My Sister's Keeper

Improved Essays
I first met my Grandma Vita at my birth; she came to welcome me into this world. I may not remember that, but I remember all the times I had visited her in the hospital. She was always in pain from the treatment she had to receive. She tried not to show it, but you could see the pain in her eyes. Later on, doctors revealed she had not been on the proper treatment and they were giving her too much pain medication that was slowly killing her. These are the harsh facts of life. This is what inspired me to read the novel My Sister’s Keeper by Jodi Picoult. It is an amazing story about a girl with a rare form of leukemia. The movie of the same name, directed by Nick Cassavetes, told a sufficient story. Ultimately, the book overrides the movie because …show more content…
Anna says that her purpose is to solely save her sister Kate. At the age of 2, Kate was diagnosed with a form of leukemia that is extremely rare and the only way to save her would be a genetic match. Since the slightly older brother Jesse had not been a match, Sara and Brian Fitzgerald make the decision to make a “designer baby.” Lo and behold Anna is conceived as an allogeneic donor. Whenever Kate is in the hospital, Anna must fulfill Kate’s needs. Whether it be for granulocytes, lymphocytes, or bone marrow. A new problem arises, Kate’s kidneys are failing. Her only hope to survive is by receiving one of Anna’s kidneys. Anna wants to be able to have a say in what happens with her body and thus far has not been permitted to have an opinion. She believes her only solace is to get a lawyer and become medically emancipated. She discusses her idea with her brother Jesse. Jesse is an outcast, misunderstood and borderline delinquent. Anna chooses Campbell from a newspaper clipping. She obviously cannot afford a lawyer, but he understands that and makes the proper arrangements. Sara is appalled that Anna is acting upon the situation in such a manner and makes the decision to become the opposing lawyer. She argues that Anna is not mature enough to make these decisions and tries arguing to dismiss the case. Judge DeSalvo decides to assign Julia to be Anna’s …show more content…
1). The author of the article does not appear to have the same viewpoint as I do. The flashbacks are described as sudden, and they do not flow smoothly with the text. They go on to explain that the transitions are not elegant and should have had more attention. They are definitely not in favor of this read. They may not have appreciated the flashbacks or transitions, but they did believe the plot was well done in the sense that it tugs on the heartstrings of the reader (par. 1). On the other hand, the reviewers at Booklist had a more positive outlook on the matter. My Sister’s Keeper is an intricate novel and one that does not deserve to be put down until every page is read (par. 1). From the moment the book is opened, the reader will be consumed by the fantastic read. This is a sincere and amazing novel, and it touches on controversial topics; something not many authors like to confront (par. 1). The novel and movie have similarities, so the reviewers of the movie had corresponding responses. Roger Ebert, the well-accredited movie critic, had a few comments to add concerning Nick Cassavetes development of the movie. Ebert gives the impression that the Fitzgeralds would be the perfect family if it weren’t for Kate’s condition (par. 3). They are like the model family, the mother that is a lawyer, the chief of the fire department as the father, beautiful home, and three

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Ender's Game Comparison

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “The way we win matters.” That clever quote was said by clever Ender, and I love it. If you haven't read ‘Ender’s Game’, then I strongly recommend it. Read the book first, because the book and the movie have plenty of differences and the movie would not make a lot of sense. Even though they have a lot of differences, they also have plenty of similarities. I hope you have the opportunity to read the incredible book and watch the different movie.…

    • 533 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    My Sister’s Keeper is the story of the Fitzgerald family. Sara and Brian Fitzgerald had two children, Jesse and Kate. When Kate was only 2 years old, they learned that she had leukemia. They immediately started chemotherapy treatments for Kate; however, her doctor, Dr. Chance, suggested that she would eventually need bone marrow transplants from a donor that was related to her.…

    • 1282 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She died only a few years after being diagnosed with breast cancer. However, we learned that she had the mutation BRCA and that lead to her sister being tested for the mutation. The results came back that she did have the mutation and she choose to have a double mastectomy. In both Tammy and her sisters case I feel like having the double mastectomy was the right decision. In Tammy’s case the cancer came back but that was after the fact that she was already diagnosed.…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the novel, Anna is introduced as the younger sister of Kate, who has been suffering from leukemia since her childhood. Due to these circumstances, Anna became the product of a preimplantation, as she was conceived solely to be a bone marrow match for Kate. So, ever since her birth, Anna has given up so much for her sister, “the first time being giving up cord blood as a new born,” having “lymphocytes drawn from [her], and when that stopped working, [taking] bone marrow for a transplant” (Picoult, 21). She has always been willing to do whatever it takes to keep Kate alive and healthy, however, this continual dependence others have on her has greatly impacted the way Anna perceives herself as an individual. Her existence has completely become revolved around Kate and her health conditions, that “[she] feels that if [she] really tried to figure out who [she] is without Kate in the equation, [she] wouldn’t like who [she] sees” (Picoult, 179).…

    • 1988 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    She was very optimistic about most things and then she was slammed with the initiate news that her daughter died and subsequently finding out that Phoebe was still alive. This really had a negative effect on Norah leading her to affairs and great depression. Caroline Gill also was a big part of the Henry household; she was the nurse that worked with Dr. Henry during the birthing of the twins and was instructed to take Phoebe to some strange place and ultimately ended up raising her as her own daughter. Gill was also responsible for telling Norah the truth about Phoebe. Paul Henry, son of Norah and David, is an established guitarist, but is affected the stress within the home because of his unknown sister.…

    • 2063 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Dr. Row Case Analysis

    • 1429 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Dr. Doe and Dr. Row are right when insisting on implementing the new procedures instead of doing nothing and letting the Barbie die. The hospital is not obligated to perform any new procedures if it cannot be tested first. Also, the hospital cannot perform any new procedures on Barbie without getting a consent from the parents. In the case, when a procedure is relatively new, the baby becomes a research subject since she will be the first person the procedure will be performed on, and the real outcomes are unknown. But, it seems like, after waiting for the donor and seeing the previous children die, the parents and relatives (the half-sister) are eager to try any treatment that could potentially save the Barbie’s life.…

    • 1429 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This has personally affected her and her friend Betsy. On page 107 Amelia and Lyddie were worried because Betsy had a continuous cough and that is unhealthy to find out later that she had TB. TB also known as Tuberculosis is a contagious and possibly life threatening disease. In the book, it states “Betsy I do wish you’d see Dr. Morris about that cough. Amelia’s voice came from the next bed” After this she had to go to the hospital and had to leave the factory for a while to heal.…

    • 673 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Anissa Ayala was diagnosed with leukemia at age 16, and as a result her parents chose to conceive another child, hoping she would eventually be a matching donor. In the real-life case, Anissa was a match for her sister, and when she was just over a year old, she provided Marissa with a transplant that has kept the elder sister 's cancer in remission since 1992. In Picoult 's novel, Sara and Brian Fitzgerald decide to conceive Anna in the hope that she will be a matching donor for Kate. They actively use genetic technology to select the best embryo to match Kate 's needs. As Anna explains, "I was born for a very specific purpose.…

    • 1495 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Vague Memories

    • 1605 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The beginning of my childhood I remember my mother being sick and trying to understand why she was so sick. As my mother received treatment my father worked on his law degree and working to pay for his kids and medical bills. After receiving multiple chemo injections my mother’s cancer spread even more. The memory of her lying on her bed with only her legs showing. I sat next to her trying to provide any comfort I could.…

    • 1605 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anytime one of the grandkids or great grandkids became ill, she came to our side to care and nurture us through our sickness. That is why we were surprised when she started falling and getting hurt, and not able to swallow hardly, we knew something was wrong. Her two daughters brought her to the hospital; the doctor diagnosed her with Progressive Supranuclear Palsy. This is a rare type of brain disorder that causes serious and progressive problems with control of gait and balance. Her daughters registered her at a nursing home here in Franklinton.…

    • 1123 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays