Nuclear War Dbq Analysis

Improved Essays
During his presidency, John F. Kennedy received reports from several sources on the effects of nuclear war with Russia. These statistics were collected by the National Security Council 's Net Evaluation Subcommittee, which was a small, covert organization that were tasked with preparing annual reports on the net damage of nuclear conflicts between the Soviet Union and Russia. All of these statistics were estimations of could have happened if a nuclear war between the United States and Russia started (Introduction Document). Even though these reports are outdated now they can help us with future conflicts between nations that have nuclear weapons. These reports were President 's Kennedy 's first account of the scale of damage a nuclear war with …show more content…
Three of these scenarios were under surprise attack of Soviet bomber missiles while the in the fourth scenario they were on full alert (Document 3). This document showed that most of the estimated fatalities were around 85 million while the fourth scenario had around 46 million fatalities (Document 3). Even though the gap is considerable between the two it is still many lives to be lost. One of the major reasons for the study to demonstrate the need for better security and defense against Soviet attacks (Document 3).This would show the true dangers of a nuclear war between the Soviet Union and America, and how much lives would be affected. This helps justify President Kennedy statement because it shows how a nuclear war has a complete lack of disregard for human …show more content…
It also showed what would be some of the United States counterattacks against Soviet attack. Another scenario was the U.S. knows the attack was arriving 48 hours in advance (Document 5A). Even though the U.S. would have time to plan defensive measures for the attacks, 60 million Americans would have died within the year (Document 5A). This is different from the scenarios in documents 3 and 1 because most of the deaths were caused by radiation that was left over from the attack rather than from the explosion itself. Half the deaths would be caused by radioactive exposure while only 1/3 would be caused by Soviet missiles (Document 5A). This document also states that the retaliation of the United States after this attack would probably yield a greater amount of Soviet death with an estimated amount of 96 million fatalities, half due to nuclear radiation. Also that the Soviet Union would receive grater industrial damage (Document 5A). The U.S. would also send jets that would be used to hit strategic locations in the Soviet Union (Document 5B). These planes would aim for Soviet nuclear plants and locations of nuclear weapons. This would cause more radiation to seep out and create a larger range of radioactivity and kill many more Soviet citizens (Document 5B). Both of these documents relate to the quote of President Kennedy because they both show that

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Many were terrified of where the Cold War was going with the certainty that the more nuclear weapons countries had, the more powerful your country was. Both the United States and Russia enormously built up their stockpiles of nuclear weapons. The world greatly changed when USA exploded the H-bomb in 1952. This one bomb was smaller in size than the Hiroshima atomic bomb but 2500 times more powerful. The Russians produced an H-bomb in 1953 and the world became a much more dangerous place.…

    • 1103 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Government knew that the Soviet Union would want to replicate this technology so the U.S started work on an even bigger bomb; the Hydrogen bomb (Nuclear). The United States assigned their top scientist Edward Teller to lead the project. The scientist produced many Hydrogen bombs all variants of each other to find what would be the best combination for a perfect bomb. Out of their main research location located in Los Alomos the scientist had created a range of nuclear weapons from the small Mike Shot with a 10 megaton payload for destroying towns to the 12,000 megaton payload of Castle Romeo. Thoughts of destroying wildlife was a concern to many political leader so they moved the Nuclear test to islands on the coast to ensure maximum protection of people and wildlife; the original test sites were done in government owned lands in what some people call Area 51.…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The frustration and sense of defeat that he faced after Stalingrad and the North African Campaign would have lured him into the trap immediately. The physicists would then present their findings, calculations, and predictions. Werner Heisenberg and his colleagues would then tell Hitler that the yield of an atomic would be the equivalent of 10 kilotons of TNT, the radiation would kill survivors, and demolish everything with just a singular bomb. Hitler would then shift his focus to defense, acquirement of materials for the weapons, and making the, ”Junkers Ju 390”, the ultimate nuke dropping craft. Germany would be capable of testing a weapon by mid-1943 and the first functioning bomb ready to be used in war would come late 1943.…

    • 1230 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Nuclear Arms Race

    • 1132 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The destruction of the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki by American atomic weapons in August 1945 began an arms race between the United States and the Soviet Union. During this time, other countries developed nuclear weapons, but none of them develop quiet as much as the Soviet Union and the United States. The Arms Race was much of just a back and forth kind of deal. According to historylearningsite.co.uk, the USA exploded the H-bomb in 1952. The bomb was smaller than the one used on Japan, but 2500 times more powerful.…

    • 1132 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Positive Effects of the Manhattan Project The United States is estimated to spend between six hundred and twenty billion dollars to six hundred and sixty one billion dollars on nuclear weapons over the next decade (PloughShares). The start of nuclear weaponry began when the test bomb, Gadget, was detonated on July 16, 1945 in Alamogordo, New Mexico. The Manhattan Project was a secret operation which the United States perfected the atomic bomb. Many people did not know about the Manhattan Project at the time, but once they found out they thought it was too dangerous because it involved nuclear weapons. Though many people think the Manhattan Project should not have happened because it was unnecessary, dangerous, and too expensive, it had to…

    • 1460 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If such an invasion was to occur, it “would cost 250,000 American lives” (Jason Hook, 2002). Moreover, the prisoners of war would also have been executed, as Japanese officials would have ordered it if they had been invaded. Overall, the use of the atomic bombs was justified and would be what any moral person would choose given President Truman’s…

    • 1181 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    (U.S. Department of State<state.gov>) The nations made sure that they could defend themselves from the destruction that nuclear weapons could cause. Also the nuclear bombs make the area where they are used unsuitable for people afterwards. The prevention of nuclear war is very important to this day because of how many nuclear bombs have been produced, and the people who have that power. The United States and Russia have the majority of the world’s nuclear weapons, but they are not the only places that have produced the weapons of mass destruction. (io9.com) The Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty signed by five known to be nuclear nations restricts the number of nuclear weapons they can have.…

    • 1904 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Effects like these resulted in terms like Mutual Assured Destruction (MAD). MAD is the idea that if a country launches a nuclear attack on another country with nuclear weapons, the attacked country will launch a nuclear counterstrike, and both countries will be annihilated (“Mutual Assured Destruction”). The Strategic Triad is a method used to ensure MAD. Both the United States and Russia have this nuclear defense system. The system relies on the fear of a nuclear counterstrike.…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The tension was building between the Russians and the US. Neither side agreed with the other’s politics. Secret intelligence existed that Russia was also working on creating nuclear weapons of mass destruction. Truman saw the deployment of the bombs as a way to influence Stalin and the rest of the world by showing the United States capacity for immense power. Not only did America have the strongest army, navy, and air force, but also the atomic bomb, a secret weapon capable of such vast destruction that no one had a defense against it (Capio 65).…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    To stop wars, nuclear weapons, such as atomic bombs, were used, but in order for the enemy to combat those weapons, they had to develop nuclear armaments themselves, which creates a cycle where the production of weapons instigates the production of more weapons16. This led to the situation in the 2000s when there were, “[…] 32,000 nuclear bombs possessed by eight nations containing 5,000 megatons of destructive energy. This is a global arsenal more than sufficient to destroy the world”17. It was only after the cold war, when the Soviet Union and the United States of America were competing to develop more and more deadly weapons in larger quantities, did countries realize that there was no need for all of the weapons they had created, and thus agreed to limit themselves to only enough weapons to eliminate the enemy. The extra bombs were disarmed and broken down.…

    • 1895 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays