October Baby: Movie Analysis

Superior Essays
The abortion debate is a hot topic of ethical arguments. While pro-choice supporters advocate that the mother has the right to choose whether to keep the pregnancy or not, the pro-life supporters argue that it is murder of a human being(Lavill, 2014). The film October Baby showed the ethical concern of abortion from a new perspective: the survivor of a failed abortion. At 19 years of age Hannah discovers that not only was she adopted, but that her real mother attempted to abort her. Another ethical issue that is related to the film is the right to life of newborns who are survivors of abortion . There is a debate on whether or not the mother should be allowed to let the child die or undergo a partial birth abortion. Some argue that killing …show more content…
Examples of how the principles of nonmaleficence and autonomy were supported or violated in the film will be further analyzed. Nonmaleficence is an ethical principle that values and supports doing no harm to others (Barber, 2014). A medical professional’s goal is to provide care that supports and ensures the health of the patients. This means that medical professionals avoid performing treatments that could potentially be harmful to the patient. The practice of abortion is a violation of nonmaleficence in that it results in harm and death to the fetus. By performing abortions the nurse violates this principle of nonmaleficence. The nurse in the film even admits that the clinic was doing wrong and harmful things, which lead her to quit her job and stop practicing nursing (Erwin & Erwin, 2011). This testimony from the nurse further argues that the ethical principle of nonmaleficence was violated in the film. Opposing this principle of nonmaleficence in the film is the principle of autonomy or individual rights. Respect for autonomy advocates that each individual has the right to choose their own course of action, which should be respected by others (Barber, 2014). Respect for autonomy was supported by the RN in the film because she respected the mother’s choice to undergo an abortion. After the abortion fails …show more content…
I feel like because of the principle of nonmaleficence no harm should be done to the fetus. In addition, the principle of justice or equity advocates that the nurse has a responsibility to ensure the fetus as well as the mother are equally considered and fairly treated. I do not believe abortion fairly or justly treats the fetus because it results in the unnecessary death of a human being. I think that there are other options such as adoption that would be a more just and fair way of dealing with an unwanted pregnancy. Although I do have my own personal values and perspective, I also understand the patient’s right to autonomy and the double effect. I would never want someone taking away my right to make choices that involved my life and personal health. That is why as a nurse I will do my best to leave behind my biases when interacting with women choosing to end their pregnancies. In addition I understand that double effect plays a role in the scenario by harming the fetus while attending to help the mother. Although I would provide vigorous education about the patient’s options and the risks associated with abortions, I would ultimately let the patient make their own choice. I would also interact with the patient in a nonjudgmental manner. If I could not provide nonjudgmental care I would remove myself from the situation and ask another nurse to take over the care of that

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Should women have the right to have an abortion? According to Webster Dictionary, “abortion is a medical procedure used to end a pregnancy and cause the death of the fetus” ( ). When it comes down to the discussion of women and abortion, the topics pro-life or pro-choice come into play. Pro-life is when people do not believe the fetus should be aborted. They protect the right that the fetus is a human whose life should be valued and protected.…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The exceptions include rape, health, and overall health of the fetus. In the piece written by Thomson she spoke about the mom having a cardiac condition. This is an example as to why a woman would want to get an abortion for her health and also ensuring that when she does choose to have a child she will be there for her baby and love he or she unconditionally. An example of over using abortions is just simple not using contraceptives and aborting the baby because you chose not to use protection. This is a reason that some may feel the need to get rid of abortions altogether but in the end there will always be exceptions to…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Abortion Ethical Dilemma

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages

    What would change is where and how women obtain abortions and the adverse outcomes that occur during an unsafe abortion. The quality of care I provide my patients, relates to the essence of caring and respect, not the medical issue involved. I would protect the health, safety, and rights of the patient (Fowler, 2010). In conclusion, I feel abortion is one of the most difficult ethical dilemmas to address. However, I also realize the unsafe risks women take when legal abortion is not an option.…

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    People are quick to consider the disposal of another. But abortion is also a right. This right encourages women to do what they want their bodies and determine what is the best option for them. Another good point would be that children should not have to come into the world feeling neglected and unwanted. The cons seem to outweigh the pros it is morally wrong, but without it where would we…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Abortion Research Paper

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Abortion is legal in the United States of America and rightly so. In other countries abortion laws are restrictive that even when a mother’s life is in jeopardy a woman does not have the choice to abort. The feeling when a doctor tells you that you are going to die because of a complication with the fetus in your womb can be devastating. The doctor claims he cannot abort the fetus because of the laws to protect life. This research paper will evaluate the reasons why abortion should be legal in every country around the world by the help of scholarly journals and testimonials of real woman on the benefiting factor of abortion.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I believed a woman should be able to get an abortion and not have to deal with discrimination from others after doing so. I did believe abortion was horrible but I believed everyone is entitled to their own opinion about the topic as well. That is why I believe that I am pro – choice. Being pro – choice to me means that people should have the authority to make decisions for themselves, like freedom, a right of the United States of America. I think people should be responsible for their own actions and what they do to themselves.…

    • 1017 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    What I would like to discuss in this paper are the philosophical arguments regarding abortion. These arguments are deontological. I am going to talk about the reasons why certain pro-life parties believe Abortion is immoral and wrong. I am also going to talk about why the pro-choice parties believe abortion should not be mandated by the government, but should be a choice made by the woman. The pro-life parties believe that abortion should be illegal, generally for these reasons; the moral right to life of a person begins at conception, induced abortions are an unjust killing which violate the fetus’s right to life, and that the law should not allow such unjust violations to life.…

    • 1227 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    -Judith Jarvis Thomson is a moral philosopher, who wrote A Defense of Abortion in1971. This piece of writing is still causing uproar even in the present time over the continuous argument of abortion. She is for abortion in the right circumstances, and in order to fight the people against her, she wrote this piece of writing. In this text, she states that a fetus is not a person and does not have the right to life, but in order to fight against objections towards her she agrees that a fetus is a person, only for the sake of this argument.She is saying that the usual argument against abortion is “all persons have a right to life, a fetus is a person, therefore they have right to life, therefore abortion is wrong.”. She says yes they are a life…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Argument On Abortion

    • 1713 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In the article titled Abortion: A Pro-Choice Perspective, Robert Blake argues that, “We see the fetus as a potential life to continued development is subordinate to the mother’s right to privacy, which includes the right to terminate an unwanted pregnancy.” (Blake, pg. 5). People who are pro-life believe that if we legalize abortions, than women will get them anytime and anywhere. When the baby is first conceived, there is evidence that it truly is just a clump of cells and hasn’t formed into anything. Perhaps, we will use the example from the reading titled A Defense of Abortion by Judith Thomson.…

    • 1713 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My stance however is Pro-Life or Anti-Abortion, but I look at circumstances individually, and I believe abortion is permissible in certain situations. I believe that abortions are acceptable if the life of the mother or the baby, is at risk. In this situation, either the mother or the fetus could die. The suggestion of abortion is given by the professional opinion of a doctor, but ultimately the mother has the final decision. The mother choses to either live and let her baby die or die and let her baby live.…

    • 1191 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics