Utopian Urban Planning

Improved Essays
Excessive Planning in the Urban Future: Obstacles to Urban Utopia The utopian-style planning of the urban future has embraced principle, and abandoned practicality. In order to form utopian cities, the planners of urban areas like Brasília and Delhi proposed detailed urban plans that have mostly ignored market factors in favor of heightened urban regulations. In the case of Brasília, these regulations, designed to further the city’s utopian conception, have actually had the opposite effect. Brasília’s regulations have drawn population centers away from the center city toward outlying areas. (Bertaud 8). Furthermore, in Delhi, planners have saddled migrants with a strict bureaucratic process for immigration to the city. As such, migrants have …show more content…
In his article, Delhi's Modernist Dream Proves a Far-fetched Fantasy, David Adler describes that Delhi was created to be an example of urban utopia (Adler). However, the city has never been able to live up to that example. The city has taken a radical approach toward urban planning (by forming a completely new urban system) (Palen 334). Consequently, Delhi has bounded itself to an overly-detailed urban plan from the Delhi Development Authority (DDA) from which the planners have been reluctant to deviate. Thus, as migrants have flooded into the area, they have chosen to establish villages outside the city while they apply, through a lengthy and potentially fruitless process, for a legal title within the city. The planners of Delhi have become so dogmatic about their plans for the city, and who should inhabit it, that they have forsaken reality—half of Delhi’s inhabitants now live in informal settlement (Adler). Ultimately, the concept of a utopia is based on perfection; however, those who plan utopian cities must understand that perfection is unattainable, and that making perfection a necessity for a city (in this instance, population composition and distribution) is self-defeating. If Delhi is to become an urban utopia, its planners must realize that the path to utopia is not a straight line—cities must adapt to the realities of the day in order to grow. Cities can never become utopias if they are not viable locales for economic and residential

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    However, the slumming and unslumming theory is doubtful to me. In my view, slumming can ultimately being eliminated, because once planners and the government use scientific and effective methods, poverty should not spread, but eradicated. In Alexander Garvin’s What Makes a Great City, the author uses long lengths to describe public realm. He argues that great public realm is one where “everyone who was there because it had something for everybody” (Garvin 57). What’s more, the public realm does not take care of itself; people must take care of it in order to keep their vitality.…

    • 1356 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Essay On New Haven

    • 1723 Words
    • 7 Pages

    New Haven, a city in Connecticut, is notable for undergoing major changes during the city’s existence. It doesn’t offer images glamorous and lavish lifestyle like major US cities, or the dream of someone coming into this city and having it change their entire life. Nonetheless, it offers the idea of the American Dream, New Haven is a city where one can own a house a among the most modern and sophisticated infrastructures. Its history of development and redevelopment is an uncommon story, consequently New Haven has been examined multiple times because it has a unique urban renewal experience. However, the implications of New Haven’s urban renewal projects have gone unheard and unforeseen by the common citizen.…

    • 1723 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    This quotation describes the effect that outside entities, such as foreign investors and even central governments, can have on the vision of a city. Local authorities created a very particular vision for the city of Hongqiao, even down to the allowed dimensions of proposed buildings. Even though this planning began in 1982, it wasn’t until the central government stepped in that development started to take place. Although the city already had a vision in place, the influence of the government and foreign investors was strong enough to essentially overturn the initial vision, as they were the entities that could make such development actually occur. Foreign and government interests eventually led to the abandonment of the initial idea of a foreign consulate in favor of an open market for land rights.…

    • 1870 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rather, it states not to rely on the gentrification process for urban renewal but to put forth the change. Despite gentrification being able to provide positive effects in Pilsen it is too late. In the case of Pilsen gentrification and its effects are not a good thing. It displaced families, pushed out family owned businesses, and further increased the housing crisis in Chicago. Pilsen if used as an example can be important.…

    • 1176 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jane Jacobs: Badass

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages

    She valued small mom and pop stores and being able to look out her window and see her community. Jacobs took on the role of advocating for these values when they were being threatened, specifically by Robert Moses. Moses, known as New York’s “Master Builder” was determined to build an expressway through Upper, Mid and Lower Manhattan, displacing half a million people. He believed “A city without traffic is a ghost town.” His proposed Lower Manhattan Expressway would span from Chinatown to Greenwich Village, Jane Jacob’s beloved neighborhood. She fiercely opposed this expressway, and Moses’s ideal of city planning.…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hamid makes the decisive choice to follow through after this and creates a chapter on why moving to the city is key to getting rich. Moving to the city is a general statement that can be easily revolved into a fictional story that will make the reader understand why this step is crucial and won’t leave you with questions. On the other hand, a non-fictional story becomes more specific because it has to be a specific city, and the reader will deliberate “move to (the specific city)” because of how specific the story was after the conclusion of the chapter. Hamid makes a critical choice when writing this book and doesn’t name a specific city when it comes to setting. Hamid keeps the setting general, letting all events take place in Asia.…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Healthy City only produces what is necessary for life. Glaucon thinks the first city is not best calling it a “city of pigs,” he points out the first city is impossible because people would also want to have unnecessary desires such as wanting rich food, luxurious surroundings, and art. Socrates believes that the true city is the Healthy City, which Glaucon appears to not agree on, so they both decide look into a much larger city called the Feverish City also know as the Luxurious City. The Feverish City requires a larger city, which leads to war in order to acquire more land. War requires an army and guardians with special skills.…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As per the proposal with the government, these institutions will be centre of excellence as IITs and IIMs have become in their respective fields and will have curriculum related to urban planning, urban transport and other related issues. The proposed institutions are likely to come up at Karnataka, Kerala, Uttar Pradesh, Jammu and Kashmir, Chandigarh, Rajasthan, Maharashtra, West Bengal and Assam. There is a serious shortage of qualified urban planning professionals due to lack of institutions teaching such subjects. The government has, therefore, decided to open new urban planning schools in different parts of the country, a senior official in the Ministry of Urban Development told Deccan Herald. At present, 25 various institutions in the country teach urban planning, including School of Planning and Architecture, Delhi, Bhopal and Vijaywada…

    • 1049 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Hughey suggest that in most places, past events are used to predict the future, much like the first paper proposed. For example, in emergency preparedness, past events are used to identify discontinuities in the current trends and therefore play a role in directing planning and preparation activities (Beckena & Hughey, 2013). In addition, emergency response is derived from experiences. However, they also propose that in the tourism industry, the distinction is not clear (Beckena & Hughey, 2013). For example, the emergence of new preferences makes it impossible to use past trends to predict the future.…

    • 1103 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Flippo Marinetti Analysis

    • 1548 Words
    • 7 Pages

    An unusual idea that came from the futurist movement was that of Antonio Sant’Elia. He said that “our houses will last less time than we do and that every generation will have to make its own” (Frampton). This idea is meant to inspire creativity and exploration of new technological advances, but it is a utopian idea and is certainly not…

    • 1548 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays