it will help drug offenders find the right path. Some people argue that treatment facilities might not always work. Yes, there isn’t a guarantee that treatment facilities will always work and every drug offender who is sent there will get the help that they need. However, it is only only a small chance that treatment facilities will fail and 165 referred people to the PSAP program, 34 have been arrested, 21 of those 34 had drug charges.…

    • 663 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even if the man did not have a desire for education, he would have had the option of vocational training. For prisoners who do not have a desire for a college education, vocational training is often a more pleasant alternative. As one man said,“Inmates agree that being employed in CI provides them with an incentive to stay out of trouble for a number of reasons” (Richmond 240). Although there is sometimes a negative stigma around vocational training, many prisoners change their attitude about it because of the skills they are earning. Similar to college education, vocational training allows a person to set goals for themselves through hard work.…

    • 1395 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    It is preferable to protect your child from potential abusers out there. As said earlier there are no particular characteristics that can be used to draw the profile of a child abuser, as they come from all walks of life. Conclusion Victims of abuse can see their lives and dreams drift away because they were deprived of their innocence as children. They risk never to enjoy the sense of pride of achieving one’s goal, for the simple reason that most of their thoughts and focus is on the past events that have molded their fragilized sense of self-worth, as well as their inability to claim their place within their communities. There have been many cases where a child molester was able to come clean with his atrocities on his own children because his wife refused to believe that he could be harming the kids.…

    • 1325 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    People with poor economical status are known to be more generous because they understand the struggle and know how hard it gets. Experiments were constructed to tell why lower-class individuals gave more. Anybody in the world can be considered rich in the fact that somebody else is sharing with them. People who don 't have anything at all, are not picky with what they receive. In life people who do not have anything to their name, will appreciate anything given to them such as pennies, hugs, or food.…

    • 1494 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays