Nepa Vs. Commonwealth Department Of Public Welfare Case Study

Great Essays
The purpose of this paper is to answer the case study questions and discuss the legal and ethical issues found in the case study Nepa vs. Commonwealth Department of Public Welfare. The case reveals elderly abuse by residents who endured abuse and neglect at the hands of the person charged with caring for them. It reviews the court’s findings of the petitioner’s appeal of the court’s judgment to revoke his license. This case study exemplifies types of patient and elderly abuse and patient rights violations which victims are often reluctant to report.
“Patient abuse refers to the mistreatment or neglect of individuals in the health care setting” (Pozgar,2016, p. 418). Patient abuse in the healthcare setting occurs quite often. Healthcare professionals and caregivers have an ethical responsibility to their patients to prevent, detect, and stop patient abuse from happening. Unfortunately, as in the example provided by this case study, it is often by the hands of those who patients entrust most with their care that the abuse is committed.
In the case study Nepa vs. Commonwealth Department of Public Welfare, a nursing facility operator appeals an order by the department of public welfare revoking his license due to resident abuse. The nursing facility operator claimed that the findings of fact were not
…show more content…
Healthcare providers and caregivers are expected to serve the patients entrusted in their care. They are obligated to carry out and uphold a patient’s rights. “Patient rights may be classified as either legal, those emanating from law, or human statements of desirable ethical principles such as the right to be treated with dignity and respect” (Pozagar, 2016, p. 438). The residents discussed in this case study were denied dignity and respect. They were also deprived of their “right to receive considerate and compassionate care from caregivers” (Pozgar, 2016, p.

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    1. Please describe your knowledge of the Michigan Public Act 593 (PA593). My previous experience with the Michigan Public Act 593 includes direct working experience with the legislation as a claims examiner at Meridian Health. In addition, I was to complete the course “Legal Aspects for Health Services Organization” for the completion of my Masters in Health Service Administration.…

    • 488 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The nature of the proceeding in the case of Winnipeg Child and Family Services (Northwest Area) v. D.F.G is an appeal. The name of the court hearing the proceedings was called the Manitoba Court of Appeal. The judges writing the majority decision are: Lamer C.J. and La Forest, L’Heureux-Dube, Gonthier, Cory, McLachlin,…

    • 1735 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Francis Jesse Deguire, former inmate at Brockville jail in eastern Ontario, is filing a lawsuit against the Ontario government. Deguire claims the province failed to ensure his safety and the brutal beating he endured behind bars was a result of the province’s negligence. Deguire nearly detached his eyelid and suffered from a head injury. Furthermore, Deguire claims he expressed his concerns to the correctional officers and told them he would rather sleep on the floor then be placed in Dorm 2 but, his request was denied. Documentation states” Within approximately five minutes of being placed in Dorm 2, the plaintiff was seriously assaulted.”.…

    • 217 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the past six (6) months Mrs. Lewis who was the head nurse on the medical surgical floor in the local community hospital has been noticing that all patients who have been admitted from the Shady Rest Nursing Home had severe injuries that were not connected with their admitting diagnosis. Which led her to believe the nursing home was abusing the patient and led her to investigate and contacted the Department of Welfare Bureau of Inspection, which immediately found proof of abuse. But when Mrs. Lewis was confronted by her hospital administrator over this investigation, she was “warned” threatened that she would be fired if she reports any other instances of abuse, since Shady Rest provides a lot of business for the hospital, and that “good relations had to be maintained”. Mrs. Lewis further found out that the Administrator was good buddy’s and a golf partner with the owner of Shady Rest, but didn’t care because she contacted an attorney who threatened the hospital with exposure and penalizes if it in…

    • 1119 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A staff member named Wayne frequently put service users underneath a chair and then sat on it, Simone was often a victim of this abuse, she was also slapped across the face and another staff member kneeled across Simone while she was underneath the chair. This took away the service users rights as the service users did not get the right to be listened to as when they pleaded for the staff to stop doing abusive things to them. The service users are also not getting the right to care and support as the hospital is not giving the therapeutic environment that the service users need as the staff are abusing them, there is no activities for the service users to do to help stimulate them and help them to learn and the staff also restrain the service users for the first option instead of looking for alternative options to help calm the service users. The staff members are also not using the correct, taught way of restraining, but instead using other ways to restrain the service users that are described as “made up as they go” by…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Staff of Life Care had an Ethical responsibility and the duty to speak up for their patients’ rights regardless of the conflict it may have cause them with colleagues or opposing authorities. Also, Provision four of the Code of Ethics for Nurses states that it is in the authority of the nurse to delegate tasks to promote optimum care for their patients (Brown 2015). This did not occur with these patients. Life Care staff passively allowed Memorial to make decision regarding the care of patient they were ultimately responsible for. The instead of being assertive and advocating they relinquished their power and…

    • 1046 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The current board members are Natalie Hall, R.N-President, Holly Presley, L.P.N- Secretary, Cecelia Smith, R.N, Lynda Narwold, R.N, Anne Ogle- Consumer Member, Kim Cooper, R.N- Vice President, Marcia Laux, R.N, Constance McIntosh, R.N., and Ed. D The four major activities of ISBN are to protect the health and safety of the citizens of Indiana in its receipt of nursing services, to examine, license, and renew licenses of qualified applicants, to determine appropriate discipline when there is an allegation that an Indiana-licensed nurse has failed to comply with the requirements for licensure, and to accredit and monitor Indiana nursing education programs. How does a school of nursing maintain their accreditation?…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Healthcare professionals have certain ethical and legal standards that they must uphold while practicing their profession to ensure their patients are adequately and safely cared for. They also need to understand that every patient has a right to their own healthcare decision and this can be through written consent, voicing their opinion or through an advance care directive. This essay will concentrate on how a valid and legal ACD must be completed, the importance of valid consent, ethical issues relating to the patient having their on opinion, how to advocate for a patient and lastly, comparing the legal and ethical standards nurses and paramedics abide by everyday to ensure morally safe practice. An advance care directive (ACD) is a legal…

    • 228 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While the role of the law is to maintain order and achieve justice, often times, such as in cases involving mental illness, the operation of justice can involve ethical, legal, social, and medical issues which creates arguments about the balance of rights relating to effective treatment and lack of insight. Many of these issues arise when the subject of involuntary detention and treatment of mentally ill persons is discussed. Mentally ill people suffer from some of the greatest challenges of any socially disadvantaged groups, which is partially due to overlap with other groups, but largely due to problems specific to the mentally ill. This includes prejudice from the public resulting in stigmatisation. Stigmatisation of mental illness leads to the propagation of myths and falsehoods, such as the widely held view that mentally ill persons…

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Association Between Individual Patient Care Focus and Social Justice The American Nurses Association (ANA) 2001 Code of Ethics for Nurses emphasizes nursing care based on an individual nurse-patient relationship with limited focus on social justice and reform (Bekemeier, & Butterfield, 2015). This direct attention of individual needs and rights is the center focus in today’s healthcare system, especially in a hospital setting. Bekemeier and Butterfield (2015) states that this shift to individual care has limited the practice of focusing on the systems that have created the medical problem, preventing social reform that serve the greater good of the population. I agree that patient center care has limited are advances of social justice and…

    • 729 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As part of their duty they should also raise any concerns they may have if they think an individual's care, dignity or safety is at any harm. This is known as ‘whistleblowing’. Being trained and knowing how to identify signs of abuse and also knowing the different policies and procedures that are available explaining the actions that should be taken if anything occurs ensures that the chance of abuse actually happening is seriously reduced. For example in George’s case study Mark is a whistleblower, this is because he found George in the condition he was in and took him to the hospital for treatment as well as reporting the…

    • 1099 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What is Law? The foundation of the Anglo-American Law is dated back to the Norman Conquest in 1066. William the Conqueror was the first king in England to establish courts and laws that were common throughout the land. The common laws, originally from England are still in effect today.…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this section of my assignment, I am going to assess the influence of a recent national policy initiative in relation to the promotion of anti-discriminatory practice. However, the national policy initiative I will be assessing is the Data Protection Act 1998 in relation to nursing care home as a code of practice. Basically, in care settings when promoting anti-discriminatory practice there are certain influences such as advantages and disadvantages that can come alongside it. However, staff and care providers need to be aware of these things in order to accomplish their aim or goals for the service user.…

    • 1332 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ethical Issues In Nursing

    • 1349 Words
    • 6 Pages

    It is with no much doubt that the health care industry, above any other shows a high degree of concern for issues encompassing the wellness of their clients (patients). Ethical quandaries in health care are often times enthralling and exacting because it puts the health care worker in a position to come up with decision(s) that attempts to balance two or maybe more diverse opinions, both of which have their own ethical excellence. Every day, doctors, nurses and other health professionals are forced to make ethical decisions that abide by the code of ethics set by ethical committees in the health sector. The purpose of the codes is to guide healthcare givers towards identifying, understanding, and resolving tough ethical decisions that involves patients and their families. However, each ethical quandary demands a tradeoff of…

    • 1349 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The American Nurses Association (ANA) describes this provision as individualized care while upholding respect sensitive to the patient needs and wishes. Susie recognized that she needed to uphold this right, preserve her dignity and wishes, and to advocate for Vivian in the final moments of her life. When the code team came in, she had to physically push away physicians and those in higher authority to protect Vivian’s wishes. Although many of the virtues and code of ethics are intertwined, this example of respect for human dignity along with patient centered advocacy best represents Susie’s actions in the scenario. Mary A. Maryland and Rose I. Gonzalez (2012), authors of journal article “Patient Advocacy in the Community and Legislature Arena”, best describes nurse advocacy as a voice for a patients even when they can’t speak for themselves.…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays