Nancy Mairs On Being A Cripple Analysis

Improved Essays
Nancy Mairs, in her nonfiction essay, “On Being a Cripple,” (1986) coveys her perpetual struggle in “getting the hang of” her debilitating condition—Multiple Sclerosis. Though her view of her condition is turbulent, Mairs acknowledges one constant truth—that she is plainly a “cripple”. Mairs’ utilization of this motif “squarely” elucidates survival amongst inexorable forces. Mairs’ purpose is to identify and generalize her condition in order to express the complexity of its duality, ultimately to explicate acceptance in stark contrast to episodic dejection. In doing so, Mairs exemplifies strengthened command over her “crippleness” and proves that she is not defined by her illness. In paragraph 16, Mairs imparts a hopeful undertone in her claim that …show more content…
Mairs’ “crippleness”, intransient to modern medicine or Scrooge’s transformation to a better man like that of Tiny Tim’s, incite implied longings for outcries similar to those of Caliban’s, instead of realistic expectations of “crippleness”, embodied in Tiny Tim’s pacifism and purity. Thus, in employing these references to well known characters who share ailments Mairs relate to, Mairs elucidates dynamic introspection between these two contrasting paradigms. In paragraphs 22-26, Mairs shifts her claim to epitomize certainty by attesting to the notion that “what [she] hates is not [herself] but a disease” (22), and in effect, defines herself as someone more than a disease. This is further substantiated in the short declarative sentence, “I am not a disease.” In transition from long, convoluted syntax, commonplace in paragraphs 18-21, to short declarative sentences, Mairs indicates resolute conviction. Mairs’ sentence structure prior to paragraph 22, evokes incessant anxiety and worry—particularly caused by what Mairs perceives as deviance from physical ideality. However, Mairs imparts a crescendo-like effect to offset her complex sentence structure with powerful simple sentences. This change in syntax

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Looking deeper, the depiction of people with physical disabilities has improved over time while the perspective on people with mental illness has gotten worse. Despite the similarities and differences of these two writings, it is clear to see that the media is misleading our society with inaccurate views of people with disabilities. With mental and physical disabilities playing such a large role around us, our society should keep in mind the thoughts shown by Mairs and Anaya. We must realize that the actions and thoughts we have toward others truly…

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Christopher reeves ,the author of “The Speech to the Democratic National Convention, implores us to respond to human suffering and injustice by treating all Americans with disabilities and the research for them through his use of point of view, cultural experience ,and as well his use of rhetorical appeals. Reeve uses point of view and cultural experience in order to communicate that there the reader should respond to his injustice by talking about research is key. When we put our minds to a problem, we can usually find solutions. Reeve describes about us all by “ one in five of us has some kind of disability”(reeve2)…

    • 289 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Definition of Terms,” author Lucia Perillo analyzes the various terms in which her condition (multiple sclerosis) is known as and how their meanings vary. According to Perillo, society has identified the beauty within people like herself and fear they won’t match up. Because of this, slurs such as cripple, disabled, or handicapped are used in order to mask this treasure within an individual (Perillo 16). As Perillo suggests, a speaker using slurs forces themselves into a toxic state of mind (Perillo 6). Perillo presents this claim as a comparison with stories, providing strong imagery.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Price’s purpose for writing this article is to inform her audience about the different definitions of disability and also to rework the definition itself. Her main argument is that there are many words one can use to describe “impairments of the mind”, but there is not one correct word to use to describe them (298). One must acknowledge the different definitions and decipher which one fits to the situation at hand. However, the definition that a person chooses must be more inclusive and expressive of individuality. She gives the readers about seven words to choose from when defining mental disability and gives examples as to how those words can be used.…

    • 1363 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hoagland’s “ On Stuttering” This essay was exceedingly interesting; at the heart of this essay, is a person who has struggled with a physical impediment, but has still managed to lead a fairly normal life. Although He struggled with the impediment to the point of not voicing his own opinion, Edward Hoagland adapted to his impediment and was able to overcome the struggles he faced everyday. Some disabilities can leave people trapped inside their own body.…

    • 796 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dreams are the fuel to real-life goals. They allow thinking beyond and within constraints. However, for some, these constrains are more apparent on certain people. Pauline, a cripple in the short story “Leaving the iron Lung” by Anne Laurel Carter, is seemingly restrained because of an uncontrollable virus, polio. The author explores Pauline’s world and shows the life she lives with.…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Unfortunately, a variety of deadly diseases exist, leaving people to battle for their lives every day. Many people feel helpless and lose hope at a certain stage in their disease, whereas others, fight back and continue to live their life to its fullest potential. In the personal essays “On Being a Cripple” written by Nancy Mairs and “Living Under Circe’s Spell” written by Matthew Soyster, both authors have Multiple Sclerosis (MS), a severe disease in which they approach differently. Through a very negative tone, Soyster addresses those who do not have MS, by sharing the limitations and restrictions the terrible disease has on his life. On the other hand, Mairs uses a motivating persona to argue that nothing should stop a person from doing what…

    • 1328 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Without actually living in another person’s life, someone cannot really tell what the other person is going through or how they are feeling, and this can occur when it comes to disabled people. In “On Being a Cripple” by Nancy Mairs and “Living Under Circe’s Spell” by Matthew Soyster, the reader is lead into the state of mind of people living with disabilities. The essay written by Mairs analyzes how being disabled does not define someone's character, and Soyster expresses the struggles of being crippled and how others view them. Both essays direct the text towards other people who are disabled, or someone who may have a negative view on disabled people. With the use of diction and other devices, Mairs tends to sound more humorous and lively,…

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A medical diagnosis can change our minds in a positive or negative way, we can suggest to keep an open mind, when Cancer and Multiple sclerosis change our perspective on how we see illness. The Cancer Journal by Audre Lorde reflects on how a woman who loses her breast still believes that she is a warrior. Likewise, a famous feminist, Nancy Mairs, author of “On Being a Cripple” is a woman who calls herself “a cripple” by making fun of herself instead of having others do it for her. The way people see themselves is how the world beholds them. Thus, Lorde and Mairs call themselves a warrior and a cripple, which changes their perspectives on their illnesses and redefine themselves to prevent others from defining them.…

    • 991 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the passage by Nancy Mairs, she refers to herself as a “cripple.” Her choice to do so, along with her reasoning, and tone was well explained. Nancy Mairs referred to herself as a “cripple” because of many reasons. One of these reasons was that she didn’t like the euphemistic alternatives. She states that using “differently abled” rather than “handicapped” or “disabled” has the same affect as calling a country’s undeveloped state “underdeveloped” or “less developed.”…

    • 219 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Chapter two of No Pity, written by Joseph P. Shapiro, focused on the Edward Roberts, a pioneering leader of the disability rights movements. The chapter starts with a look into Roberts’ life and how he struggled to find normalcy after becoming disabled. At the young age of fourteen Roberts fell ill with Polio and his life changed in a dramatic way. He went from being a star on his high school football team to being paralyzed from the neck down, unable to breath on his own. Because he was unable to breath on his own, Roberts spent roughly eighteen hours a day in the iron lung.…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wendell explains that disability is not easily deconstructed, despite efforts of accommodation to some of the needs of people with disabilities because everyone with a disability experienced space and time differently. She begins to describe how one’s environment can be an obstacle for people with disabilities, however people with disabilities may not view them as obstacles. Lastly, she begins to describe obstacles of disability. Susan Wendell argues that “the distinction between the biological reality of a disability and the social construction of a disability cannot be made sharply, because the biological and the social are interactive in creating disability.” She goes on to explain how disability is socially constructed and how it is relative to one’s environment and standards of normality.…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rosemarie Garland-Thomson was a key figure in feminist disability studies. Within the critical framework of feminist disability studies, disability becomes a representational system rather than a medical problem; meaning that whoever has a disability or was seen as different did not represent what was considered beautiful throughout our society. Rosemarie Garland-Thomson wrote an article titled “Misfits: A Feminist Materialist Disability Concept”, which has many strengths and weaknesses. Her essay makes three arguments: “the concept of misfit emphasizes the particularity of varying lived embodiments and avoids a theoretical generic disabled body; the concept of misfit clarifies the current feminist critical conversation about universal vulnerability…

    • 1298 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Charles Murry says this and I think that it is significant to what the author is trying to express the whole time. Also, Murry is one of the biggest influences in her…

    • 1055 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Feminist Disability Study

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages

    I first became familiar with the relationship between feminism and disability when I was assigned reading from the anthology Feminist Disability Studies. With essays from writers such as Rosemarie Garland-Thomson and Alison Kafer, it is an incredibly powerful collection, demonstrating how the interests of feminist theory and disability studies overlap. And yet, despite the efforts of these scholars and disabled feminists in academia and in activist groups, disability does not seem to be on the broader feminist agenda. Similar to the Garland-Thomson and Kafer essays we read, I hope to make the case as to why a specifically feminist focus on disability within academia and activism is not taking away from the current feminist movement, and in…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays