Natural Capital Valuation

Improved Essays
Objective:
The objective of the proposed study is to estimate the economic value of the ecosystem services and benefits provided by various types of land uses found within the part of Julienne Carly’s property in North Bay, Ontario, presenting a corridor approximately 200 m wide and 5 km long across the property. The proposal summarizes the required actions, as well as estimates associated costs and duration of the natural capital valuation. The proposed consulting report is intended to assist Ms. Carly’s lawyer and serve as a basis for filing a civil suit against the district.

Introduction:
Natural capital valuation measures and assesses nature’s benefits in terms of ecosystem goods and services, such as water, air, land, and renewable and
…show more content…
It measures avoided damage costs or replacement costs of a specific ecosystem service (Modee, 2014). David Suzuki Foundation has recently conducted a natural capital valuation for the proposed Rouge National Urban Park. The study consisted of several parts: physical natural capital inventory, typology and identification of ecosystem services and benefits, non-market ecosystem service & market values, and mapping of land cover and ecosystem goods and services. One of the key challenges of the study was to fully monetize all ecosystem service benefits due to limited availability of data and information. However, such challenge is encountered in virtually any non-market valuation, and David Suzuki Foundation’s natural capital valuation framework provides a good estimation based on provided data (Wilson, 2012).
We propose to apply a similar multi-part natural capital valuation approach to monetize the value of Ms. Carly’s property corridor. However, we will omit mapping of land cover and ecosystem goods and services, as it does not present useful information for litigation purposes and would extend the duration of the
…show more content…
Physical natural capital inventory:
The physical account of natural capital and land use will be based on the land cover data from the Southern Ontario Land Resource Information System (SOLRIS 2000-2002) to estimate the area of each land cover, ecosystem, and land use type.
2. Typology and identification of ecosystem services and benefits:
The typology of ecosystem services will be based on classification developed by The Economics of Ecosystems and Biodiversity (TEEB) Foundations report. The identification of these services will be determined by ascribing services typical to each land cover type. The ecosystem services will be attributed based on a review of relevant literature in addition to a review of local information sources.
3. Non-market ecosystem service & market values:
The economic value of the ecosystem benefits will be assessed for each land cover type. The valuation will be based on the TEEB methodology described in their Ecological and Economic Foundations report. The market value of croplands will be estimated based on average net farm revenue per hectare in Ontario (Wilson, 2012).
Work

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Florida Ecosystems

    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Ecosystem is a biological community of the organisms and their physical environment. There are three Florida's major ecosystems groups: Coastal Ecosystems, Freshwater Wetlands & Aquatic Ecosystems, and Upland Ecosystems. Furthermore, there are more different types of ecosystems as the subgroups. This paper will cover about the name, location, geology, soils, threats of major natural systems and common plants in major ecosystems. It will start with the coastal ecosystems.…

    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Old growth is a term used in forest community ecology to convey a very late successional stage, where the dominant tree species in the location has attained a very old age. Ecologically, old growth forest is very important, therefore, measurements and indexes should be used to reflect the value these habitats hold. I suggest that an old-growth habitat index be used to reflect the “old-growth quality” of the upland and floodplain regions in Prospect Park. Most “old-growth” indices capture multiple qualities of the trees such as trees with dbh’s of over 100cm, diversity of tree sizes, standing dead trees greater than 50cm dbh and larger than 15 m. These three elements are readily available in forest inventory data sets and are easily calculated in the field; however, height was not calculated for this data set. Therefore, using a comparison of the number of snags of Sycamores and Silver Maples in the Floodplain data and Red and White Oaks in the Upland data, which were the most dominate species in the respective sites, a index can be created.…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    I would be much more persuaded by their argument if they provided more concrete evidence like data, literary analysis, or secondary scientific articles to support their point. Additionally, there will never be one alternative that does not offer some tradeoffs, but the authors neglect to mention any potential cons associated with their preferred alternative, and thus it is possible to argue that their alterative could negatively impact the local environment by altering the ecosystem from its natural function to timber production. Plus, for their plan to fully work as they intend it, they suggest changing the Multiple-Use-Sustained-Yield-Act to allow for greater acreage to be devote to timber, which would alter the law that seeks to ensure that for every acre devoted to private timber crops, there is another acre for recreation, wildlife, water, livestock and ect. Thus some public goods and land usage could be diminished for public and private use in addition to incurring ecological damage with the author’s proposed…

    • 1465 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This article began with a fact stating that 2 billon acres of developing land has been reduced by 98 percent. Also, saying that as wildlands became scarce, American’s began to appreciate it value. From these statements being made you can conclude that the main topic of the article is going to display the importance of wildland preservation. In the beginning of time before the world became populated with machinery and human beings, there was just plant life available. As civilization began to develop, more things started to become produced by technology more space on earth began to get taken up by building and factories.…

    • 271 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Located adjacent to the maple syrup forest was a large plot of land that is owned by the government. While on the sugar bush tour, the guide (who was a 3rd generation owner) explained that the land in his opinion, wasn't well maintained as there are fallen limbs all throughout the forest. He felt that the government should be making a bigger effort to maintain the forest just as he does to this own. I was curious to walk down the Trillium Woods Trail, to see what he was talking about. While keeping this week’s principal in mind, I thought about what this forest would look like if there was more maintenance and I feel that the government has chosen to keep this site as natural as possible for a good reason.…

    • 490 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I am writing in regards to the recent decision to privatize Elliott State Forest. The Elliott State Forest is located within the southern Oregon Coastal Range, and includes 82,500 acres of forestland. This state-owned forest was created in 1930 in hopes that the forest would be able to provide long-term funding for Oregon’s public schools, and has allowed thousands of people the pleasure of indulging (opportunity to indulge) in the vast beauty that our forests and waterways are able to (can) offer. In addition to this, the Elliott State Forest has added to the health, community, recreation, as well as economic value of our state.…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Center Parcs

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Time constraints prevented us from investigating these issues, and instead we tried to focus on the ecosystem services of clean air, clean water, and increased biodiversity, as they all have threshold values for which a customer may decide to not live in our residential area or visit our park. Through innovative…

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For a multitude of reasons, the management philosophy became outdated and failures developed - the old paradigms were insufficient to meet the changing realities faced by federal agencies. By the 1990s, federal policymakers, land managers, and environmental scholars conceptualized and suggested a new paradigm - ecosystem management - to correct prior deficiencies in light of changing ecological, legal and political realities for federal land and resource management and its respective federal agencies. In Federal Ecosystem Management, James R. Skillen, an Assistant Professor of Environmental Studies at Calvin College, notes that the new paradigm of ecosystem management would address and correct prior failures through a three-pronged framework of land and resource management integration across factitious jurisdictional boundaries, amelioration of the conflict between biodiversity protection and economic development, and re-structure the process of federal management by making it more collaborative and less hierarchical. Skillen’s narrative traces the emergence of ecosystem management as official federal policy, how it was shaped into two distinct models by federal environmental…

    • 1334 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The results from Chapter 2 indicate that harvest culture is one worth saving, as harvesters prioritize the forest beyond economic reasons, specifically as they enjoy time outdoors. This was also seen in Bailey’s dissertation (1999). Chapter 2’s results determined that the general (non-harvester) West Virginia community is more likely to value the forest for economic reasons. Since there is a difference in the priorities of harvesters and the general West Virginian community, non-profit organizations or government agencies can use the results of Chapter 2 to develop effective educational outreach materials for land-managers about how a diverse forest can be financially profitable, as seen in the results of Chapter 3. Chapter 3 shows that sustainable harvest of stewarded wild ginseng, or the harvest of cultivated ginseng from a farm, can provide substantial economic value to a plot of land.…

    • 1445 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If someone were to put a value on Tall Oaks, as a natural area, it would be a big monetary value for a lot of…

    • 851 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Dia De Los Muertos

    • 1804 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Nonetheless, with the support from larger organizations, the developing business ENCORE 3 can potentially expand their market into the United States. A non-governmental organization, The Nature Conservancy values corporate accountability to preserving nature and wildlife through means of reconstructing business practices and raising awareness. The Conservancy has a Private Lands Conservation Program that procures and protects environmentally sensitive land; these lands are then offered to prospective landowners who work towards preserving the land and possess an intention to better the environment. Currently, the Conservancy has acquired over 15 million acres up for opportunity in the United States (“Private Lands…

    • 1804 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Marginal ecosystem weighs the existence of ecosystem services to human development. It is important to understand how much profit can be obtained from the ecosystem before it is destroyed because replication of the original ecosystem is nearly impossible and carry a hefty price tag (Daily, 1997). In regards to the Pennsylvania hydrofracking situation, marginal ecosystem service value is not considered important. This is because before the process of hydrofracking began, the farmland was not necessarily used other than extra space for roaming cows and chickens. In other words, even without the piece of farmland, it would not have had any major impact on the local economy.…

    • 1397 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    National Parks In Canada

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages

    By examining different stakeholder perspectives as well as the governance context within which this park proposal is situated, this case seeks to make visible some of the key trade-offs between conservation and development in this region, and to prompt reflection about navigating conservation and development dilemmas more…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Berkes (2004) discusses community based conservation which would allow society to become part of the environment and allow the idea of simultaneous development and conservation to flourish. This would prevent society from exploiting and overconsuming the habitat in order to suit development needs and would focus on the relationship between human and nature. Berkes (2004) also raises the idea of forest conservation which expresses the emotiveness of the wilderness and displays natures astonishing biodiversity. Forest conservation is a way of planning and maintaining the biodiversity of an area so it can be preserved for future generations. It is these different strategies and perspectives presented by critics that subsidize to the establishment and management of protected areas in the…

    • 862 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Environmental sustainability is the maintenance of the natural capitals. Natural capital are natural assets or environmental resources, which includes but not limited to geology, water, carbon dioxide absorption, fossil fuels, minerals and waste assimilation. Natural capital and ecosystem are important in relation to environmental factors and climate change because it provides life-support to sustain human life. Naturally, natural capital has financial values that drives the economy (Global Development Research Center, n.d.). According to Goodland, environmental sustainability is urgent due to the deterioration of global life-support systems.…

    • 859 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays