Odysseus Dialectical Journal

Improved Essays
Book I When I was a young boy, my father left for a journey. Twenty years have passed by, and he still has not returned from that journey. I do not think he is alive anymore. There is no way he could survive twenty years on a journey, is there? I hear my father is an incredible man, but twenty years is a long time. It saddens me to speak of my father which I grew up without, but today it came up. One of my father’s old friends, Mentes, told me that Odysseus is still alive and will be returning back home to Ithaca soon. He convinced me to gather the suitors that are staying at my father’s estate to be banished. Then she tells me to head over to Sparta and Pylos and ask about my father. I am so confused on why this just came up out of the …show more content…
An old man named Aegyptius started things off. He noticed how it was the first time an assembly had been held since my father was around, and he praised me for it. After Aegyptius finished speaking, I took over and discussed how I lost my father and now I am losing his home, too. It’s being taken over by the suitors. I disapprove how they eat Odysseus’ sheep and oxen and continue to live here day after day, while still acting rudely. A good man would just ask Icarius, Penelope’s father, for her hand in marriage instead of acting this way, in my opinion. One of the suitors named Antinous blames everything on Penelope, which I do not agree with. He says that she attracts every suitor in, but never actually commits to just one. Then my mother says that she will marry once she finishes weaving a shroud for her father-in-law named Laertes, but every single night she undid the work she had done during the daytime so it would never be finished. That way, she could remain unmarried. But then Antinous says if she doesn’t make a decision, he will send her back to her father so he can pick a husband for her. That really got me mad! Nobody will take throw my mother out. I call to the gods that they should punish the suitors, and that very moment some eagles appear above us. A man named Halitherses interprets this and says Odysseus will return and the suitors will face serious struggles if they do not leave. They all do not believe this. I began …show more content…
The first thing I come across with Mentor is a religious ceremony where dozens of bulls sacrificed to the god of the sea, Poseidon. But I needed to remember the point of journey, and that was my father. Mentor reminded me of that and encouraged me to head to Nestor, the King of Pylos, and discuss Odysseus. Once I reach him, he has no information on him, sadly. He told me that he had left with Menelaus and that Odysseus decided to stay back with Agamemnon. Then I asked him about Agamemnon’s fate, and he explained to me that he had returned back from Troy and found that Aegisthus married Clytemnestra, which was his wife. Aegisthus is a coward that stayed back while the Greeks fought. Then Aegisthus murdered Agamemnon, with Clytemnestra’s approval. Then he sent his son Pisistratus to come with me to Sparta. I then find out that Mentor is Athena, who turned into an eagle and stays behind to protect the crew of the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Odysseus has learn a valuable life lesson from the adventure of the odyssey. Odysseus learned to always know what you're getting into. Odysseus knows what he’s getting into, when “odysseus’s arrow hits [the sutor] just under his chin and punched the feathers through his throat” (955).” secondly time when Odysseus shows that he knows what he is knows what he is getting into is when he “[listened] with care, and the god will arm his mind” (925). I have listened to someone when I was going into an unfamiliar place.…

    • 104 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Shared Characteristics of Odysseus and Everett In O Brother, Where Art Thou, the main character Ulysses Everett goes through a journey with two of his friends to find his way back home. Everett expresses that he is full of pride and arrogance based on the actions and choices he makes on his journey. Odysseus, the protagonist from the Odyssey, shows that he is controlling and full of pride when he accomplishes his goals and becomes a hero. Everett is a worthy representation of Odysseus because they are both arrogant, controlling on their journey, and loyal to their men.…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1.Thebes is plagued by a plague that’s affecting not only the people, but the crops and livestock as well. The priest says, “A rust consumes the buds and fruits of the earth; The children are sick; children die unborn, and labor is vain,” (Prologue). The people have decided to look to King Oedipus for help, and are “clinging to his altar steps.” 2.Creon tells Oedipus, “The god commands us to expel from the land of Thebes an old defilement that it seems we shelter,” (Ode 1). The defilement is the murder of King Laios, and Oedipus must avenge his death.…

    • 553 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Both Odysseus and Krakauer experience guilt in both stories. Have you ever felt guilty for something that you did wrong or think wasn’t going right? Some point in your life I bet you have felt guilt. They both feel guilty for something they have done in their lives that they will never forget. They want to try and resolve their guilt, but for sure, they will both never be the same again.…

    • 469 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Your grandfather, Odysseus arrived at the swineherd’s house and reunited with his old friend, Eumaeus Eumaeus did not recognize him and only saw him as a beggar. Nonetheless, he welcomed Odysseus into his dwelling and fed him food and wine - remember son, we must welcome everyone to our homes, for we cannot anger Zeus, the host god. Eumaeus truly honored your grandfather and he talked on and on about his riches and his heroic journey to Troy. Even though he thought your grandfather will never return home he told him that he was still protective of his riches, and he was furious with your grandmother’s suitors freeloading of all the wealth and food you grandfather had.…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As a former suitor of Helen, Odysseus is a part of a pact made between the other suitors to “defend [Helen] from all injury and avenge her cause if necessary” (Bulfinch). With this pact in mind, King Menelaus “[calls] upon his brother chieftains of Greece to fulfil their pledge” (Bulfinch) and sends Palamedes to Ithaca to recruit Odysseus. Odysseus, however, “[is] very happy in his wife and child” (Bulfinch) and feels “a sense of duty [and]…

    • 1331 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    She is an intelligent woman. Penelope is a seductive character even though she plays her role as a mother. She uses her charm and beauty to fool the suitors in the house for three years in order to get what she want while waiting for her husband Odysseus to return from Troy. Penelope encourages every single one of the suitors to go after her, bringing her gifts to prove themselves to her and she will pick one of them as her lover. By this, she is able to gain material objects that she need from the suitors.…

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My Odysseus College Essay

    • 693 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Similar to Odysseus’ treacherous journey home, my odyssey through middle school had its moments of success and defeat, happiness and frustration, and absolute uncertainty. From being adrift on my makeshift raft in a vast sea of sixth graders to my final days in middle school, I have obtained many new traits comparable to Odysseus’. As a new sixth grader, I was optimistic and hopeful of the years to come, analogous to Odysseus’ confidence that he would ultimately return to Ithaca. Through seemingly endless hours of studying, I gained the ability to make sacrifices and prioritize in order to succeed. Odysseus also demonstrated this skill when making decisions and sacrifices in acute situations to benefit as many people as possible.…

    • 693 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Odysseus

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Odysseus is described as a strong hero and warrior but after his return to Ithaca, but these words are just describing his physical capabilities and do not take into account his mental health. After a veteran (a modern day hero) returns home from war it is very common for them to experience Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder also known PTSD. Post-Traumatic Stress is commonly seen in someone who has just experienced a traumatic event (ADAA). The common symptoms of PTSD are feelings of agitation, irritability, loss of interest, guilt, and sleep insomnia. It is very common for someone experiencing PTSD to avoid places that would bring back memories of the traumatic event or experience.…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although Telemackus has progressed to be the son of his father, he still has not been able to become a man like Odysseus. Although it is true that his physical stature and his personality resemble greatly of his father, he still lacks a few key traits that makes Odysseus so heroic. The first would be that his strength. This was shown when Penelope makes an agreement with the suitors that the first to string Odysseus’s hunting bow will be her future husband. Telemakus quickly realizes the opportunity this brings and ambitiously declares he’d be the first to try it.…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Odysseus returns home from trop to find 100 suitors occupying his home. They took his” house to plunder “ (957) and make his maids serve their beds. They show no respect for his home and he makes them pay in blood. He reconnects with his son and has a tearful reunion making up for the childhood he missed but that family member was the smallest obstacle when he returned home. The real problem was his wife you was cold to him even after he told her who he was.…

    • 694 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The story of the Odyssey, tells of a cunning hero who has gone on a journey to fight in the Trojan War, to recapture a queen named Helen, who was supposedly kidnapped. Ten years later, the war is over, but Odysseus hasn’t found his way home. Maybe it’s just an inevitable force(s) that causes him to stay away from his homeland for another ten years…who knows. Furthermore, the story shows its complexity through multiple themes its surrounded around. The most profound ones are: appearance versus reality, loyalty, and spiritual growth.…

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Odysseus’s road back is when he and his family travel to see his father Laertes, who has been living more like a slave, rather than a former king. Odysseus sees this and feels sympathetic for him and wants to bring his father home with him, so he can live a peaceful life. The arrogant and selfish Odysseus would not want to help his father, but now that he has overcome those flaws he becomes a good person and shows kindness to the ones he loves. While Odysseus is with his father, the news of the massacre has spread throughout the city, and Eupithes, the father of Antinoos, is enraged at the killing of his son. He declares revenge and him along with other men travel to Laertes’s home, wanting to kill Odysseus.…

    • 1566 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to the epic poem, she yearns for Odysseus’ return “with an enduring heart” (XVI, 42). This shows that she is capable of holding onto her belief that Odysseus will return for years to the point she “fooled [the suitors] for three years” (II, 115) in order to delay her marriage to one of them. Even though nobody knows…

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Oedipus Journal Entry

    • 346 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Stephen Ofori Tuffuor WCU ID: 874618 Professor Ayan Gangopadhyay January 27th 2016 Week Two Journal Entry January 27th, today we began reading the classical Greek tragedy Oedipus Rex by Sophocles. This story really has an interesting plot; it unfolds as Oedipus becomes king of Thebes, a king whose hubris and hamartia makes him more ignorant and blind to the truth about his fate the gods had sealed for him. In this pagan and ancient tragedy, the city of Thebes is besieged with a plague, king Oedipus whose entire life is shrouded by darkness seeks the path of light and truth to purge the city he once redeemed from the singing sphinx.…

    • 346 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays