Dehumanisation Of Aboriginal People In No Sugar, By John Pilgen

Improved Essays
Aboriginal people are the original custodians of Australia. They have survived on this land for thousands of years before European settlement in 1788, and it is one of the longest surviving cultures in the world. However, Australian society has turned a blind-eye to the culture and traditions of Aboriginal people. They are choosing to ignore the tragic past that ended in many massacres of Aboriginal people. The documentary Utopia directed by John Pilger, and the play No Sugar by Jack Davis demonstrate the dehumanisation of Aboriginal people, and how white authority figures try to manipulate society’s views. By presenting these issues, Pilger and Davis are striving to make the audience feel guilty about the mistreatment of Aboriginal people. …show more content…
In Utopia, it is shown through interviews and actual footage of the living spaces where Aboriginal communities live. An Aboriginal male named Eric Elkedra states that there can be up to twenty people living in a house with no kitchen, no air conditioners, no showers, and no electricity. He states the only access to water he has is through a tap outside in which he uses not only for drinking, but also for hosing the children since there is no shower. He describes his house as being nothing more than a tin shed. However, next to his house is a Government Business Manager’s building which has eighteen air conditioners. How is this fair? Eighteen air conditioners for a few people who work at the building, but no air conditioners for up to twenty people living in a hot tin shed that they have to call home. It’s like society is classing them as animals like in No Sugar. In the stage directions in Act 1, Scene 2, it states there is a sign on a door saying “Government of Western Australia, Fisheries, Forestry, Wildlife and Aborigines”. By having Aboriginals classed under the same category as fisheries and wildlife, it is dehumanising them and saying that they are the same as animals, not a human being. This is taking away their human rights. In the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 1 states “All human beings are born equal in dignity and rights. They are endowed …show more content…
Both texts expose how white Australian’s react to Aboriginal’s. In Utopia, John Pilger used vox pop to present people’s attitudes towards Aboriginal’s. One man, with his young child and wife told Pilger that he was “…full of shit…” This presents that people would rather turn a blind eye and pretend they don’t know about anything, rather than face the issue that’s right in front of them. This makes the audience feel guilty as they can see firsthand how people ignore Aboriginal people, and turn a blind eye to it.
In No Sugar, in Act 4, Scene 5, when Jimmy dies from a heart attack, Mr. Neal, the Superintendent of the Moore River Settlement, claims “Ah! He’s only fainted”. This shows that he doesn’t care to see what is wrong with Jimmy; instead he jumps to conclusions that he will be fine. This makes the audience feel guilty because it exhibits how people react towards Aboriginal people, and how they jump to conclusions.
Utopia directed by John Pilger, and No Sugar by Jack Davis show the dehumanisation of Aboriginal people in different ways. Utopia, being a documentary, it leads people to expect the truth and evidence supporting the truth. No Sugar presents an idea through the play, which makes people reflect on how they could try to make a

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Stand Up Film Analysis

    • 1537 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Australia, being the multicultural country that it is and has been for decades, some form of racial discrimination will always be inevitable. Through the use of characters and visual techniques, Australian Rules and ‘Stand Up’ from the TV series Redfern: Now are able to create a representation of the indigenous race and reflect on the racial attitudes toward them at the time. Australian Rules was released in 2002, and according to the events that occurred in the film, racism and racial divide was still very present in Australian society. On several occasions during the film, conflict is demonstrated amongst white Australians and indigenous Australians. ‘Stand Up’ on the other hand, creates a rather different representation of Indigenous Australians.…

    • 1537 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There was a definite difference in the attitudes shown towards Aboriginal people. White Australians were considered more superior in every aspect. They were not allowed to have a say in anything and there opinions were never valued as they were considered less superior, a nuisance to society and a waste of time. “You can’t tell me what to do on my own land.” (P.88).…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article centres around Stan Grant’s debate during the IQ2 debate series held by the Ethics Centre in Sydney. The Indigenous journalist delivered an impactful and bold viral speech about the topic, "Racism is destroying the Australian Dream” sending ripples across the globe. One of the main points highlighted in the article is that the widespread racism in Australia is shattering the Australian dream. This is supported by the incident in which Adam Goodes, a prominent Indigenous Australian rules footballer was booed on the pitch and told that “he wasn’t Australian”. At that moment, Stan Grant claims to have heard the howl of the Australian Dream, telling the Indigenous people that they were not welcome in Australia, a land they called home.…

    • 721 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    I lived in an inland rural area of New South Wales, and after finishing school I moved to Kununurra, a northern remote area in Western Australia. This was a place where my knowledge and understanding of the Aboriginal people their culture, history and identity was largely developed. I was exposed to so many dimensions of the different ways they lived, whether it was traditionally in remote communities or within the township. This exposure tested and challenged my thoughts, it lead me to further question some of the reasons why the Aboriginal people had vastly different ways of living. During the 3 years I lived in Kununurra I gained much repect for their culture and…

    • 1485 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    From the onset of the invasion of Australia in 1788, supported by the claim that Australia was uninhabited land, ‘Terra Nullius’, a ripple effect of disadvantage began which resulted in intergenerational discrepancies in the educational outcomes of Indigenous Australians. However, the unequal outcomes of Indigenous Australians were, and often still are, attributed to the belief of Indigenous Australians’ inherent inequality to Whites. This is despite the fact that the systems established in post-invasion Australia perpetuated this very inequality through structural and institutionalised racism. The views of race and racial hierarchy which sanctioned these systems continue to linger on and pervade areas of society today, albeit often in a more…

    • 1010 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It was inevitable that the sound of laughter from children his own age, the buoyant jokes they 'd utter and the encouraging words they’d say to one another would cause numerous questions to run through his mind, "How does it feel to be like them? To not be ashamed of who they are and where they’d come from? " It’d leave him wondering how it would feel to be accepted. It’s tough to imagine children experiencing something as horrid as discrimination, it’s even harder to believe they’re also the ones causing it. How they see the universe and everybody in it is influenced by those around them.…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This can coincide with Edward Said’s Orientalism but can further examine the notion of ‘revolt’ amongst Indigenous Australians. In the building campaign for constitutional recognition of Indigenous people, moving away from treating Indigenous people as a race must be replaced with the idea of ‘first peoples’. Problem not being race, but more racial discrimination. Indigenous people use self-determination; and express themselves according to their lineages and strong culture that connect them to places and ways of life that have existed long before colonisation. Additionally, by labelling an Indigenous Australians as a ‘race’ and determining laws around their way of life has only enhanced confusion of the Indigenous Identity within Australian society.…

    • 1170 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Comparing some of Australia’s first definitions of aboriginal peoples, to the classifications used by countries all over the world, the audience can see that there are some overarching themes to these constructs. It is shown that aboriginal peoples were seen as ‘underdeveloped’, ‘backwards’ or ‘inferior’ than the colonisers which were concerned, in such representations as from…

    • 1026 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However due to deep seeded discrimination no marginalization the issues surrounding Aboriginal women and violence aren 't addressed to the extent where these differences between the gap of Aboriginal women and non-aboriginal women regarding violence is closed. Social constructural flaws have regulated and cemented the systemic Ideas around aboriginals; racial and gender discrimination…

    • 1309 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Australian history the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders of Australia were not treated with the respect and dignity that they deserve, they have been the protectors of this land for many years before British colonised here, they lived from the land and they had a very strong community based life. After years of demoralising them and taking their basic ways of life away from them, we now have certain policies and procedures in place to bring the equality back. From the National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders Health Plan 2013-2023 the government is committed to improving health and wellbeing through closing the gap in health outcomes with the wider Australian population. In the National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders Health…

    • 1082 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    "Given the history of the European colonisation of Australia, many Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people are wary of white institutions and social welfare’ (Chenoweth & McAuliffe 2015, p.268). Identify and discuss one or two policies or pieces of legislation that have impacted on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people and how the effects can be seen today. During the European colonisation of Australia, oppressive laws functioned to subjugate and control the indigenous population. The Aborigines Protection Act, 1909 (APA) (Cth) and the child removal policy were particularly devastating, stripping Indigenous people of basic human rights and freedoms, and robbing generations of their connection to their families and culture. Although the Act was abolished in 1969, the trauma…

    • 1586 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ksandra Earle 10G In 2014 John Pilger released a documentary called Utopia. Utopia is about the treatment of Aboriginal people in remote communities; it compares the wealth of white Australia to the living conditions of the original landowners. The main purpose of the documentary is to get viewers to feel empathy for the Aboriginal people, shame for being a white Australian who ignores their issues, and anger towards the Australian government for not providing the assistance needed. Pilger uses a wide range of persuasive techniques to evoke a reaction from the viewers, including the use of emotive language, images, tone and bias.…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The windows and doors though this seems odd, are made of salmon, sturgeon and cod (The Land of Cockaigne; Pleij, H.) Resor and Gandy use another picture called Our Barn Is Full which is a tall-tale postcard (Alfred Stanley Johnson Jr.). This post-card is telling a tall-tale of all the immigrants moving to America, the immigrants are thinking this is the Utopia they have been dreaming of. Resor and Gandy use many other examples, but all of them have something in common and that is even in different countries, society’s, books utopias are explained and shown in so many different and sometimes disturbing ways. Yet all of these different examples have one thing in common and that is they are most likely impossible to be a…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Australia was once an undiscovered island inhabited by Australian Indigenous natives. That was before white settlement in 1788. For middle school students at Kimberley College, the unit for this term has been about the hidden Indigenous history and reconciliation. We studied the book, Deadly Unna? and its connection and relevance to young men and women of Australia. We studied the mockumentary BabaKiueria to help us step into the shoes of an Indigenous Australian and help in the understanding of perspective.…

    • 258 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Beyond The Veil Analysis

    • 1412 Words
    • 6 Pages

    A denial of personal pride might have been absent, but pride in the society that one belongs to is pride nonetheless. On the same token, power still existed, albeit in a lesser form, in Utopia; instead of being born into it, as is the case with European Nobility, power was placed in the hands of elected officials. Once again, the view of what “power” is and how it manifests has just been shifted from one group to another. And finally, as far as the elimination of property ownership, while no one individual may have held land or a homestead of their own, the collective population of Utopia still brandished ownership, in that they permanently occupied, as a nation, the island known as Utopia. It is interesting to see how More used a shift in perspective and…

    • 1412 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays