Miss Emily believes she did the ‘students’ a great favor by attempting to “prove you had souls at all.” While she remembers her efforts as heroic in order to keep her conscious guilt free, she actually did the students a great disservice. By never learning anything other than the arts, and to value creativity, the students never questioned the shadowy system that held them captive to their predestined futures. One may argue that without the childhood Hailsham provided Kathy she would have no pleasant memories to keep her content within the harshness of life, who is to say that she could not find happiness as an escaped donor, living life with all her organs and with actual life
Miss Emily believes she did the ‘students’ a great favor by attempting to “prove you had souls at all.” While she remembers her efforts as heroic in order to keep her conscious guilt free, she actually did the students a great disservice. By never learning anything other than the arts, and to value creativity, the students never questioned the shadowy system that held them captive to their predestined futures. One may argue that without the childhood Hailsham provided Kathy she would have no pleasant memories to keep her content within the harshness of life, who is to say that she could not find happiness as an escaped donor, living life with all her organs and with actual life