Naomi Klein's Capitalism Vs. The Climate

Improved Essays
The article “Capitalism vs. the Climate” was written by Naomi Klein about climate change and its solutions in relation to the economy as well as the political reactions to such solutions. Her article mainly revolves around the premise that climate change deniers are right about one thing, that in order to fix climate change, drastic changes in the modern economic models are needed. To this end, she makes a good, albeit flawed argument, as although she does provide a plethora of sources for her arguments at times, at others she stops short of providing much evidence for her claims, all the meanwhile going from a neutral tone of language to at times quite obviously biased uses of it.
She starts off the article from the perspective of a fish who’s just swam to unfriendly waters
…show more content…
Her language is anything but subtle in describing how she views those gathered there that day as well as where she stands on the topic at hand. This kind of biased language is immediately apparent to any readers as she was, as will be seen later, not shy about her position and stance on the topic. An example of this biased language can be found quickly in just the first sentence of her second paragraph where she describes the conference she’s at as the “premiere” gathering for climate change deniers who deny the overwhelming evidence of the scientific community on the topic. As a sentence in terms of language, it starts off fine and neutral but as it progresses on, it becomes apparent that she wants to emphasize the fact that the vast majority of experts on the topic agree that anthropological climate change is a real deal, as

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The public must be enlightened, but the public must not be belittled. That is the major difference between Anna Lappe's essay The Climate Crisis at the End of Our Fork and Derrick Jensen and Stephanie McMillan's As the World Burns: 50 Simple Things You Can Do to Stay in Denial. Although these two pieces seem similar on the surface, as they both address society's ignorance towards climate change, only one truly educates the public on the issue and sparks initiative for change, while the other criticizes and mocks its audience for trying to cope with a situation that is far more complex than the average person comprehends. As the World Burns presents itself as a self-aware satire, in hopes of causing society to recognize how the "easy solutions"…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mark Bittman, author of the article “The Aliens Have Landed” published on the New York Times April 2, 2014 issue, argues that we need to take action to stop climate change. Bittman begins to support his argument by comparing our ignorant behavior towards climate change to the “retreating French” during World War II. He then informs the recent news from the Panel on Climate Change to emphasize the negative effects, and sarcastically compares them to aliens invading Earth. He next proposes a public works project and provides several examples of what can be done to start addressing climate change before it is too late. The author’s purpose is to…

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    McKibben's article attempts to persuade his audience to accept this dreadful truth, as well as doing something about it. Factors such as, fossil fuels, the structure of carbon dioxide, and a neglectful federal government, affect the future of global climate change. Assuming that, we continue to do nothing about global warming, we stand zero chance against the consequences of our actions in the future. With…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    apable effects of a warming world. Miami, and major parts of Florida are a great risk from the earth’s changing climate as the rising oceans threaten to swallow most of the southern half of the state. Tensions between Bangladesh and India intensify as the rising sea water threatens to displace millions of people, with India’s only solution to the issue being to build a larger border. “The Siege of Miami”, written by Elizabeth Kolbert, paints a terrifying portrait of the consequences of rising sea levels with its effect on human populations. Using scientific evidence as well as with her own personal experiences, she graphically illustrates how climate change is dramatically changing the face of Miami.…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the reading, “The Environmental Issue from Hell” the author portrays some of the dangers of global warming, such as how it affects the polar bears in the Arctic, how SUV’s are a big part of the problem and how we can influence change to people by switching to solar power and possibly change the politics that affect global warming greatly. Although the influence of solar increasing and GNP’s is generally reducing the amount of smog that goes in the air slowly, that still doesn’t mean we’re better off now and there’s still much we can do about global warming. McKibben’s main argument is the crisis of global warming is affecting us, animals and how it’s our own doing because of financial gain for the economy the smog that comes certain from…

    • 1187 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In class, we have discussed Naomi Klein’s book “No is Not Enough”, Father Arrupe’s “Men and Women for Others”, James Baldwin’s book “No Name in the Street”, and Dr. King’s “Beyond Vietnam” speech. In this essay, I will provide answers on what Naomi Klein meant on her book “No is Not Enough” when she mentions Trump as the “personification of the merger of humans and corporations” and how we can improve the government and be able to move in a direction that is fair and just to everyone, what it means to be a person for others based on Father Arrupe’s “Men and Women for Others”, why Dr. King was critical of war in his speech “Beyond Vietnam”, and why James Baldwin’s outlook on racism was wrong in “No Name in the Streets” despite achieving the…

    • 1368 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stop Oil Sands Expansion

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages

    They do not provide any facts or credibility besides the fact that the number of scientists involved in signing for a moratorium went up from eight scientists, to one hundred in one year. All that this proves, is that word on this issue is spreading as I'm sure the opposing side has also had in influx of supporters. Lastly, the article seemed to be saying that scientists in fields other than climate change are a silly waste of time. The author makes it seem as if humanity is doomed and focusing on other fields is betraying human life. I found this article to be very one-sided and I didn’t feel that they represented their viewpoint very…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Modern times offer a very diverse way of expressing oneself. The expression of a single person who consumes more than they need may not be enough to hurt the environment; however, the overproduction of harmful waste from big business is big enough to impact the environment. Critically acclaimed author Anna Lappé describes the climate crisis through the food production industry in a sector of industry where people rarely scrutinize in her article “The Climate Crisis at the End of Our Fork.” In a very different, yet scarily similar way Carolyn Merchant metaphorically describes the problems with modern human tendency and desires through the image of a shopping mall in “Eden Commodified.”…

    • 1123 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Public discussion is frequently a positive platform for opening discussion topics and easy worldwide access. However, in Merchants of Doubt authors Naomi Oreskes and Erik M. Conway presents the dangers of relying on the public or popular platform. One of the major issues is the public platform is the number of people in the discussion only fuels to the argument, thus it takes longer to achieve their objectives. The other issue is the stakes and implications the debates have on policy. In general, Merchants of Doubt teaches readers it is important to understand the source of the issue versus what is being debated and to further examine the purpose behind each side.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the article ‘Fewer people would mean fewer worries’, (Geer 2008, p.1) biologist Allen Geer contended that 1. technological solutions to environmental problems are inadequate, and 2. that stabilizing the population at present or lower levels is a durable and easy solution to implement. Therefore, stabilizing the population should be implemented as a solution to environmental problems such as climate change, either in tandem with, or in place of technological solutions. 1.1…

    • 1663 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this paper I will discuss hoe the character Jo from Chapter 1 of Philip Kitcher and Evelyn Fox Keller’s “The Seasons Alter”, develops two broad types of evidential support for human-induced climate change. Her two claims include: build on what you know and consider the alternatives. I will accuracy present how these two types of evidential support for human-induced climate change (build on what you know and consider the alternatives), support the claim that human activities are contributing to climate change and that indeed it is real. I will also engage critically with Jo’s claims by considering ways in which humans might act to mitigate the effects of climate change.…

    • 1314 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Climate Of Doubt Analysis

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Frontline’s Climate of Doubt was a compelling film showing how climate change has become more of a political issue than an environmental one. The film followed correspondent John Hockenberry around the United States as he interviewed several individuals that included scientific specialist, conservative republicans and liberal democrats who may or may not have been holding a position in office at that point in time. He asked simplistic questions surrounding the issue of climate change that could have been answered by anyone who was able to comprehend their own beliefs, however some individuals refused to answer the question directly and the pattern seen behind their response seemed to be associated with their political choices. It was clear to see that throughout the film there was a trend occurring. Republicans refuse to believe that human-made climate change is an issue and the real question is why they believe such lies.…

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The correct use of the term, especially by an influential figure aids in the acceptance of climate change’s presence. Research in the article "The Scientific Consensus On Climate Change As A Gateway Belief: Experimental Evidence" notes that “at least 97% of climate scientists have concluded that human-caused climate change is happening” (van der Linden et al. 1). The scientific evidence supporting climate change is paramount, yet numerous people--conservative Republicans--continue to believe that the severity of the situation does not exist. Climate change has gained controversy within the political sphere due its negative portrayal of fossil fuels an energy source which Americans have relied on for decades. This financially and politically motivated reliance has left little to no room for alternative energy sources: ethanol, geothermal, solar, and…

    • 1270 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Remaining neutral, she gives the reader a good chance to see where both sides are coming from but also giving many reasons to contradict the other so that no bias is influencing the reader’s opinion. Meant for any one, aware of this debate or not, she clears the fact this issue has been exaggerated and is indeed affecting…

    • 1514 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thank you Dimitri, Ben, Viktoriia, and Vladimir for your thoughtful take on whether or not the media should have a responsibility to cover climate change related issues and if they adequately raise awareness and concern among the population. Your points of unquantifiable predictions, using an alternative organization for reporting purposes, and educating the people in power not the masses are very valid arguments for reporting climate change differently. However as a team we still feel that mass media has the most power to convince the public that change is necessary; since it is an extensive issue that affects all, they can reach the largest audience, and that in democratic states the masses can persuade their leaders to commit to change.…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays