Nancy Cruzan Case Study

Improved Essays
Nancy Cruzan on the frigid night of January in 1983 was driving home from her job at a cheese factory down Elm Road in Jasper County Missouri when she lost control of her car and was promptly flung from her vehicle when she crashed into a ravine. Cruzan was later found by EMT face-down in a ditch of water, and was successfully resuscitated when no vital signs could be found. Cruzan was then transferred to a hospital in a comatose state where the attending surgeon diagnosed her as having severe brain damage caused by oxygen deprivation over an extended amount of time, also known as anoxia. Cruzan remained in a deep coma for about three weeks after the accident before doctors decided to further diagnose her with being in a persistent vegetative …show more content…
The only life-sustaining treatment that could be withdrawn in Cruzan’s case was the artificial nutrition and hydration supplied through her feeding tube. The people opposed the withdrawal of the life-sustaining equipment, and became inflamed by the notion of Nancy dying from starvation and dehydration when Cruzan’s parents had made the decision to have her removed from the life-sustaining equipment. The right-to-life groups fought Cruzan’s family with passion, afraid of what the consequences to society would be if Cruzan’s family were legally allowed to take away her life-sustaining equipment and hastening her death. The right-to-life groups weren’t the only people against Cruzan’s family’s decision, the rehabilitation center in which Cruzan was housed also strongly disagreed with the family’s decision. Cruzan’s family went to court fighting for what they believed Cruzan would have wanted, and they were vigorously challenged every step of the way. Cruzan did not have a living will, or a durable power of attorney document stating her end-of-life wishes, so initially, the court felt that the state’s interest in upholding the purity of life superseded the quality-of-life arguments that Cruzan’s family diligently …show more content…
Right-to-life protesters stood outside the rehabilitation center Cruzan was staying in after her feeding tube was removed holding signs with comments like “PLEASE FEED NANCY”, many of these protesters even tried desperately to get close to Cruzan in order to rejoin her with her feeding tube. These protesters spoke out in an unyielding disapproval to the court’s decision, disputing what they considered the murder of Nancy Cruzan. The Cruzan case was one of the most substantial legal battles regarding euthanasia, it had revealed the complexity of the medical decision making process to an extensive audience, and motivated Senator John Danforth to present the Patient Self-Determination Act, the first legislation outlining uniform advance directives (Contemporary World Issues). The Patient Self-Determination Act or PSDA for short, was a critical move on the road to expounding the duties of the physician, patient, family, and healthcare facilities. PSDA superseded all state-level living will legislation and guaranteed everyone living in the United States access to advance

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Director, Missouri Department Of Health 1990,” Encyclopedia (2001) states the case along with Majority and the Dissenting opinion. This article states my case, which is of course part of the government. Justice William J. Brennan, Jr. wrote “Dying is personal… For many, the thought of an ignoble end [not noble] steeped in decay, is abhorrent [horrible]..., no state interests could outweigh the rights of an individual in Nancy Cruzan’s position. Whatever a state’s possible interest in mandating [requiring] life-support treatment under other circumstances, there is no good to be obtained here by Missouri’s insistence that Nancy Cruzan remain on life-support systems if it is indeed her wish not to do…

    • 680 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The chapter 3, Comas: Karen Quinlan, Nancy Cruzan, and Terri Schiavo, introduces three new cases of patients facing a persistent vegetative state (PVS.) These cases discuss the ethical and political issues of keeping people in a vegetative state alive, being individuals who would never have a conscious life again. The first case began around the resolution of the Supreme Court of New Jersey about the removal of the ventilator to the PVS patient Karen Quinlan, in 1976. Her father waged a legal battle with the Supreme Court of New Jersey to have the right to disconnect the respirator that kept Karen alive, to which agreed with Quinlan's father. As Quinlan, Nancy Cruzan became a public case after being in an irreversible vegetative state.…

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “As illustrated in in the case Cruzan v. Missouri, implementing assisted suicide would give the terminally ill and suffering patients the chance to die with dignity.” The cases involving death have always been controversial. As the life expectancy began increasing and people began dying in hospitals, the controversy over right to die and assisted suicide came into place. This is when Cruzan v. Director, Missouri Department of Health 1990 came into limelight and became a hot topic for the next decade or so because their is no law backing up this case. “The war started when twenty- five year Nancy…

    • 1550 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kansas Vs Crane Case Study

    • 1265 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Content of Litigation Plaintiff: Argued the New York ban violates the 14th amendment’s equal protection clause by allowing ill adults to end their own lives. Also brought up the point that there was no direct distinguished difference between the two ways. Defendant: Defended the ban stating that it prolonged the lifespan of the patients and it was valid as it had important public interest that satisfied the constitutional requirements. III.…

    • 1265 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She explained that the hospitals care more about its policies than the actual preferences of the patient. During this section, she examined her views on abortion being a strong…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The court noted that Ms Bouvia was mentally competent, understood the risks involved in refusing nasogastric tube feeding, and, hence, any objections to her refusal of the feeding could not be based on those grounds. The hospital staff argued that the interests of the state should prevail over the rights of the patient to refuse treatment. Traditionally, viable state interests include: preserving life, preventing suicide, protecting innocent third parties, and maintaining the ethical standards of the medical profession. The court decided that these interests, although valid, were insufficient to overcome Ms Bouvia's right to refuse medical treatment. The appellate court concluded that the trial court had erred in deciding that, just because Ms Bouvia could live an additional 15 to 20 years with sufficient feeding, the state's interest in preserving her life for that period prevailed over her individual right to autonomy.…

    • 694 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Opposition to the Supreme Court decision of the Roe v. Wade case, which upheld a woman’s right to have an abortion in the early months of pregnancy, brought together a vast gathering of individuals and different organizations. They were prepared to support any political agenda that agreed with…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Terri Schiavo Case

    • 1369 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Introduction The case of Terri Schiavo brought attention to the debate over the right-to-die. On both sides of the debate, people from around the world, including the Vatican, weighed in with their opinion and viewpoints. There was no correct answer and no easy answer about if Terri Schiavo should live, with the requirements of extensive long-term care, or if she should die, presuming her informal conversation she had with Michael Schiavo about life-saving and prolonging were enough to make the decision final. This research paper will review how Terri Schiavo, Michael Schiavo, the Schindlers, the international attention and the State of Florida statutes played a role in a landmark decision involving Terri Schiavo’s end-of-life decision.…

    • 1369 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Cruzan V. Missouri Dhs Case Study

    • 1674 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 5 Works Cited

    The Cruzan family won the right to remove Nancy from life sustaining machines and feeding tubes. " Last spring (1996) Ninth Circuit Judge Stephen Reinhardt wrote a fire breathing opinion to overturn Washington's Assisted-Suicide Ban on behalf of three plaintiffs who had already died naturally. Choosing a dignified death, Reinhardt asserted was a Constitutional Right under the 14th Amendment's Due Process Protection of Personal Liberties and the Principal of Privacy defined in the Court's abortion rulings. ' A competent terminally ill adult' should not be forced to endure 'a childlike state of helplessness, diapered, sedated, incompetent'" (Van Biema…

    • 1674 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 5 Works Cited
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Physician-Assisted Suicide: The Trouble With Dying Introduction Have you ever wondered what life would be like if you were unable to rationally think for yourself, speak for yourself or emotionally accept yourself, lying in a hospital bed unable to convey that you wouldn 't want to live this life anymore? Instead, maybe you are able to portray what you want in life but life has made things complicated by throwing you a curveball of irreversible brain cancer or any terminal illness for that matter. Would you be willing to end your life if you had the chance to live a life pain-free or the life you previously lived before?…

    • 1738 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a result, her family grieves from the loss of a loved one, but they also have to pay for medical bills, that did not help her disease. However, this family’s misery could have been more bearable with assisted suicide, but most states illegalize the cure for terminally ill patients. People who did not vote for assisted suicide states that it goes…

    • 1327 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout American society, the citizens believe that they have rights that protect their free will. The citizens assume that every right given to them is for protection. They do not realize that a right can harm them. Truthfully, some of the rights that are given to the people by the governemnt are not benefical. In A Crime of Compassion by Barbara Huttmann, the author expresses her opinion towards the right of being revived.…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Argumentative Essay On Mercy Killing

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages
    • 7 Works Cited

    Supporters also ask why mercy killing is not legalized when murder in defense is taken into consideration by law (Naik, 2011). 1. The Patient’s right to self-determination. Patient empowerment has been a trend for more than twenty-five years. “it’s my life, my pain.…

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages
    • 7 Works Cited
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This analogy is challenging the more extreme view held by those in opposition to abortion. This view finds abortion “impermissible even to save the mother’s life.” Imagine a woman has become pregnant and in the same day learns of a newly developed heart disease that will kill her if she carries her baby to term. The baby has a right to life, but so does the woman. Thomson brings up the argument most familiar.…

    • 1953 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the United States of America, the legality of physician-assisted suicide or “Active Euthanasia” has been the topic of a highly debated political controversy. Whether there is a morally relevant difference between “Active Euthanasia” and “Passive Euthanasia”, or more simply between doing and allowing harm is at the center of this dispute. Two American philosophers, James Rachels and Bonnie Steinbock share their outlooks on the topic in their essays Active and Passive Euthanasia (1975) and The Intentional Termination of Life (1979). Steinbock argues that Rachels has misinterpreted the standard view on the subject, or the view in which the American Medical Association has published, and refutes Rachel 's conclusion. However, Rachel 's provides…

    • 1667 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays