Gender Roles In The Movie Mulan

Improved Essays
What would lead someone to willingly change their gender just to be accepted? What kind of world do we live in that the discrimination of women leads them to desperately look for ways to assert themselves into this broken society? The movie Mulan is a great picture of how gender issues get in the way of letting people break away from the mold and become the person that they were meant to be. The movie, Mulan, brings up gender stereotypes, identity through gender, and gender inequality.
Mulan is based on an ancient Chinese legend. There was even harsher discrimination of women then than there is today. Any alternative gender roles were not acceptable and would result in death in this time period. Mulan, however, represents the “modern” woman, one who embodies certain traits of masculinity. The ways she tries to twist gender roles is seen through her attempts to disguise herself as a man. This rebelliousness is an extremely significant move in the context of the ancient Chinese culture.
…show more content…
This blatantly shows a large contrast to how females were expected to behave in ancient China. Mulan, throughout the movie, reminds herself that she needs to be “quiet and demure, graceful…” so she might meet the expectations of a perfect Chinese daughter. This theme parallels to today’s society as we have to constantly remind ourselves to act out our gender roles accordance to what society thinks is correct. This brings in the idea of gender stereotypes. Rebelling from this cookie cutter mold often results in undesirable consequences. In the case of Mulan, her rebellious behavior worries her father, who prays she will “impress the matchmaker” despite her tomboyish

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In the criticism, “Questioning Race and Gender Definitions”, Malini Schueller draws light to the expectations of Chinese women and how they are to be quiet and passive in nature. According to Schueller, “The initial story establishes the denial of expression women are condemned to in patriarchy and the cultural stranglehold the narrator must fight in order to express herself” (423). It is this cultural expectation that Kingston rebels against by telling her version of the unnamed woman. Schueller writes, “To articulate herself she must break through the numerous barriers that condemn her to voicelessness” (423). This liberation from the expectations placed on her has not only freed her but given her unnamed aunt a voice as well.…

    • 409 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This also shows that she is looking in the perspective of Fa Mu Lan. When she is comparing herself to something that is known for being a “man’s job”, but she says that they're not so…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    At the end of the journey the hero realizes they must live in the moment in order to be truly happy. If one excessively desires and/or fears, they restrain themselves from satisfying their current needs. However, the hero should live freely without worrying about death because the best part of human life is our mortality. Therefore, Kingston values herself and rejects certain Chinese traditions, loving on her own without a husband or children. She breaks stereotypes pushed by her family and becomes a contemporary Fa Mulan or “female avenger” of those who treat minorities without respect and dignity.…

    • 340 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Bethulian Heroism

    • 1548 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Ancient Heroism of Western and Eastern Culture According to Joseph Campbell’s Hero’s Journey, every hero shares the same typical adventure of the archetype. Despite this universal archetype, the heroes of each culture differ according to that culture’s values and beliefs. The river of history flows slowly; every country and every era has its own heroine who is acknowledged in their own ways. In one story of the Bible, a woman named Judith in ancient Israel made the ignominious defeat of the Assyrians; an army bent on world domination.…

    • 1548 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Heroic Journey Essay: Mulan Heroes have traits that define them, but those traits can resonate within the common person as well. For many, it takes major events for these certain traits to appear. Mulan is a girl who believes that her father is too old to be called into war, so she impersonates a man to get into the army to fight in his place, which creates a whole set of challenges.…

    • 1119 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Literarily, the stories of Mulan and Imperial Courtesan Yang also achieve this subversive nature when coming to the normalized version of the ideal woman. And, just like the historical story if Empress Wu, they show how the ordinary woman can be completely in line with the virtues and duties of her gender, but just take them to such a great extreme that they reveal the dissent or extraordinary circumstances for women at the time. In once instance, a woman “took up a mirror and a knife and cut off her nose” in an effort to refuse a roal suitor after her first husband died, and her extreme example of filial piety earned her the “the title of Exalted Conduct.” This was an instance of the author showing what would be exemplary, but not the norm in society at that time. Women most likely remarried after the death of their husbands, either at their parents urging or for themselves, and so the tale of this woman mutilating herself for chastity was spread far and wide.…

    • 1471 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Do right is a novel written by Lisa Sandlin who enhances the societal depiction of gender roles. Sandlin allows room for those same characters to challenge the stereotypes within their singular character arcs. Sandlin provides examples of women siphoning the power from the male-dominated culture of the time and setting. The feminist theory was created to shed light on the oppressive state of women in society. Theorist based their claims on the overt power of men and their domination of central societal structures.…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Kingston experiences gender discrimination at home, especially from her mother and father, who always favor the boys and not the girls. Kingston’s father is said to be so discriminatory that he “refused to eat pastries because he didn 't want to eat the dirt the women kneaded from between their fingers”(Kingston, 98). Chinese believed that woman were dirty, and second to men. The image of men juxtaposes the image of women. Men are thought of as “gifts from God”, while women are thought of as “maggots in the rice” (Kingston, 69-70).…

    • 1413 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Han Dynasty Women

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The writer demonstrated humility expected of women in the China society under the Han Dynasty as a small girl placed underneath the bed and given fragment pottery to play with and later publicize her birth to her predecessor (Nystorm 115.) The girl been placed lower than the bed would signify humility that should be expected of a woman. The pottery given to the girl means that she should not be idle and needs to be…

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Symbolism In Raymond's Run

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Both the characters Mulan and Squeaky are fighting the stereotype of girls, since they have someone in their daily lives who is disappointed in who they are and is trying to make them someone they are not. For example, in the movie, Mulan’s parents want Mulan to “look like a bride” and “bring honor to the family” while Squeaky’s mother wants Squeaky to “act like a girl” and wear a “white organdy dress with a big satin sash”. Both Mulan and Squeaky learn the power of confidence during their respective journeys. Mulan learns to show her true self in front of her family, no matter what they think, and Squeaky learns to slow down a little and enjoy life more. Though both of their lives may not be perfect, they both realize that being true to yourself earns respect in…

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I find the feeling toward women in this time quite contradicting. I believe that Yuan cherishes women while society tells him to dismiss them. A quote from this passage that supports my previous statement is, “If husbands and sons could only remember that their wives and mothers are helpless and suddenly repent, wouldn’t that be best?” (The Problem of Women, pg 215).…

    • 1321 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The narrative of a woman Throughout history war has been depicted as a man’s war. Rarely are women shown as equals to their male counterparts, or at least capable of defending themselves or their love ones. But the narrative of a weak woman is a false one, far from the truth that is shown in movies. In my opinion Pan’s Labyrinth is an example of how women are often depicted as weak and invisible during times of war.…

    • 1537 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gender is a socially constructed component that shapes the society that’s around us. From an early age, children are taught what a little boy is and what a little girl is and how each should act. Gender Identity is the knowledge that one knows if they are male or female. From an early age, children know many differences between themselves and their peers, although it might not be as defined in a way of actual biological differences. Mainly children see gender differences based on what roles they are exposed to.…

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kingston launches her memoir negotiating the story of her unnamed aunt, a woman dishonored and intentionally forgotten by her family after an illegitimate pregnancy. Kingston does not merely take the story at face value with the burden of shame accompanying her aunt’s memory, rather she retells it, exploring her aunt’s perspective. Kingston entertains the concept that her aunt, “looked at a man because she liked the way the hair was tucked behind the ears” (Kingston 8). This romanticized version of her aunt’s life remains enticing, relatable, and perhaps even probable had it occurred in the United States. If this scene was set in America, the anger of the family following the actions of an errant daughter would seem justified.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Feminist Analysis Of Mulan

    • 1150 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Mulan is the hero in her own story, and gains the affection of a man through her bravery and intelligence, not her beauty. Not only does the movie break the gender stereotype that the woman is the one being saved by the man, but also that a man can fall in love with a woman for more than just her beauty. These are all great messages that should be sent to young girls today, especially since they will grow up in a society where they are bombarded with messages telling them that they are worth little more than their appearance. Unfortunately, many of these same messages are embedded in the movie, giving very mixed messages, especially to a primarily young audience who does not yet have the ability to pick on more mature themes of irony and sarcasm. As a result of this, Mulan (1998) is receiving much more credit than is…

    • 1150 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays